이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

Have 당신 ever wonder what if the movie franchise was a TV show instead? (sorry if this has been asked)

whats your opinion if it were a tv show??

i think if it were a tv show, it would not have gone on for so long. and i wouldn't like it particularly. because in tv shows most of the time when adapted from 책 the story wort of changes. and sometimes for the worst.

just wondering..
*
oh, i forgot another plus side. we would get to see them grow up!
alisonfaith297 posted over a year ago
 alisonfaith297 posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

Lunalovely said:
NO! A tv,show wouldve been terrible! They wouldve changed EVERYTHING! Like the show Pretty Little Liars, not many know it was a book series, but I cant even watch it! They change SO much its almost unrecognizable, except for like the first few episodes, most of it is like WHA?? What did they do!
Harry Potter wouldve been bad as a tv series
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Vixie79 said:
Yeah that would have been an awful idea. They would have changed almost everything, even 더 많이 so than the 영화 already had. Also people that hadn't read the 책 would be demanding changes that weren't in the books. Also, ones that weren't happy with the conclusions would stop watching and the ratings would plummet.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LadyNottingham said:
A TV series would have allowed plenty of time to show things and events and people 더 많이 in details. Look at the Dune saga (by Frank Herbert). The movie was great, yet the series wasn't bad either.

However, I don't think it would be a good idea to make such a series now. Because we still are full of the imaginary set 의해 the 영화 (in terms of decors and costumes, etc). Plus, the actors were so wonderful in the movies, we cannot replace them now. Especially one Alan Rickman.

So I think a TV series, which develops well all the events, things, places, people as well as in the 책 would be great. But not now. Maybe in 20 years time. After the phenomenon, we'll need time to assimilate what a formidable adventure it was. I, for one, would be spending my time making comparisons with the 영화 from an 연기 and aesthetic point of view. Not good.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
PotterLambert93 said:
actually, I used to want it a tv show, but now I think it was best if they just stuck with the 영화 instead. Plus, any Tv show that was based on the book turns out to be way different. Like True Blood for example, the show is a little 더 많이 different than the books.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »