이 질문에 답하기

Sayaka Miki 질문

Why do 당신 think Sayaka gets too much hate?

Just want to hear your opinions:)
 comic-freak posted over a year ago
next question »

Sayaka Miki 답변

HomuraAkemi225 said:
Maybe other Homura 팬 think she deserve much hate because Sayaka said that Homura let Mami die to get the grief seed 또는 because for being not confident to confess to Kyousuke.....
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
IllusionDolls said:
First things first, I think that the primary reason that people hate her is because she became self-righteous around the mid-point of the series. However, I still find it invalid to due the fact that she did not exaggerate her emotions; therefore, her behavior and feelings were completely understandable and also realistic. I think that the fact that she fell into despair over Kyousuke after she still didn't seem to act on her feelings in the first place annoys people. Regardless, not only has a magical girl's life already been explained to viewers / readers thus we should understand why she felt that she couldn't be with Kyousuke, but ALSO, according to the director (or writer, it was either one, I don't recall), in one of the alternate timelines where Sayaka had also made the contract, Kyousuke discovered her double life and reacted 의해 addressing her as a MONSTER. It is speculated among 팬 after learning this that it may be another reason and the trigger of why she fell into despair and became Octavia-- she thought of this as a confirmation of her 이전 feelings about her own self after forming the contract with Kyubey.

People also tend to think that she only formed the contract in the first place because she wanted Kyousuke to feel indebted to her and return her feelings, which is actually pretty true in a sense, but can we talk about how REALISTIC her character is in all aspects? She still truly cared about Kyousuke and even after how he treated her and near the end of the series was displayed crying grateful tears due to his own happiness that came from her wish.

Maybe Sayaka was foolish and self-righteous, but she was a perfect representation for a magical girl in the world of PMMM, and I, for one, thought that her character was executed spectacularly.
select as best answer
 First things first, I think that the primary reason that people hate her is because she became self-righteous around the mid-point of the series. However, I still find it invalid to due the fact that she did not exaggerate her emotions; therefore, her behavior and feelings were completely understandable and also realistic. I think that the fact that she fell into despair over Kyousuke after she still didn't seem to act on her feelings in the first place annoys people. [i]Regardless[/i], not only has a magical girl's life already been explained to viewers / readers thus we should understand why she felt that she couldn't be with Kyousuke, but ALSO, according to the director (or writer, it was either one, I don't recall), in one of the alternate timelines where Sayaka had also made the contract, Kyousuke discovered her double life and reacted 의해 addressing her as a MONSTER. It is speculated among 팬 after learning this that it may be another reason and the trigger of why she fell into despair and became Octavia-- she thought of this as a confirmation of her 이전 feelings about her own self after forming the contract with Kyubey. People also tend to think that she only formed the contract in the first place because she wanted Kyousuke to feel indebted to her and return her feelings, which is actually pretty true in a sense, but can we talk about how REALISTIC her character is in all aspects? She still truly cared about Kyousuke and even after how he treated her and near the end of the series was displayed crying grateful tears due to his own happiness that came from her wish. Maybe Sayaka was foolish and self-righteous, but she was a perfect representation for a magical girl in the world of PMMM, and I, for one, thought that her character was executed spectacularly.
posted over a year ago 
*
I think her wish was the most human out of all the magical girls:) Well,normal characters are always hated:(
comic-freak posted over a year ago
*
u have made me look at sayaka from a whole other level so now i don't hate her i just dislike her
SakuraKyoko posted over a year ago
*
But Sayaka casued your death, SakuraKyoko. Madoka walked 앞으로 before 당신 can attack 또는 set your Illusion barrier for the 3rd time.
3ASV89 posted over a year ago
TheDollmaker said:
Sayaka was absolutely awful to Madoka and a complete asshole to Homura and Kyouko. She never apologised for it. Her growth at the end of the 아니메 was basically to say that "she only ever wanted Kyousuke to be happy". She never admitted to doing something wrong 또는 any fault at all. It's the cheap excuse of someone who doesn't want to own up to their mistakes and refuses to face their faults. The only time Sayaka endeared herself to me was in Rebellion. She finally showed some form of actual growth and there was some acknowledgement for her former actions when she talked to Homura and tried to encourage her. She seemed to have gotten over her irrational and unnecessary antipathy towards Homura, but unfortunately she immediately fell back to her old habits and easily believed that Homura is the devil. It says something about Sayaka that she readily falls for Homura's act.

Sayaka was verbally and emotionally abusive to Madoka and constantly guilt tripped her. She never apologises for it. She was trying to pull Madoka down with her and doom her for her own sake. This is incredibly selfish and not how a friend should ever behave. (and Sayaka 팬 dare complain about Hitomi)

How dare Sayaka berate Kyouko for stealing? Newsflash 당신 spoilt little brat! Kyouko needed to survive not everyone is fortunate enough to have parents that pay for the food. Kyouko has no choice but to steal if she wants to survive her life as an orphan, 거리 kid and magical girl. I hate that Kyouko sacrificed herself for Sayaka because she believed Sayaka's heroic facade and fell for her moralistic speech. Sayaka was just busy riding the moral high horse, she's a much worse person than Kyouko who at the end sacrifices her life for self-centred Sayaka who had been insulting her the whole time. Sayaka is no hero, she has no empathy whatsoever she just wanted to feel better 의해 morally condemning Kyouko and spit her in the face rather than show a smidgen of goodness. (Well outside of that one time she actually sympathises with Homura in Rebellion-finally some character growth). How the hell did their "talk" convince Kyouko to go back to her true heroic self? Sayaka showed zero compassion, empathy, understanding, goodness 또는 heroism! Wth?

Homura, oh Homura. Right of the bat Sayaka disliked Homura. This was true for Moemura, too. I can only guess why this was the case for Moemura, but I hazard that it was jealousy in both cases because she did not like sharing her friend Madoka and envy in the case of Homura cause Homura is amazing and made quite the entrance as a transfer student.

Truly Sayaka was blinded 의해 her envy of Homura and was ready to believe the worst of her which is why Kyouko and Kyuubei had such an easy time manipulating her.

Btw, Fuck Kyouko for selfishly manipulating Sayaka and Madoka into becoming Magical girls. Note that Kyouko thought the worst of Homura, too. Kyouko just didn't like Homura telling the truth.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
3ASV89 said:
The reasons are obvious:
Reasonable answers:
1. Sayaka lied to her best friend Madoka Kaname. (Hinted in episode 7).
2. She made Madoka cried. (Hinted in episode 6 and 8)
3. Failed to clean her soul gem. (Hinted in episode 8)
4. Caused Kyoko Sakura's death. (Hinted in episode 9)

Unreasonable answers:
1. She is the only one has a boyfriend. (What's wrong with a girl has a boyfriend? Ichigo Momomiya in Tokyo Mew Mew also has a boyfriend so why she does not get hated)


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »