해리 포터

해리 포터 Agree-disagree game

KathyHalliwell posted on Oct 30, 2008 at 07:46AM
I say something about HP (my opinion), and the next person will say if he/she agrees or not and why (and then he/she says something about HP, too)

Ok, so I say:The 7th book is the best

해리 포터 202 replies

Click here to write a response...
Previous

Showing Replies 1-50 of 202

over a year ago CaliGirl1204 said…
I agree all the books have good points some better then others but the 7th book has the most dramatic and interesting story that brings everything to a major climax for the entire series and then closes in a very awesome way!
over a year ago hm94991 said…
Uh..... sence Galigirl diddnt make somthing to disagree with, ill just start another. XD

hmmm.... Luna Lovegood was very underplayed in the 5th movie.
over a year ago Sappp said…
I disagree.
I actually loved the portrayal of Luna. She has that weird kind of dreaminess that IS Luna. Her voice is just right for Luna.
And I loved her hair and the fact that she wore All Stars :)

My turn:
I liked Dumbledore from the first two movies better then the one from the movies after that.

over a year ago Biathine said…
agree. For be he was the real Dumbledore.

Sirius rocks! XD
over a year ago KathyHalliwell said…
Agree.I love him!

Hermione&Ron are the best couple in HP
over a year ago CLovegood7 said…
agree. There was so many ups and downs for a full 6 years before they finally got together. But when they did it was perfect!

Evanna Lynch is perfect to play Luna Lovegood!
over a year ago martemora15 said…
she rocks as luna! dobby was the sadest death in the entire series!
over a year ago KathyHalliwell said…
Disagree.I think Fred was.But Dobby's death was really sad too.

Rupert is hotter than Dan
over a year ago DarkSarcasm said…
Disagree. Then again, I think they're both kinda gross... =P

Tonks and Lupin were an awesome couple.
over a year ago Biathine said…
Agree! My favorite...

Teddy would make an awesome spin-off character.
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
disagree. i just don't think it sounds exciting...

kreacher is the coolest house elf in the series
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago DarkSarcasm said…
Disagree. Dobby pwnz Kreacher. =P

Hermione shouldn't have married Ron.
over a year ago KathyHalliwell said…
Disagree.They're very cute together.

They should find a better actress for Ginny.
over a year ago catherineairey said…
Agree.
Bonnie Wright just doesn't convey Ginnys strenght and confidence in the later films.


Emma Watson is amazing

over a year ago hm94991 said…
Agree!

Hmm..... The afterward of the seventh book was not neaded.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago jlcapor13 said…
Disagree. I think that a lot of us who read the books are pleased to know what happeness after the ending.
over a year ago jlcapor13 said…
emma watson is HOT!!!
over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Agree. I am a girl,LOL. She is very pretty.

Rupert Grint is the best actor out of the trio.
over a year ago xGeorgie said…
Agree.... Dan and Emma are both really good and all - but Rupert is just really unique and suits the character well


(In the book) Harry and Ginny make a wicked couple and their relationship should have lasted longer.
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
disagree i thought they had enough time. besides deathly hollows was amazing i'm glad she put everything she did in there, if he had stayed with ginny longer it would be different (or maybe your talking about the 6th book, sorry)

lupin OR tonks should've died, not both of them
over a year ago jlcapor13 said…
disagree if only one of them died then the other one would be miserable.

It would be cool if JKR would have shown Nicholas Flamel in one of the books
over a year ago LabraLege said…
Disagree, it is not a necessary and HP series already has lots of characters.
Grindelwald didn't love Dumbledore as much as Albus did
over a year ago Hogwarts_Army said…
Agree,HP doesn't need another character plus he was suppose to die after the philosopher's stone was destroyed in the 1st book...my turn J.k Rowling should write another book about wat happened in between the end of the deathly Hallows book and the start of the epilogue
over a year ago Jonapello23 said…
Disagree-
I would read it, but I think it's good the way it is.

-The epilogue should have had more detail
over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Disagree: I think it is good the way it is. I actually thought it had too much detail...LOL

-Dobby shouldn't have died.




over a year ago hm94991 said…
Agreeeee! I was so sad after a I read that I almost cried!


Agree or Disagree-
Emma Watson was sexyst in the 4th movie.
over a year ago isa-isa said…
agree (in a not weird way)

The guy who played Wood was cuter in the 1st movie than in Twilight-sorry, I don't know his name
over a year ago aanniiee_ said…
I think you mean Cedric (Robert Pattinson)?

anyway, disagree, I thought he was really hot in Twilight!

Dean Thomas should have married Luna - They were so cute together in the 7th book!
over a year ago EmCon said…
smile
Disagree Luna should have married Neville.

I really wanted Ron and Hermione to get together.
over a year ago hm94991 said…
monkey
Erm... They Did? lol what are you asking?


Agree or Disagree? 4th movie was the worst.
over a year ago catherineairey said…
dissagree. The fourth movie is my favourite one. I think that it is done really well.


I went mad when i saw all the bits that had been left out and changed in the 5th movie.
over a year ago makintosh said…
Disagree-
He died like a hero

Agree or dissagree? Snape'd have deserved another end.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Disagree. The way he died was horrible but I think it was okay that he died. It was a very dramatic moment and it was very well written. It was really sad but necessary to the story. It showed how brave he was; he was a hero.

Colin Creevey shouldn't have died.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago spikes_girl said…
agree! he was just a kid for crying out loud! it was so brave of him to stay behind and then he died and i was so sad!!!

cedric should've made it through the graveyard and gone back with harry, so they would both be triwizard champions.
over a year ago marglo said…
agree! definatly

they should hurry up making the new movie!

over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Agree! I want so badly to watch the movie already!

The actor who plays Snape is awesome. He is Snape.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago aanniiee_ said…
AGREEEEE! He's way excellent as Snape, just as I pictured him.


Sirius should not have died - it would have been soo much better if he had lived
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Agree! He never really enjoyed being free... but I think JK would have killed him anyway in Deathly Hallows,lol.


I would have liked to know more about James and Lily.
over a year ago pixie09 said…
disagree ... james and lily didnt need a bigger part, it would have made harry a different person if all he could think about was his dead parents.

FRED SHOULDNT HAVE DIED !!!!!
over a year ago Hogwarts_Army said…
AGREE that would've made it less sad

Snape should have lived
over a year ago liissaaxx said…
Nah. As said before Snape's death was necessary!

Mad-eye shouldn't have died!
over a year ago EmCon said…
smile
Agree he should have survived.

Ron should have never gotten together with Lavender Brown
over a year ago whooshaa said…
disagree. He needed to have someone xD


They shouldn't have moved the release date for HBP
over a year ago linhousepotter said…
Agree!!!!!!! I was so mad when they did it!! Now I am just waiting like crazy to watch the movie. I am sure it is going to be AMAZING.

I think that splitting the Deathly Hallows movie into two parts was a WONDERFUL choice.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago aanniiee_ said…
AGREEEEE! There's no way they could have squeezed the whole 7th book into one movie without it sucking. I'm so excited, it's going to be brillianttttttttttt :)


I thought Devon Murray - the kid who played Seamus Finnegan - was terrible in the 5th movie.
over a year ago snoznoodle said…
Agree. I don't think he's actually a good actor. That's why he doesn't have that many lines.

The 6th movie will be the best. The actors and the movies just keep getting better and better!
over a year ago pixie09 said…
are they really going to make the 7th movie into 2 parts ??!! OMG that would be awesome :D !!! anyway...

agree, the 6th book is my favourite and i recon it will be the best movie too

daniel radcliff cant act that well (sorry, but i dont think he is that good :o)
over a year ago Carolopay said…
Agree. He's not as dramatic as I hoped the boy who lived would be. But I also believe if he tried a little harder, he wouldn't be overshadowed by the other characters.

JK should have mentioned how Bill and Fleur Weasley ended up in terms of family life.
over a year ago makintosh said…
Disagree.IMO we have enough information about Bill&Fleur :)

Agree or Disagree? JK should had mentioned more details about future life of the main characters(Ron&Hermione,Harry&Ginn­y,L­una­,Ge­org­e,N­evi­lle­,Dr­aco­...­)
over a year ago Janni said…
Agree:D

J.K should write a book about what happend in those 19 years. Where she tells what happend, and how things happend..
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!