I'm confused about Philip and Syrena...

I'm quite sure Syrena never ate Phillip...
Here's my theory (it's just a theory, but you'll see, it makes sense)

1-When Syrena gets a "totally human" form after her water cage broke down, Black Beard forces her to walk but she can't, Phillip kneels beside her and says:
"Put your arms around me."
She answers:
"I do not ask for help!"
He then replies:
"But 당신 need it."
And then only, she puts her arm around Phillip' shoulders...

That's the first part of my theory. Phillip helps Syrena even if she never ask for any help.

In my idea, the end of the movie is just the "mirror-scene" of the other one... Now Phillip needs help. Syrena arrives and says she can heal him "if he asks to"... but he only asks her to forgive him (so, he also doesn't ask for help, even if he REALLY needs it). She then kisses him (and it's been said ealier in the movie that a 키스 from a mermaid protects from drowning) and drags him to a mysterious somewhere... She has to save him!

...and I don't say that because I want it, I'm quite a big cinema fan, and it always works that way: when something happens in one way, it will happen in the other way.

For example, in the old 별, 스타 Wars trilogy, when Han Solo is about to be 겨울왕국 in carbon, Leia says "I 사랑 you", and he answer "I know", in the 다음 movie, when Leia and Han are threatned 의해 Storm troopers at the bunker's door, Leia shows Han the gun she hided all that time... WHAT ARE THEY SAYING? Han:"I 사랑 you", and Leia:"I know"...

See? It's ALWAYS working that way!

I have read some 책 about the teen Jack :DD And the 2nd book was about sirens-mermaids.It tells that that there is under water cave where all the mermaids-sirens is protecting their treasures and also lives there.So I think that Syrena got Philip there.

Syrena saved Philp life because in the movie someone said if 당신 키스 a mermaid 당신 can live under water .

well i think she did save him because in the scene were the pirates were baits for the mermaids, one of the pirates said that if 당신 were kissed 의해 a mermaid 당신 will never drowned. Serena kissed Phillip because he couldnt live on ground anymore because of his wound, so serena decided to 키스 Phillip because she loves him and that its the only way to save him, so they lived happily ever after underwater lol

When she kissed him she gave him the ability to breath under water

She obviously saved him from dying because Barbossa stabbed him and threw him in a ditch near a puddle thingy.She dragged him under and saved him....I think.