이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

i have a 질문 related to spells.Please read the details and answer.

"Avada Kedavra's a curse that needs a powerful bit of magic behind it - 당신 could all get your wands out and point them at me and say the words, and I doubt I'd get so much as a nosebleed."
—Barty Crouch, Jr. as Alastor Moody

Its just not about the killing curse.They sit in the classes and try hard to perfect a spell.Its always inclined that casting a spell is not always about saying the incantation.there is a whole theory behind it.
But my point is how could Harry and Ron cast the protective enchantments just 의해 copying what Hermione was saying?Later at Gringotts Harry used the Imperius curse and while breaking out they again copied Hermione's spell just 의해 saying the same incantations.How could they if they didn't learn them.I certainly think Harry didn't learn the Imperius Curse.
 jhakanaka420 posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

jameswilson said:
Yea, there are things that go on in the seventh book that all seem to happen pretty fast - but I think the idea is that they all prepare for these things when they are at both Grimmauld place and shell cottage. Hermione (having prepared far 더 많이 than the other two for their journey) probably learned the protective enchantments and then taught and practiced it with Harry and Ron. I imagine the case is the same with the Imperius curse since they determined they would need it at Gringotts.
Also, one of the things that is said about the unforgivable curses is that 당신 have to mean it. Presumably, they learned how to perform the curses and later on they surely meant it when the situation was life 또는 death at Gringotts.

Hope this helps! :]
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thanx! i guess you're right.in the Grimmauld Place and in Shell Cottage there is not details on everyday.So they must have learned new things at that time.
jhakanaka420 posted over a year ago
*
and the intention thing is important too.as Harry perfectly used the Cruciatus curse only when he really meant it
jhakanaka420 posted over a year ago
LadyNottingham said:
They were shown the curse in 4th year, remember ? 의해 Barty Crouch Jr impersonating Alastor Moody.

Besides, it's the intention that fuels the magic. 당신 may learn a spell but if 당신 don't have the intention, it'll be weak - hence what Barty said which 당신 quoted in your question. 당신 have to mean it to make it efficient.

Therefore, they may imitate Hermione, it'll work as long as they have a real intention behind it. Remember too that Hermione had taught them many things, that Harry must have learnt many things to be able to teach the DA in OotP. There were many things left asides in both 책 and movies, we can imagine that they spent a lot of time together practising, especially Harry that had been keenly aware of the importance of defensive and offensive spells since Voldemort had returned.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly. The Will and The Word. Know the Word, and focus your Will behind it.
BlackHound posted over a year ago
*
Now that's brilliant, BH, I like it ! The Will and the Word... would make a lovely 제목 for a fanfic...
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
*
Hmm I didn't think that way at first.Thanks!!
jhakanaka420 posted over a year ago
*
@LN: It absolutely would, and thank you. @jhakanaka: You're welcome. I was very young when I learned that.
BlackHound posted over a year ago
next question »