해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 Club
가입하기
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
Now here's the thing that seems to be the 인기 topic now. Harry Potter 책 and the Twilight series. First I'd like to point out I do not call Twilight a "saga" is because well if 당신 look it up 당신 will know why. There's this whole big clash of the Twilight fanatics and the Harry Potter fanatics. I just need to vent out on how I feel about this situation.

Okay if 당신 사랑 Twilight than that's fine with me. I respect your opinions, but to me the book was terrible. 당신 can instantly tell that it was Meyer's first book she had ever written. I only hate the book, I don't hate 당신 for liking it neither will I say 당신 are stupid for liking it. Unless 당신 become negative towards me and say I did not read the 책 completely, that I'm a 쓴, 쓰라린 person, 또는 that I'm just jealous of Meyer. Etc, etc. I don't want to go on, cause I've been called many things; but fact is I just like Harry Potter. If 당신 want to argue with me that Twilight is better, than 당신 better have a legit argument.


Here's the thing I've been hearing about what Twilight 팬 had to say about Harry Potter. That there was no 사랑 in it at all and that Twilight had 더 많이 사랑 in it. Okay first let me define the term "love" 의해 wikipedia.

Wikipedia: "Love is any number of emotions and experiences related to a sense of strong affection and attachment. The word 사랑 can refer to a variety of different feelings, states, and attitudes, ranging from generic pleasure ("I loved that meal") to intense interpersonal attraction ("I 사랑 my boyfriend"). This diversity of uses and meanings, combined with the complexity of the feelings involved, makes 사랑 unusually difficult to consistently define, even compared to other emotional states."

So what they're say is 사랑 is not just couples' love. It means many things.

In Harry Potter there was a whole bunch of references of love. Harry's parent's 사랑 for him led to their deaths after trying to fend off Voldemort. Lily's, Harry's mother, 사랑 was the thing that helped him survive. Okay throughout the whole book, all his friends, he loved them all. That was what helped him eventually defeat the antagonist. Harry eventually 의해 the 4th book began to have romantic interests with a few female characters. So 당신 should understand what I mean.

Now in Twilight, Bella just noticed Edward because of his dazzling looks. She begins obsessing over this guy after just one glimpse. She knew nothing about him. When they do finally go out, she just keeps detailing how Edward looks. That's annoying, unnecessary details, just bores me to tears. It's amazing even how someone can finish the first book in a day. So Bella is just really focused on this guy's looks. She says nothing about Edward's personality, nothing. Um Edward is in fact pretty abusive and obsessed over Bella. Okay first for those girls out there. What kind of guy are 당신 looking for? If 당신 사랑 Twilight, probably just like Edward. No. 당신 do not want to get involved with someone like Edward. Edward forcefully drags Bella into his car, whatever, I forgot. Now women 당신 cannot let the guy take control of the relationship, neither should you. That's a bad relationship 당신 want to get out of quickly. But because of Edward's looks, Bella is blinded to that fact Edward is not right for her. This is not love, it's lust. Lust which she will get over soon and she will be asking, “What did I ever see in this guy?”

It's pretty amusing, but Bella's situation reminds me of this story in mythology, something like that. Well Bella was in fact the 사랑 interest of two guys of course. Edward and Jacob. Edward was this awesome hot guy to her. Jacob was not so much, but he was the actual good one. Now in the 3rd book Bella had two choices, Edward 또는 Jacob. She chose Edward which really hurt Jacob. Now I find this ridiculous. Jacob was simply to good for Bella. He stood 의해 her side in the 2nd book in her time of need, yet Bella had to go for the original man candy.
added by youknowit101
Source: tumblr
added by cassie-1-2-3
Source: EW
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
added by youknowit101
added by youknowit101
added by youknowit101
added by youknowit101
added by Gred_and_Forge
Over-all, the movie wasn't that bad. It stuck very, very close to the book (like, literally taking lines straight), with the exception of one 또는 two parts, so Breaking Dawn 팬 will absolutely 사랑 it. But, even if you're like me and hated Breaking Dawn, the movie was still pretty enjoyable. Definitely not unbearable. The effects were great, the 음악 was awesome, and Kristen kicked major ass. There was humor (because Charlie was there), there was drama, and there was even an awesome fight scene. (One-and-a-half, really.)

Spoiler-y Opinions
Liked:
-The one-liners.
    Charlie's...
continue reading...
1. Twilight has 더 많이 deph to their plot
2. The harry potter characters are mary-sues
3. The harry potteR characters are sparkly wizards
4. The characters in twilight matured while harry potter characters didnt
5. twilight has a theme park based on them
6. smeyer created a world while j k rowling created a book
7. twilight is aimed for people of all ages while harry potter is aimed for teenage girls
8. The war in harry potter was anti-climatic
9. twilight is about 사랑 and friendship while harry potter focuses on how to get a boyfriend
10. even daniel radcliffe says that he didnt like the character he...
continue reading...
posted by bessmarvin1
 Ginny vs Bella
Ginny vs Bella
I know that many of 당신 like Bella and many of 당신 hate her.But I 사랑 Ginny 더 많이 than her.In fact I hate Bella.She's such a Mary-Sue.

MY REASONS WHY BELLA SUCKS,COMPARED WITH GINNY.


Bella made us all realize that we cannot live if we do not have a man in our life.
Ginny made us realize that 당신 don't need a man in your life to live.

Bella was broken down when Edward left her.
Ginny fought for her family and 프렌즈 when Harry left her.

Bella always hurdles behind Edward when she had to face danger.
Ginny was nearly killed,but she did not back down.


Bella married just after she graduated out of school...
continue reading...
This is just a draft. We've been working on it, but we want to see how 당신 guys react to it so far. We both plan to explain each point further, but we want to know what else 당신 guys want to see addressed.




Youknowit101/Cassie-1-2-3 collaboration.

I asked a 질문 a bit 이전 asking what bothers 당신 about Bella’s pregnancy. We got some very interesting answers, thank you. We are now here to respond to the points made.
(I’m going to be using words like penis and orgasm, so if 당신 haven’t had a certain talk with your parents yet, 당신 probably shouldn’t read this)

First, we’ll address te...
continue reading...
Alright, so here I am again in the 기사 section. And with the strangest topic yet.

I'm extending an apology to youknowit101 for my numerous mild to severe transgressions of civility against him. I am also apologising for losing my temper yesterday and to be honest, I don't think the evening of December 12th 2010 on the Harry Potter vs. Twilight spot was very enjoyable.

Now, I am going to analyse this bloody debacle from start to current, and give 당신 my opinions afterwards.
I first encountered cassie-1-2-3 when someone worshipping the Holy Potatoe as a running gag told me she had levied "blasphemy"...
continue reading...
This 기사 isn't mine, this is just an 기사 I found on cracked.com (one of the best sites ever!). I agree with most of it, and on that note remember this is opion based, not fact. This is...*drumroll* if 당신 don't hate Twilight already, why 당신 SHOULD hate Twilight!

Click here to check out the article:
link

Enjoy, and no getting pissy (that's right I'm talking to 당신 Twilight 팬 girls) if you're going to post, DON'T POST unless 당신 write something I can understand. For example, THIS is something I can't understand:
omg liek edward iz liek sooo hawt an like sexxii an liek OMG umminess an u hateur iz liek tttly stoopid an homo an--
It's hurts too much to even finish the example! Anyway, again no haters and enjoy!
"Why compare Harry Potter and Twilight? Why would 당신 compare such different things?" are two 질문 this spot has come across often. And to be honest, it irritates the living crap out of me when people ask this.
The media plays a role in things and this 토론 is no different. On the cover of Breaking Dawn there is a quote from USA Today saying "Move over Harry Potter".(Newsflash, we're not going anywhere) Now, don't tell me that doesn't anger you/ 당신 wouldn't feel angry if 당신 were a Harry Potter fan. "Stephanie Meyer is the new J.K.Rowling." It really pisses me off when people say this...
continue reading...
posted by ilovereading
Like a lot of other Antis, I was at first a Twilight fan.

I got into 읽기 when I was 8 years old. First real book I have read was Harry Potter. Since than, I have read loads of fiction - romance, science fiction, fantasy, historical novels...
I liked some of them and disleked others. With years, I learnd to tell why and found my favorites - 판타지 novels.

My friend heard of upcoming Twilight movie, so she decided to read it. She recomended the book to me, so I said: "Heck, why not, it sounds interesing." I borrowed it from school 도서관, 라이브러리 and read it. I admit, I thought it was great, and I...
continue reading...
New Moon Review

“…she [Stephanie Meyer] can’t write worth a darn. She’s not very good…” ~ Stephen King

And frankly, I agree. Stephanie Meyer, author of the Twilight series, has gotten her share of criticism, but also many undeserved raving fans. I’m going to take a closer look at her 초 book in this series, New Moon.
New Moon Is quite possibly the just all-around worst book in the series, and I will tell 당신 why.

One, Edward leaves Bella, and she turns into a zombie-like wreck. She abandons all of her friends, instead focusing what little personality she has on hatred for Edward...
continue reading...
added by youknowit101
Source: tumblr
added by youknowit101