이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 질문

From these 2 series whose 팬 are 더 많이 hard to handle?

Im asking 당신 guys,because im sort of torn between.
For example Twilight 팬 focus alot on what 또는 who they like and are always hard to make them change they're mind no matter how hard 당신 try,they will find something good no matter what 당신 would say.
...
for instance HP 팬 (only refeering to the 팬 on this spot,because I don't know about the other spots)
Tend to give full 답변 and explications which is just so hard to come with a comeback!

So ...I find myself needed to ask you(:


 nessienjake posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 대 트와일라잇  최고의 답변

XDRoseLuvsHP said:
Well, I can almost guarantee that most of the HP 팬 will say Twilight 팬 are harder to deal with, while most Twilight 팬 will say that HP 팬 are harder to deal with.

In real life, Twilight 팬 (and I mean real Twihards here) can be rather... erm... obnoxious. They flip out if someone criticizes Twilight in the slightest. I've heard stories where people even say that they like Twilight, but they don't 사랑 it, and they've been attacked 의해 Twilight fans. They also do not argue their point thoroughly. I guess it's hard to, with something like Twilight, but I really think that they should be able to do better than "EDWARD IS HOT" 또는 "UR JUST JEALOUS".

However, I do know that we HP 팬 can be... very thorough about making our point. We feel very protective about HP (as I'm sure Twilight 팬 do), but we really explain thoroughly. I guess that can be rather disheartening for those who 사랑 Twilight. I also do admit that we can be kind of mean sometimes when defending HP 또는 explaining why we don't like Twilight (sometimes to the point where we are harshly insulting it).

But I have to say that I personally think that Twilight 팬 are harder to handle. (But not all of you! I'm only talking about Twihards here, not the sane fans!)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah...at some point the twilight 팬 really are harder to handle but HP 팬 can exxagerate a bit in 'defending' :)
nessienjake posted over a year ago
*
Rose, I agree with you. But 당신 know, HP contains SO much that it's impossible not to be thorough, so we dont leave anything out of our arguement. It just shows how amazing HP really is.
MissDK posted over a year ago
*
I am agreeing with MissDK
Galesgirl posted over a year ago
next question »

답변

MissVictoire said:
I think, being a Harry Potter fan(atic) and an anti-Tw*l*ghter, that Twilight 팬 are harder to deal with, simply based on experience (I mentioned what I was a 팬 of to make sure it was clear). They seem to be .... personally insulted when anyone insults Twilight, and that's when the attacks start. I will admit that most Harry Potter 팬 dislike most (rabid) Twilight 팬 on principle, like Gryffindors to Slytherins 또는 (because I'm being fair here and have read the books) 뱀파이어 and 늑대인간 (at least in Twilight). But we don't take it as a personal offense when someone insults Harry Potter, we just want 당신 to, in our minds, see sense. Anyone will get upset 또는 at the very least confused as to why someone doesn't like their preferred series. But it's when people get crazy and obnoxious about it that we fight back. And from my personal experience, as well as others of my fandom, that seems to happen 더 많이 with the Twilighters.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly right. We spend so much time explaining ourselves to make Twilight 팬 see sense... and to have come backs like 'Well, Twilight has hotter guys!' is just frustrating. I would 사랑 to actually see a decent 토론 between a Twilight 팬 and a HP fan.
Kylie90210 posted over a year ago
*
Thanks, and wouldn't that be fun to watch? :)
MissVictoire posted over a year ago
*
definatly I agree with 당신 guys too, we just want people to understand how WE see it and WHY we think it is better
Galesgirl posted over a year ago
LadyLilith said:
I would say the Twilight fans, because most HP 팬 will leave 당신 alone (or even support you) if you're polite and make good points. 또는 if you're just nice, whichever.

But naturally I only think badly of the hardcore, retarded Twilight fans. I have great respect for Twilighters in general. They're just as decent as the sane HP fans, but if we had to take all of the 팬 into consideration...Twilight has it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MadamOcta13 said:
Twilight of course! I don't get how anyone can stand screaming, crazy, obsessive teenage girls-and worse-their MOMS!!!!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
VampiresRevenge said:
Ok, while I agree that some Twilight 팬 can be really, and I mean really, hard to handle, not all of them are. It's really not nice to generalize and stereotype all Twilight 팬 into incoherent 13-year-olds 또는 Twilight moms. And I'm sure there are many, many Harry Potter 팬 that could fall into those same categories. Most of the Twilight 팬 are able to give a full 설명 of what they are trying to say, though it is mainly the sane ones. But some Harry Potter 팬 who spend most of their time hating on Twilight 팬 try to give long descriptions just to try to sound smarter than the Twilight fans. And it really is the Harry Potter fans, mostly, who try to put down the Twilight 팬 to make them feel better. Some of them can be really hateful when it comes to the topic of Harry Potter vs. Twilight, especially when they attack the 팬 specifically. There are so many Twilight hate clubs that support Harry Potter, while I have never seen a Harry Potter hate club run 의해 Twilight fans. Maybe I haven't looked hard enough, I don't know.

On the topic of Twilight 팬 being really defensive, 당신 have to be defensive when 당신 are being attacked over and over again for "Stephanie Mayer not being able to write" 또는 "having stupid preteen fans." We get it. 당신 can think as Harry Potter 팬 being on the offense and Twilight 팬 being on the defense. Whenever Harry Potter gets hated on, the 팬 flip out, too. It's just that 더 많이 people focus on defensive Twilight 팬 more, because they get hated on way, way 더 많이 than the Harry Potter fans.

I really just don't get why we can't all get along. Being a 팬 of both, I hate seeing them being pitted against each other all of the time, when all they really have in common is that they are 판타지 책 that young people read. If J.K. Rowling and Stephanie Meyer don't fight why do the fans?

Answering the question, though, haha, for me, some Twilight 팬 can be hard to handle and some Harry Potter 팬 can be hard to handle. I can't really compare the two.

(Oh, and I hope no one takes offense to any of what I said, because I am really not trying to be offensive, I just wanted to explain how I see things.)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Now that's a very short answer xD
nessienjake posted over a year ago
*
and that eally just don't get why we can't all get along. Being a 팬 of both, I hate seeing them being pitted against each other all of the time, when all they really have in common is that they are 판타지 책 that young people read. If J.K. Rowling and Stephanie Meyer don't fight why do the fans?
nessienjake posted over a year ago
*
Haha, good. Because I feel like a hippie a lot when I came into this spot. I really just want everyone to get along. :)
VampiresRevenge posted over a year ago
BellatrixCissy said:
Twilight 팬 totally. As i am a 팬 i am not that crazy over it like for example i wouldn't go to a premere fpr twilight and just be like screaming omg edward nor would i do so screaming omg hp at one for hp but most twilight 팬 are too crazy take it down a few
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Alright, this is slightly funny... Why would 당신 have the names of two Harry Potter characters (very evil ones at that) and then use Aro as your avatar? 당신 can't like both very much, they're completely different.
MissVictoire posted over a year ago
shankardevi said:
My opinion is twilight fans.... I think that they are a bit narrow minded....No offense please..
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
same here:)
nessienjake posted over a year ago
*
don't worry,no offense taken:)
R33n33sm3 posted over a year ago
jedigal1990 said:
i definitly think its twilight 팬 especially the obsessed ones because they don't see that not everyone likes twilight and they are so narrowed minded they think they can post it everywhere including spots that it doesn't belong in and then get really upset that others don't like it in my opinon alot of them are to protective over thier precious twilight
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »