What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

트와일라잇 시리즈 For those who have read Breaking Dawn, How did 당신 feel about the book?

54 fans picked:
LOVED IT!
LOVED IT!
   67%
mixed emotions!!
mixed emotions!!
   17%
(added by twilightfan22)
Loved it and hated it but in the end I was ok.
Loved it and hated it but in the end I was ok.
   7%
i was really dissapointed but i didn&# 39; t hate it!
i was really dissapointed but i didn't hate it!
   6%
(added by brucas4ever)
HATED IT!
HATED IT!
   4%
I was so mad I couldn&# 39; t finish reading.
I was so mad I couldn't finish reading.
no votes yet
 jupiterfaerie posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

18 comments

user photo
HATED IT!
kitkat211 picked HATED IT!:
Sorry, I'm just being honest!! The baby thing didn't bug me, the imprinting on the baby and OOC is what got me! It read like a fanfiction!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
Vampire-gal picked LOVED IT!:
I can see everyone's point with the whole different view to the book but i hope that no one is hating Stephenie Meyer now. If someone doesn't like it I hope they can be mature about it, and if someone else liked it, I'd hope that they'd not hate others because they have different views.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
CullenCult picked LOVED IT!:
I LOVED IT ALL!!! Eeven the part inJacob's POV!! lol and kitkat211... what does OOC mean?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
HATED IT!
kitkat211 picked HATED IT!:
out of character! Also who the hell is "Jazz?" I know that is NOT jaspers nickname! This book was just a mess! Jacob POV was the worst part of the book. You and I both know that I am not the only one who hates this book. Go to Amazon.com and see how many people "LOVED" this book. I am so glad that this the final book. (with the exception of Midnight Sun)I don't also don't want to hear a love story between the pedafile warewolf and his child bride.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
kctjohnson picked LOVED IT!:
Pedophile werewolf? Clearly the concept of imprinting is lost on you. That's not how it is (remember about a "mother seeing her child for the first time"? About a "blind man seeing the sun for the first time"? It's not always about romance, and with Jake and Nessie, that's not how it is - not right now at least). And speaking of pedophile, many actually saw Edward with Bella that way in the beginning.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
HATED IT!
kitkat211 picked HATED IT!:
Bella wasn't a baby!! She also wasn't forced to love someone. I guess the "imprinting" concept has been lost on me, because I will NEVER understand people thinking it okay to imprint on a baby. Also I all about choosing to love someone, not being forced to.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
ShamrockMoon picked LOVED IT!:
Jacob is not a pedophile! If he is then so is Edward! Edward is an old-ass vampire, Bella was a minor! Imprinting is about love and doing whatever the object of your love needs at that stage in their life. Just like Claire and Quil! He plays with her, he babysits her, he is devoted to her. The wolves don't age until they're done being *wolfy* and Nessie will catch up in age to Jacob. Meanwhile, he is her protector, her playmate, her friend and hopelessly devoted...but he doesn't sit in the forest having sexual fantasies about her as a child. kitkat211, the JAZZ thing also made me ROFL, I thought it was reaching a bit.

All in all, I thought the book to be *amazing*!!!!! I loved that Edward and Jacob were able to get over their differences and also to find that they're not mortal enemies *shapeshifter* :) And now that I've read the book, I FINALLY *get* the cover! I could go on and on forever because I loved the book. I also thought that it seemed *different* but she had to do that, we couldn't expect Bella to be all clumsy as a vampire! I was mourning a little because even while she was still human, Bella seemed *different* and more sure of herself, but I think SM just did that to prepare us for a Bella that could save the day, instead of always ruining it. It was just as captivating as the others, weaved itself into my dreams and was all I could think about while I was awake, until I finished it. And then I cried like a baby when it was over. My husband thinks I'm crazy. :) By the way, I'm a thirty year old woman with a two year old daughter (and some sons!) and I didn't find Jacob imprinting on Renesmee at all disturbing...and trust me, I'm superiorly overprotective of my own daughter (and sons!) and I didn't find this pedophiley at all! :)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
mixed emotio- ns!!
tubby2002 picked mixed emotions!!:
I really did like the book but it was so different from the other ones in the series. At first I was a little upset that Bella got pregnant but it kinda grew on me. So yea, I have mixed emotions on the book but I definitly don't hate it!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
CullenCult picked LOVED IT!:
DANG kitkat211... you really hated the book, and Jacob is NOT a pedafile! If you reread Jacob's discription about imprinting, there is nothing ROMANTIC about his, and Reneeseme's (???) relationship.. it's like Quil and Claire... and Nessie isn't forced to love Jacob, she doesn't HAVE to do anything... I thought the Jazz thing, was a tad strange, but kinda cute. It could grow on you if you let it... and I'm pretty sure you are one of the few that didn't like it... look at the results, sorry if that offends you, but yeah....
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
Wordwok picked LOVED IT!:
But, honestly when I started reading Book 1 I wasn't too into it. By the end of Book 1 and the transition into Book 2 I was like WOAH! I couldn't hate it AT ALL from that part on. It just made me love Jacob alot more! I loved BD. And I'm totally sad to see it end... Until Midnight Sun! XD
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
kctjohnson picked LOVED IT!:
Seriously kitkat. If a 100+ year old man is romantically interested in a 17 year old, that's considered a pedophile, especially since 17 is not legal age in the US. However, we like to overlook that in Twilight because then we wouldn't be able to enjoy the romance *LOL* Also, Nessie is not being forced to love Jacob back. If you read the explanations of imprinting again in Eclipse, Nessie would have complete freedom to chose who she wants to be with. The only one being "forced" in this scenario, if you think about it, is Jacob (and all the other werewolves who've imprinted). They all seem to be happy so I don't see why one should rain on their happiness.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
mixed emotio- ns!!
theslipperfit picked mixed emotions!!:
how could people say that its OOC? they are stephenies characters, she is the one who knows how they are, she created them. so if anyone knows how they act it would be here.

and people are getting a little too out of control about the imprinting thing. i mean, quil imprinted on a 2 year old and no one seems to be complaining about that. its just because for reasons that escape me, people hate jacob and are making him imprinting a reason to hate him more.

its stupid!

the book was great, everyone got what they deserved.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
HATED IT!
kitkat211 picked HATED IT!:
CullenCult...I'm not the only one who HATES this book!!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
mixed emotio- ns!!
Sweetiecheeks picked mixed emotions!!:
When I first read about the baby I was upset because her love for Edward seemed to die!! :( But after a while I could still see it there. This book was so cool, and it made me actually like Jacob! I completely enjoyed reading his part!

Not only that but I love Renesmee's name! (hate the nickname though) I do agree that it sort of reads like a fanfic. For I read one recently and it sounded...identical in some ways...and this person wrote the fanfic before she even read New Moon!

But the ending is TO DIE FOR!! I was blissfully happy!! I don't feel sad Bella's story is over, because it was closed beautifully! And I really hope these other stories SM is talking about are of Jacob and Renesmee when they are older! (I mean when SHE is older!)

But I have to admit...when Edward called Jacob his SON...i was a little creeped out! lol.

I also agree with tubby2002.

Can't wait for Midnight Sun!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
mixed emotio- ns!!
mbally500 picked mixed emotions!!:
i thought it was perfect
it had everything i wanted in it, i just wish there was more

there still midnight sun though

i will just have to be really patient
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
CullenCult picked LOVED IT!:
kitkat211 I didn't say that you were the only one.. I said that you were one of the few who do, okay?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Loved it and hated it but in...
kateliness2 picked Loved it and hated it but in the end I was ok.:
I liked it and didn't like it. The pregnancy felt... wrong. Just like it was forced into the plot and became a way for everyone to get along. Not natural. Forced.

Bella/Edward's relationship got less creepy.

I'm probably the only one who didn't like Nessie too much.

I'm a sucker for a happy ending though, so it's okay with me.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
LOVED IT!
DramaGeek picked LOVED IT!:
I personally loved it, and I loved how it ended - waaay better than how Rowling finished the HP series. At least in this series I got some closure.

I can't wait until Midnight Sun either - the first draft of ch.1 was brilliant! & like Sweetiecheeks said, I really hope SM writes more books, and some about Renesmee and Jacob :)
posted over a year ago.