Killing people is wrong: opinion 또는 fact?

*
*Murder
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
Is murder wrong.
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
Why is this an answer instead of a pick?
Sappp posted over a year ago
*
Because I want people to state their opinion and then give examples and arguments to back it up. But I actually didn't think about making it a pick question. I'll do that,
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
 emilyroxx posted over a year ago
next question »

토론 답변

nene72 said:
I'm going to say fact. The way I see it we wouldn't have so many different religions and cultures throughout history labelling it as something wrong if it hadn't had a mostly negative impact on their society to start with.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
but there are certain cultures that dont think it as wrong
alisonfaith297 posted over a year ago
*
Which cultures?
nene72 posted over a year ago
*
^ nazis.
pandawinx posted over a year ago
*
Just because they killed people didn't mean they didn't think it was wrong to kill. It just means they were willing to kill even though it was the wrong thing to do. They knew what they were doing was wrong. That's why they tried to hide their concentation capms. That's why there are so many nazy supporters who still try to deny the holocaust ever happened. They have no acceptable reasons to excuse their actions during their reign.
nene72 posted over a year ago
Twilight_Dream said:
In most cases I think it is. But for certain things like self defense, it can be necessary.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Summer_Leanne said:
In Western cultures 또는 cultures that have been influenced 의해 the west, it is somewhat an opinion that has become "fact" through widespread agreement with this belief; many 인기 belief systems, mainly Christianity, have made it an accepted fact. The Ten Commandments, which stem from the Bible's book of Exodus, is often referred to as the moral code of Western Civilization. One of the commandments specifically states that people are not to kill others. The east, like China and Pakistan, may not always agree with this, because the Ten Commandments are the morals of the West, not specifically the East. Meaning, since 기독교 is less prevalent in those countries, the Westernized view of murder isn't always accepted there. So, to us Westerners, it's fact, but to others in Asia, it may not always be classified as fact. (I think 당신 meant murder; self-defense cases that end in the death of another is seen as okay, if the person was harmful.)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Very true, I'll fix that.
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
Yes, the Ten Commandments says "murder" is wrong, but in self defence, it is justified.
MusicMaker95 posted over a year ago
*
How did this stem into religion? First of all, I don't really think ANY religion condones murder positively, if it does that religion is obviously not enforced 의해 law officials because I doubt that murder is legal in ANY country. If I am wrong, please correct me.
darkkhorn19 posted over a year ago
bri-marie said:
Opinion. There are times where it's necessary (kill 또는 be killed/defence). Not everyone thinks it's "wrong" to kill people like Hitler 또는 Osama, 또는 people who have been sentenced to the death penalty in general.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
True. I agree.
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
MusicMaker95 said:
I believe the killing of the INNOCENT is wrong, but if 1.) 당신 have taken the life of an innocent person, yours is forefeit, 2.) taking the life of another in self defense is not wrong, 3.) war. If 당신 have 또는 are helping in the killing of innocent people, like those who planned and carried out 9/11, 당신 deserve to die. And any sniper/general soldier who kills such a person is not a murderer.
select as best answer
 I believe the killing of the INNOCENT is wrong, but if 1.) 당신 have taken the life of an innocent person, yours is forefeit, 2.) taking the life of another in self defense is not wrong, 3.) war. If 당신 have 또는 are helping in the killing of innocent people, like those who planned and carried out 9/11, 당신 deserve to die. And any sniper/general soldier who kills such a person is not a murderer.
posted over a year ago 
*
That wasn't really the question...
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
I was merely clarifying what IS right. Anyone can say killing is wrong, it's deciding what form of it is not wrong.
MusicMaker95 posted over a year ago
*
Agreed, Szayel, but there are some people who dosn't feel any remorse...
Yumichika posted over a year ago
alisonfaith297 said:
well, i definitely think it a matter of culture. i mean if 당신 talk about killing someone in a police raid as self defense then is a right think to most people and i think everyone agrees on this (i not quote sure but i think so) even though they took a life it was self defense and i think most are on the same page which means in this case it is a fact. but on the other when 당신 actually murder someone, then also obviously it is a fact that it is wrong. but when the person is executed, the fact of right and wrong becomes an opinion. as depending on culture and beliefs, it differs.
therefore, it depends on what your beliefs are of what 당신 define killing as even.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
ThePrincesTale said:
Opinion.
당신 can't say that it is a cold, hard fact, because morality isn't fact. Morality is something humans have devised- morality is 더 많이 of an idea.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
darkkhorn19 said:
Opinion.

Murder is necessary to deplete the population, without murder, Earth will be overpopulated. I'm not saying that killing is good, I believe that committing murder is inhumane, murder is important for population control.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Interesting...I've never thought if it that way, but I guess you're right.
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
O_o as a doctor, i must say that is very EVIL!
Szayelapporro posted over a year ago
*
but death is an inevitability of life. either ways without murder people will still die. so your reasoning escapes me.
alisonfaith297 posted over a year ago
*
^ 당신 wouldn't be saying that if 당신 were murdered for "population control"
pandawinx posted over a year ago
Szayelapporro said:
Fact. Whether 당신 know it 또는 not.....it is. It would be on ANY human beings concience if they ever killed another. Why do 당신 think that is? Why do we have a concience in the first place? The answer is to tell us if we are wrong to be doing something. *now i am not meaning to preach 또는 anything like that* but God is the ONLY one to decide if a person lives 또는 if he dies and ANYONE who tries to take that position....yes even police, FBI, judges, ect......are sinning.


Just my honest to goodness opinion.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
...So 당신 said that it's a fact that murder is wrong, stated your resoning, and then ended it saying that it was your "honest to goodness opinion." That's contradicting yourself.
emilyroxx posted over a year ago
*
lols true.
alisonfaith297 posted over a year ago
eman6044 said:
"Murder is wrong" is clearly an opinion. Whether everyone agrees it is wrong 또는 not makes no difference. If everyone agreed that blue is the best color, it is still an opinion.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »