이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

What do 당신 think Dudley heard in the 5th book when he and Harry got attacked 의해 Dementors??

 magic18 posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

theblondegirl said:
I'm guessing that he was most afraid of not being in control of things. That's the only traumatic thing that we know of. Here's where I base my theory:

1. The time when Hagrid cast a spell on him and he ended up with a pig's tail was probably quite a shock

2. His father is mentioned to have slapped him several times in the first book (when they flee 쥐똥 나무속의 식물, 바비큐, privet Drive and go to the hotel it's mentioned he was crying in the back 좌석 of their car because Vernon had slapped him when he had been too slow to pack). He also quite roughly threw both Harry and Dudley to the hallway when they first start getting letters.

I think his feeling of despair was caused 의해 the lack of basic safety and helplessness. Harry wasn't the only one who suffered from the Dursley's unimaginativeness. Also Dudley was expected to grow up to become the kind of a boy the Dursleys could approve of and in his case their oppression was even 더 많이 severe since Dudley had their 사랑 to lose if he failed to meet their expectations. Harry never had this problem since the Dursleys didn't 사랑 him in the first place.

3.Also remember that he used to bully and belittle Harry when they were young, and all of a sudden Harry became the stronger one when turned out he was a wizard - even Dudley's own parents were afraid of Harry's abilities.
I think Dudley basically just feels the need to be in control of things which he expressed through bullying, and is afraid of situations and people he has no control over. Dementors represent both of the things he's afraid of: magic and his own weakness.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
SiriusSeverus said:
Gooood question...

Possibly himself being killed 의해 some dark evil force he doesn't understand?

It depends how grown up 당신 think he can be.
Possibly the thought of no 음식 ever again...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
LOL ya I agree 또는 maybe something that happened when he was young
Mel4ever posted over a year ago
*
LOL the thought of no 음식 must have tormented him :)
magic18 posted over a year ago
*
i'm happy!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
lakota_spirit said:
Maybe all the suffering he has inflicted upon his victims of bullying?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i dont think he will be worries about it!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
ecpjll said:
when dementors attack 당신 you're supposed to live YOUR most tramatic moments...not someone else's. So he wouldn't feel how the kids he bullied felt. He probably remembered being a baby and screaming bloody blue murder for whatever he wanted; and his parents not giving it to him because they have no idea what he wants since he can't talk yet? Probably the only time his parents ever didn't deliver to his every spoiled want and demand.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
LOL thats very right!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
TrueTwi_hard said:
Maybe the moment with the snake in part 1. It's quite scary. 또는 a moment without tv. Depends.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
a moment without tv? lol! just what i thought but i think it was something much 더 많이 scarier!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
MithrasPotter said:
I think Dudley fears lack of attention, being ignored, the most. He was always screaming for his parents' attention as a boy, and was a bully when he was older. He had to be the center of the world, all of the time. When faced with the dementor, I think he saw himself in a situation like that - whether he was ever actually in one, in order to relive, I don't know.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
dont u yhink dudley gets 더 많이 than enuf attention 4rm his parents and aunt?
iluvstories posted over a year ago
emilykuru said:
당신 know it is mentioned in the book that they bought a tv and insatlled it in the 부엌, 주방 specially for him. maybe the thought of it not being there! just kidding! thi is what i think:

1. all his 프렌즈 start bullying him back and all his victims attack him!

2.his mom and dad no longer care for him but r hugging harry - he would hate that a lot!!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
he'd hate his parents liking harry 더 많이 but that would never happen!
magic18 posted over a year ago
*
yes but i think that's what he heard when the dementors approached him!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
iluvstories said:
dudley probably was not affected as much as harry.. and din hear anything..i don think even ron and hermione heard anything,did they?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »