What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

소녀시대 Should there be a FACE OF THE GROUP?

40 fans picked:
Yes
   60%
No. This should be a rotating role.
   40%
 vinxinc posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

21 comments

user photo
SugarBell20 picked Yes:
Yeah, I mean its working they make tons of revenue with a "face" and a consistent one to. If they rotated images how many people would care about SNSD if Sunny or Hyoyeon were the image....answer:no one
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sone4life picked Yes:
@SugarBell20 I would love it if Sunny or Hyoyeon were that! Don't come to conclusions so quickly! At least find out the truth before you state something.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SugarBell20 picked Yes:
^don't act butthurt its just a fact. they are the ugliest members in SNSD, period esp hyoyeon. Yoona is the saving grace of SNSD because people actually like her face, the only people who could also be the face is Seohyun or Yuri (she looks like Yoona). Everyone is either too short, ugly, or too dark.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
sone4life picked Yes:
@SugarBell20 Its not a fact. Sun and Hyo aren't the least beautiful, no one is! What you call "ugly" is really pretty! Get some glasses you obviously need them because your not seeing correctly!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SugarBell20 picked Yes:
^again butthurt and it is true, look at most polls by SK citizens I want you to guess who is at the bottom of the list and it ain't because they are talentless its because they are considered ugly not for you "not pretty enough"
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
VipSoneJack picked Yes:
@SugarBell20 I don't care if i am being "butthurt" i only care that your wrong! (Same person as @sone4life)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked No. This should be a rotating role.:
cause most of the time, i don't agree with the face of the group. i found them plain or ugly. so, of course it annoyis me seeing certain members getting all the screentime
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked No. This should be a rotating role.:
SugarBell20 look i don't know what's wrong with you, but saying that's a fact, it's so stupid. are you korean? if you are, i get your point. but don't try to say to europeans or americans that we're buthurt because we don't have the same opinion as koreans(and most of the asians) do. so what if Hyo and Sunny are considered the least pretty there? it's NOT A FACT. to me, the least pretty members are Jessica and Seohyun, yet, they're considered beautiful in South korea

i found it funny how you're saying that Yuri would be the second best option after Yoona, but then you contradict yourself, saying that the others are either too short, ugly or dark. Yuri IS the darkest member. so, what you're saying is invalid. not to mention that Yoona isn't even that white, i will never understand korean's definition of beauty. so, they're supposed to be tall, have a v shape, s line, double eyelids, big eyes and white skin. well, the only thing that Sooyoung doesn't have on the list is white skin....then why is she considered unnactractive? and then, you guys have ugly people like Sohee as the face of the group, yet, she doesn't have ANYTHING on that list. she's short, she has a round face, single eyelids and really small eyes. she looks like Sunny's sister sometimes. why is she the face of the group? i will never get these things...
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
sone4life picked Yes:
^ Agree
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
vinxinc picked No. This should be a rotating role.:
I think the face should only appear at their early days. Now all of them have been known personally, other girls than Yoona should be in the center. It's both for fairness and for promoting each of them individually. I actually like videos like Hoot and Mr Taxi, wherein there's no real center.

posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SugarBell20 picked Yes:
I am korean and I have lived there so don't talk about shit you dont understand.
Facts: Most Koreans think Sunny and Hyoyeon are UGLY and Sooyoung but older guys like her most.

Fact:Yoona is the only reason SNSD make as much money as they now, so before you all start whining think for a minute. They like her youthful looks and how innocent she looks, she gives that demure appearance. If you think SNSD would be just as popular with another member promoting them then you all really don't understand how things work.

You all think that personality matter when it doesn't in the music industry esp in Korea, if you don't look a certain way you don't get a job..a fucking job so if I tell that most people think Sunny and Hyoyeon are ugly I mean it, that is why they had to get plastic sugery and they still look funny.

pretty_angel92,
1. it doesn't matter if your american or european that isn't going to change how things are for a "KOREAN" group. Your talking as if SNSD are anything but an Asian group who come from an Asian culture. They are not Western they are Eastern who value things different then others would. So when I say that some members are considered ugly or "less attractive" it is a fact because they are Koreans in a Korean Culture with Korean people in it.

Its nice that people think other members are pretty but since they are a Korean group you have to also judge by the standard of Koreans sometimes. Sunny has small eyes, an ugly nose, and is really short. Hyoyeon is just too much sometimes everything except her eyes are wrong. I like all SNSD members but I also understand reality.


2. I said Yuri because most people actually like her look despite how dark she is.

3.Sooyoung is unattractive because her face is shaped weird, she has to wear bangs in order for her face to give off the illusion of a V-line shape. She has nice long legs but like I said she appeals to an older crowd most of the time, I like her face but I also know my people to.

4.Soohee is like Rain and refused to get surgery and she isnt' ugly she just appeals to a bunch of old men fapping in their office (jk) but she has the right shape chin, and she isn't marketed as sexy so its the innocent look people like. Most images of groups are the ones that look the most "innocent" its a way to lure people in.

The point is that Yoona is not only necessary but vital for the group as far as an image goes, she is pretty and for some prettier then anyone else in SNSD and nothing will change that. She makes millions of dollars with her face, she makes the most money in her group because people actually like her look and what her to sponsor their product.
I called you guys butthurt because you really don't understand how things work.Don't you think if people though she wasn't pretty she would still be the image of the group? Yoona will get all the attention, so what? All the other members knew that about Yoona but why are fans the only ones bitching about it. Its not supposed to be fair, its business this way of business makes them the most money. They have to appeal to a Korean audience not a global one.That is how things work. If all the other members can be ok with it, why can't fans?

There has to be a face of the group because that is how groups get exposure, promotions, and money. So for SNSD the one who makes the most money gets to be the image...and its Yoona because she is considered the prettiest member and Koreans love her face too. Hell even Sooyoung wants her face so what?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih picked Yes:
^wow while I understand what you are saying I think that your being a little harsh don't you think?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SugarBell20 picked Yes:
No not really. I tried being honest but you still have these butthurt Sones telling me how wrong I am, as if I made this up.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih picked Yes:
that doesn't change the fact that it is still harsh. You will have sones like that but you can't rant at all of them you will get a headache. I am not saying you are wrong but you will make enemies here if you rant at every person who doesn't like what you said.

Question: If you think Sunny is ugly why is she your icon?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
nacchiee picked Yes:
^SugarBell20 hmm... after your comments, lets see what will pretty_angel92 response XD
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
sone4life picked Yes:
@SugarBell20 Something can not be a fact if everyone doesn't agree!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih picked Yes:
^if he is korean then it technically could be considered fact considering it is a korean group, just read what he is saying.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
pretty_angel92 picked No. This should be a rotating role.:
nacchiee LOL i don't understand why everyone's waiting for my response, cause it's clear that SugarBell20 is being kinda immature. it's never a fact, PERIOD. even in South korea you will found people with different opinions. not every south korean will think like you. not every south korean will say that Hyo and Sunny are the least pretty. that's something you need to accept
and i don't get what you said about Sooyoung...weird shaped face? what is a weird shaped face to you guys? =S
and what you said about Sohee doesn't explain anything, because Sunny can also look cute and innocent.

don't forget the fact that Yoona was already popular before their debut, so of course that helped her image. i bet that if SM didn't over exposed Yoona that much, she wouldn't be that popular. look at Siwon from Suju. he's the face of the group, but he's far from being the most popular member. can you tell the difference? i sure can, since SM doesn't show his face 10 times during the MV's, against 2 or 3 from the others. they also don't give him lines that he doesn't deserve. same thing for Sulli. people actually thought Krystal was the face, not Sulli. what they did to Kai from EXO is the exact same thing they did with Yoona. trying to convince people that he and she are the most gorgeous on their respective groups, and that won't change. look at the amount of teasers that Kai got before their debut, despite not fiting to koreans beauty standarts. from what i know, he has dark skin
what SM does is simply strategy. if they didn't show Yoona that much in the middle since the BEGINNING, people wouldn't give a damn about her. i'm saying this by personal experience since i know i a lot of people who were surprised after discovering that Yoona was the face. they said she was so bland and forgetable

oh and btw, Sooyoung never said she wanted Yoona's face, she just said she was pretty
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
tiagih picked Yes:
^but he has a point. I am not hear to defend him because I think that if you have something to say you should always try and be respectful but I do understand what he is saying.

I think he is talk about the mainstream South Korea and since I have Korean friends I can vouch for him, most of what he is saying has an element of truth. My friends laugh at me because I like Sunny not because she is ugly but for the reason that she isn't pretty, same with Hyoyeon and they are much harsher on her.

" i bet that if SM didn't over exposed Yoona that much, she wouldn't be that popular." I don't think so. If you listen in thier interview most people in the beginnng of SNSD debut days thought only of Yoona because of her acting so she was already popular for most people who knew little about SNSD. Her exposure was after the fact that she was acting.

"Kai got before their debut, despite not fiting to koreans beauty standarts." You have to understand Kai is supposed to be the sexy type hense why they chose him because he has the darkest skin color. Innocent cool people must have pale skin, sexy type of people have dark skin hense why Kai is the image because is (less plastic) and has dark skin.

"i know i a lot of people who were surprised after discovering that Yoona was the face. " most people are suprised after years of SNSD being idols not in the beginning I know I have lived thier when they debuted.

But I think what is important to note that since SNSD is a korean group a korean perspective may hold more water then a more international one. That is why I said he makes a point, I just don't like how rude he was about it.

While on my hiatus I have been to kpop forum sites, so I would recommended people to go to those to try and learn things from other people perspective. Sooyoung doesn't have a weird shaped face, but her jawline is much stronger then most people would like from an idol. Also realize that even if Sohee has monolids she makes the most money out of the group, sh that could be why people like her image more than other because she is more known and doesn't more promotions.

"
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Miyuki-hime picked Yes:
I think it makes sense. The purpose of an idol group is to make money and if Koreans find YoonA to be the prettiest then it follows that she should be the center. Other countries don't matter as much, besides Japan (where YoonA is still considered to be the prettiest and most popular), because SNSD is a Korean group. Appealing to America or Europe wouldn't make much sense.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tiagih picked Yes:
^and that is how I feel. I like that you spoke how you felt but was also respectful at the same time.
posted over a year ago.