NOONE can top Michael Crawford!!!

I picked Howard McGillin because he is the one I saw on Broadway. I was not fortunate enough to see the genius of Michael Crawford. I don't know if my heart could have stood it. I was front row at the Majestic to see Phantom and I was so awed I had to remind myself to breathe. I count it as the happiest night of my life.

Ramin is just epic as The Phantom... no not The Phantom in Love Never Dies, but have you heard him sing with Gina Beck!? I think my heart stopped beating for a minute...

John Owen-Jones is a close second, but Michael Crawford will always be the best!!!!!

that was really really hard bc i love all of them. It was especially hard 2 pick between ramin and JOJ

I literally grew up listening to his version it cannot be topped for me however Ramin is a very close second

Ramin Karimloo, Michael Crawford, John Owen Jones, Ben Lewis and offcourse Colm Wilkinson are my favorite Phantoms. :-)

Rob Guest is the only Phantom I've seen on stage acting even though have heard Michael Crawford, Gerard Butler, Ramin Karimloo as well as the 4 at the 25th anniversary concert. But you say on stage so Rob Guest is my answer.

john owens has agood voice ramin for the win for me