해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 Club
가입하기
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by hpotterforever7
This is an 기사 that will clear some things that have been used in arguments between Harry Potter and Twilight.

The first thing I would like to clear up is Lily Potter's protection to Harry. Now, I know some have said that it doesn't make sense because people die to protect others. For example, in the seventh book, Voldemort goes tothat family to ask for Gregorovich, but the women said he wasn't there. Voldemort raised his wand, ready to kill her, and then her kids came running out. She shielded them, and died, but then why did they die too? This doesn't work because the women didn't have a choice to live. She was going to killed 의해 Voldemort anyway. This is not the case with Lily Potter. Because Severus Snape asked Voldemort to spare Lily, so Lily had a chance to escape from Death. But she didn't. That's why Harry survived.

This happens once 더 많이 throughout the series, and it is in the 7th book when Harry knows he must meet Voldemort in the Forest where he will be killed. Same concept, he had the chance to not go, but he decides to die, to save others, and that is 사랑 at it's deepest.

Another thing that bothers me is that people think Harry Potter is bad because it uses swear words. Let me set straight that the only two times that they have used a serious bad word (and no, bloody doesn't count) was when Bellatrix almost killed Molly's daughter! How would 당신 react if one of your kid's was about to be killed? No, I don't think you'd stop to think: Don't swear! The other time was when Ron punched Malfoy under the invisibility 망토, 망 토 and said "that's the 초 time we saved you, 당신 two-faced bastard!" The two swear words that were used were both used in extreme situations, so I think that they were acceptable.

But with Twilight, they use smaller swear words often, like damn, and hell, so it should be ok. One thing that bothers me about Twilight is that Stephenie Meyer is too scared to kill off any of the main characters. I just think it's kind of unrealistic. I think the message from Harry Potter is that death is unfair and that it its coming for all of us, no matter what we can do. The important thing is, that they died fighting for what they believe in! And that's honour!
posted by SpeedyGonzalez
I, SpeedyGonzalez did NOT write this. I just merely copyed and pasted it.

Ah, yes, Stephenie Meyer, author of the Twilight series. My opinion of her, from the way that she has presented herself to the public in interviews and such, is that she is a whiny, self absorbed woman with the mind of a 13 년 old. She can't deal with criticism because it hurts her delicate little feelings, and believes that she is an amazing writer and that her story and characters are somehow superior to those seen in the works of people such as Jane Austen and William Shakespeare. Here's one statement that shows that...
continue reading...
So Harry Potter is MUCH better than some stupid book about wimpy girls and sparkly fairies. First off:
ALL the Twilight people are UGLY! I mean seriously, Taylor Lautners muscles are gross and he has ugly man-boobs. He looks like a creep on steroids. and Robert Pattison looks like a bum, and Kristen looks like a drug aggict as Bella. I mean, EW! Who wants to watch a movie with eyesores like them? Harry Potter is WAY better, I mean we have HOT guys, and the girls aren't half bad either! I mean. we have Lucius, Draco, Sirius, and Snape to say the LEAST! Plus like a zillion other eye-candy dudes!...
continue reading...
1. It has better writing.
2. It's plotline is better.
3. I'd rather read a book about a teenage boy going to a wizardry school and fighting a dark sorceror than one about a ditzy girl who's way too obsessed with her sparkly boyfriend.
4. The characters are 더 많이 relateable.
5. J.K. Rowling is not afraid to kill off plenty of good guys.
6. Most of the characters' educations actually matter to them.
7. It doesn't have thousands of rabid fangirls.
8. The characters are 더 많이 three-dimensional.
9. It stays true to mythology.
10. It has 더 많이 types of 사랑 in it, not just romantic and sexual 사랑 (or should...
continue reading...
 The Golden Trio
The Golden Trio
I'll Start with Harry Potter:

1.The Characters are 더 많이 likeable.
4.Even the villans are likeable.
3.You can related to at least one of the likeable characters.
4.Harry Potter has Bellatrix Lestrange where vas Twilight only has Isabella Swan.
5.The villans actually seem thretning unlike the Volturi.
6.The cast seems friendlier.
7.The relatonships in Harry Potter are taken one step at a time.
8.Harry Potter is 더 많이 realistic; the characters each have a flaw as well as some good traits
9.Harry Potter shows real life issues such as; the loss of someone dear to you, child neglect, (the dursleys) and raceism....
continue reading...
Before 당신 start reading, I'd like to say this is my personal opinion. Maybe I'm wrong. If I am, I'd appreciate 당신 don't get mad because I don't like fighting. It wasn't meant to be rude, mean 또는 hurtfull to anybody.

For me Twilight was too easy to read. I could predict what would happen and the plot was too easy. The thing is, the plot isn't bad. 뱀파이어 exist, that's cool. 당신 know one, yes, very cool. But the way Stephenie Meyer introduces it, how she developed her characters, how she modeled the vampire species, that is where Twilight gets people annoyed. It represent the iceburg that...
continue reading...
I thought this would be fun!Guess what!?What if I had an interview with J.K. Rowling and Stephanie Meyer together!This is the fake interview with me,J.K. Rowling,and Stephanie Meyer:
----------------------
Me:Welcome,Stephanie.Welcome,J.K.
Rowling:Hello.
Meyer:Hi.
M:Are 당신 ready for the interview?
R:Yeah,Stephanie.
Stephanie:Yes.
M:Ok,since 당신 both write fiction-how did 당신 come up with the books?
S.M.:It was a dream,the meadow scene and I woke up and I'm like,"How did they get their?How did they fall in love?WHat would happen,next?"I jumped out of 침대 and sat down and started writing.Going,"I can't...
continue reading...
posted by GemonkDruid
First, let me get this straight: I'm not a 팬 of Twilight. In fact, I hate it. But I can see why everyone's so hyped up about it.

You see, I've recently been introduced to a new theory- The Twelve-Year-Old girl theory. It's mostly used in music, like for 인기 아이콘 like Hannah Montana, Justin Bieber, the Jonas Brothers, but Twilight also fits into this catagory.

What is the Twelve-Year-Old girl theory, 당신 might ask? Well, let's just look at people at the age of twelve first. When 당신 turn twelve, you're on the thin line between childhood and the teen years. You're young and vulnerable,...
continue reading...
This is an answer to a 질문 게시됨 의해 coolbek. If 당신 read it, please feel free to provide constructive criticism. However, please don't post hateful 코멘트 without backing up your opinion - it just makes 당신 look foolish.

These are my reasons as to why people like Harry Potter 더 많이 than Edward Cullen:

1. Harry has flaws - anger, sometimes arrogance and a few more. These flaws make Harry a character with depth, and also a character that we can relate to. Nobody can be perfect in the real world – our flaws are what make us human. The saying “Perfection…is apt to be dull” explains...
continue reading...
Alright,I don't know where to begin,I guess I already begin.

I can't believe I've taken months to conclude that I was being something humiliating,nasty and dumb for those past months.I loved Harry Potter with all my heart,its the very first novel I would not eat to have it.I used to like Twilight too when I watched the movie in the first place.

However,its pretty obnoxious when media started to compare my most 가장 좋아하는 book with a simple 사랑 story like Twilight-no offenses,just how I used to think.That's why I joined this site,to prove that all the "move on Harry Potter.." things was wrong.
'Harry...
continue reading...
posted by Sophia21
Ah well, in the name of justice now I will take it a little bit against Harry Potter. For starters I will only mention consistency errors 또는 plot mistakes. Scientific and lore mistakes will be included later. HEY! They are 7 very long books, and unlike Twilight were mistakes were easy to spot amongst the constant lovey-dovey of Bella and Edward, Harry Potter has a lot of information going around. Now then.

1)Where did Voldemort stick his wand?
Explanation: Yeah the 제목 doesn't give a very nice image. But seriously. Voldemort went on a solo mission to kill the Potters and their baby. Due to...
continue reading...
Publishers Weekly-"After her transformation into a vampire, it's almost impossible to identify with her in Breaking Dawn"

Lilah Lohr of the Chicago Tribune-"Bella's character, compared to the Quileute wolves, is less satisfying"

Kirkus Reviews-"Bella's appeal is based on magic rather than character, but her and Edward's portrayal of dangerous 연인들 hits the spot"
"Bella's personality is flat and obsessive"

Laura Miller of salon.com-"In regards of Edward and Bella, neither of them has much personality to speak of"

Jennifer Reese of Entertainment Weekly-"You may wish she had loftier goals and a mind...
continue reading...
NOTE: This interview is written as if Bella is still human. Think after Eclipse but before Breaking Dawn. And I don't mean to offend Twilight 팬 with any of the 질문 that Rita asks Bella in this article, based on Rita's personality in the books, I'm assuming she'd ask awkward questions.

Me Myself and I
By Rita Skeeter

Today's interview is with 인기 판타지 book character, Bella Swan. Captivating readers in Twilight, read on as I interview Bella, and see if there's 더 많이 to her than just an obsession with Edward!

*The door opens, and in walks Bella......with Edward.*

Bella Swan: Can...
continue reading...
Kristen Stewart screen test interview with W magazine about filming Breaking Dawn
video
twilight
크리스틴 스튜어트
interview
w magazine
브레이킹 던
filming
added by bri-marie
video
해리 포터
팬 video
clips
posted by june13
We all been asking since this culb stared who would win the fight Harry Potter 또는 Edward Cullen. First it mattereds if Harry has is wand wish it would come avange of him in a way and if Edward had Bella 또는 not she would come a distracing to him lets start.
Harry has is wand and Edward does not have Bella. But Edward can read his man but since he does not know what the spells do it will not help at all and Edward has got speed that will help him out alot becouse he can get a way from the spell so they both got disavanges and avanges so it just may be a tie
added by lalaland21
(i have edited this 기사 so there r no spelling mistakes :) )

Hello everyone, today I'm going to tell 당신 why Twilight is a BILLION times better than the Harry Potter. Here are some reasons.

1. First, they are no swear words!! I mean I heard in Hp they is swearing, like "h*ll" and "b*tch" I mean little kids are 읽기 that!! Like 7 and 8 years olds!! It's crazy!!!111 In Twilight, there is no swearing beacuse it is a child 안전한, 안전 book :)

2. HP is for kids only!! I mean Twilight is for all ages!!! I haven't read HP but I know only little kids read it!! Twilight is for everyone, my 10 년 old...
continue reading...
posted by PotterForever
Severus Snape is without a dought the deepest most complex character in Harry Potter. His relationship with Harry was quite complicated in the sense that he had a very difficult past with both Harry's parents. On the one hand he was deeply in 사랑 with his mother, but on the other hand he absolutaly LOATHED his father. This resulted in the awkward difficult relationship the two of them had throught the books. Snape cared about Harry, but only to the point where he wanted to make sure his physical being was protected, and that he was alive and well. He cared about this, because his 사랑 for...
continue reading...
added by KateKicksAss