For those of 당신 who watched the original series...who gave the best portrayal of their character as compared to the original? 투표 Results - 별, 스타 Trek (2009)

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

별, 스타 Trek (2009) For those of 당신 who watched the original series...who gave the best portrayal of their character as compared to the original?

75 fans picked:

Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley)

52%

Zachary Quinto as Spock (formerly portrayed 의해 Leonard Nimoy)

24%

I haven't seen the original series.

13%

Chris Pine as Kirk (formerly portrayed 의해 William Shatner)

Anton Yelchin as Chekov (formerly portrayed 의해 Walter Koenig)

Simon Pegg as Scotty (formerly portrayed 의해 James Doohan)

Zoe Saldana as Uhura (formerly portrayed 의해 Nichelle Nichols)

no votes yet

John Cho as Sulu (formerly portrayed 의해 George Takei)

no votes yet

chel1395 posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

15 comments

	chel1395 picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): I can't get over how great he was as McCoy! posted over a year ago.

	makintosh picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): His performance of McCoy was pretty good posted over a year ago.

	JustHuddy picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): He was so great! posted over a year ago.

	TheAnswer picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): Zach Quinto was really great, and Chris Pine too, but Karl urban really got the sour humour of McCoy down, just sort of a younger, livelier version. He was terrific. posted over a year ago.

	EllaBlack picked Chris Pine as Kirk (formerly portrayed 의해 William Shatner): Pine as Kirk, then Urban as Bones, then Quinto as spock posted over a year ago.

	StarbucksBunny picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): he was awesome! posted over a year ago.

	fanfly picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): Bones has always been my favourite and Urban was closest to Kelley's portrayal of him. I loved it! posted over a year ago.

	brittlegirl94 picked Zachary Quinto as Spock (formerly portrayed 의해 Leonard Nimoy): Very comparable, I love Spock! But Bones was great too. posted over a year ago.

	BeSafe picked I haven't seen the original series.: I've only seen bits and pieces of the original. posted over a year ago.

	spockrocks picked Zachary Quinto as Spock (formerly portrayed 의해 Leonard Nimoy): No one portrays Bones as well as DeForest Kelly posted over a year ago.

	AcidBanter picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): Urban was perfectly cast as Bones!! posted over a year ago.

	Spotted4 picked Zachary Quinto as Spock (formerly portrayed 의해 Leonard Nimoy): or Karl Urban posted over a year ago.

	MelBelle2 picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): Considering since I'm a HUGE Bones fan and I don't mean the show. lol I do mean my lovely Doctor McCoy. :D I was very impressed with Karl in his performance, he did wonderfully and I know DeForest would've been proud. :) posted over a year ago.

	TeeFly picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): From what I've seen of the original series. posted over a year ago.

	ryans_love picked Karl Urban as McCoy (formerly portrayed 의해 DeForest Kelley): my god...so hard to choose! they were all brilliant! posted over a year ago.