디즈니 프린세스
디즈니 프린세스 Most Impressive 애니메이션 Countdown; 일 1! Pick the least impressive 애니메이션 (Elimination based mainly on comments)
This question is now closed
40 fans picked: |
알라딘
|
|||
잠자는 숲속의 미녀
|
|||
라푼젤
|
|||
인어공주
|
|||
The Princess and the Frog
|
|||
신데렐라
|
|||
백설공주와 일곱 난장이
|
|||
미녀와 야수
|
|||
Pocahontas
|
|||
뮬란
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
It's pretty simple, especially compared to the other DP movies. Simple shapes, simple colour schemes, etcetera.
On a more personal note: I also don't like the cartooney style they choose for this movie. But the main reason for choosing it first is really that you can't stop noticing where they blend computer animation with traditional animation.
By the way, this animation is pretty awful, gray, boring and very simple. I mean squared trees? uhh, and Aurora's castle is the ugliest Disney castle ever.
This style is the kind you would get from any other animation company, it isn't DISNEY animation. There's just nothing really impressive about it. I can see why people are voting out The Little Mermaid, I have to agree that the backgrounds aren't that great and sometimes even kind of make me uneasy, if that makes sense.
HOW is Sleeping Beauty being voted out already? It is gorgeous and just stunning! It is a very... stylized style. It is meant to look like a painting/ tapestry you would see in a medieval castle, and still somehow manages to be very smooth. It's fantastic!
I'm with rhythmicmagic...when it comes to animation, Sleeping Beauty is gorgeous! And unique! (And the trees are squared because the style is inspired by medival tapestry...the whole movie is one giant moving picture).
As much as I love Cinderella, the animation in the movie - aside from the dress transformation and the ball scene - is not nearly as impressive as in others. And frankly, it's astonishing that people vote off Sleeping Beauty and Aladdin so soon considering they had exceptionally stunning scenes such as the colorful and incredibly detailed nature display or the magic carpet ride, respectively.
I also thought about Cinderella, but the Mary Blair inspired backgrounds are just wonderful!
I'm not saying you have to like it but how anyone can look at this picture:
link
and think "plain" is beyond me. I'm actually flabbergasted that people use that word to describe Sleeping Beauty. Again, if you don't like the animation style, that's fine, but plain? Really? Of all words in the english language to use... PLAIN?!?!
Would someone care to clear something to me. Is this countdown about how good film looks(backgrounds, characters desing etc.) or how good the animation itself is(how good movements/expressions are, does characters look like themselves during the whole movie etc.)? I'm quite unsure I got it right and I might change my pick. Thank you.
I picked Tangled because I generally prefer 2D to 3D animation. I'm not at all impressed by the 3D. Maybe by the first movie, I think it was Toy Story, but nowadays I prefer 2D all the way.
I judged based on the following apects:
1. Was the movie inventive at the time it hits the theaters (for example a movie like Snow White gets higher points for being the first one than a movie which basically only repeats what Disney already did before).
2. Did it age well (as I mentioned that was the reason Aladdin had to go first, because that movie didn't age well at all. The computer animation used, while impressive back then, is quite an eyesore when you watch the movie today, especially the palace looks very fake in the carpet flying scenes.
3. How much work went into it and how good was the result - there the three older movies have an advantage, because they were still done by hand-inked animation, so a detailed background like the one you can see in the link mongoose posted is naturally especially impressive in Sleeping Beauty. When you compare the to a background from, for example, The Little Mermaid, which isn't half as detailed, but was made with technology which didn't exist back in the 1950s, natrually Sleeping Beauty gets higher points from me than for example The Little Mermaid.
4. How big of a challange had the animators to face. Tangled for example was a big challenge, because hair, water and the movement of clothes are three of the most difficult things to animate (along with fire - that's expecially true in CGI, but also an issue in more traditional animation), and Tangled tackled all three aspects and did it damned well (with computer software especially written for the movie).
5. Do I like the style of the movie and does it fit - that's naturally a matter of taste. I personally like it more when Disney doesn't use its "house style" and goes more out of the box.
agree with you Swanpride
코멘트를 추가하려면 로그인하거나 팬팝에 가입하세요