Because she took the bait from her villian, although she was under a trance. But I think she'd take an apple if it meant she could make a wish to be with her prince.

She was given the chance to have her own resturaunt (which was her dream) by her villian but she didn't take the bait so I don't really think that she'll take an apple from a stranger.

SarahCorine the question said Wouldn't not would....

In Almost There, she talked about how people took the easy way and how it wasn't her style.

I can see her refusing and thinking it's stupid at first, but later thinking about it and wondering if she should have taken it.

I don't understand why people are picking Jasmine... I definitely think she would take the apple. She's not exactly street-smart and wouldn't know whether it was appropriate or not so would just take it to be nice.

Yeah Jasmine and Aurora would definitely take it, they were both so sheltered, they couldn't help being gullible. Belle and Tiana would be smart and cynical enough :)