이 질문에 답하기

Critical Analysis of Twilight 질문

What do 당신 think of Stephenie Meyer being in 'Team Jacob'?

I was 읽기 this interview about S. Meyer and I saw this little caption:

If Stephenie were to pick a team, "I'd say I'd probably be in Team Jacob. That's 더 많이 of my style."

I think it's a little ironic that some people here say that S. Meyer is Bella (something like that) 또는 a Mary Sue. (No offence really!) I don't know whether she is (she could be...) but I do think it does contradict her statement on being in Team Jacob.

However, I do find the fact that she's in Team Jacob and the way she ended the Twilight Series (Edward+Bella, Jacob+Renesmee)rather strange... I'm just wondering what 당신 guys think of it...



*
i agree that is a bit strange.
topazEYEs91 posted over a year ago
*
Just adding a link to that related article: link . It's in Paragraph 6.
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
*
1-0 for jacob!!!! LOL sorry but i cant stand edward and bella i like nessie and jake!
nessienjake posted over a year ago
 rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight 답변

Plenilunio said:
Team Jacob? Yeah, that's why he turned Jacob into a jerk in "Eclipse" and made him imprint into Mary Sue and Gary Stu's spawn. Come off it! She might have a soft spot for Jacob and, since she has such poor 글쓰기 skills, she proves it 의해 completely ruining him as a character, but I don't think she's Team Jacob at all.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah, I agree. I was kinda surprised when she said she was Team Jacob. I always felt that she was Team Edward. Seeing how she turned Jake into a jerk in Eclipse and how she ended Breaking Dawn. :/
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
*
Agreed...it's pretty crazy,really...she makes Jacob a jerk, then she says she's on his team? What-?
silverandgreen7 posted over a year ago
*
^^^ LOL xD maybe so...
silverandgreen7 posted over a year ago
HerMelody said:
Hmmmm, while I agree that Team Jacob is the way to go, seems funny that Stephenie would choose that team. After all, Edward is the star, the Mr Perfect, the one Bella marries and makes 아기 with and spends eternity with.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Precisely...
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
taisa said:
WOW! after 읽기 the responses i have to agree with some of you! I dont think shes Team Jacob at all..given of all the things she has made him look like...
Its soo unexpected in a way..
I always thought she'd be 더 많이 of a Team Edward, given all the things she has created him to be...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I don't know... I'm not going to make a conclusion based on her statement... I mean it is possible that she's Team Jacob... Maybe she is... Perhaps she didn't know how to end the series with a Bella-Jacob ending and so she just simply chucked Jacob aside... hmmm...
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
Phoebe_Gabriel said:
Stephenie Meyer is obsessed with Renesmee so I don't think it's weird that she's Team Jacob.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Impulse85 said:
Okay, so she's Team Jacob, but yet she had Bella pick Edward...yeah, that's just weird. This proves, that she was playing it 안전한, 안전 with her books. See, if she was a real writer, she would realize that you're not always going to be able to make all of your 팬 happy. Writers take chances and she decided to play it 안전한, 안전 so her 팬 wouldn't get mad at her. Too Bad, that's the chance 당신 take with anything 당신 write. Sacrifces have to be made. She should stick to childrens fairy tales if she's going to be Ms. 안전한, 안전 all the time.
select as best answer
 Okay, so she's Team Jacob, but yet she had Bella pick Edward...yeah, that's just weird. This proves, that she was playing it 안전한, 안전 with her books. See, if she was a real writer, she would realize that you're not always going to be able to make all of your 팬 happy. Writers take chances and she decided to play it 안전한, 안전 so her 팬 wouldn't get mad at her. Too Bad, that's the chance 당신 take with anything 당신 write. Sacrifces have to be made. She should stick to childrens fairy tales if she's going to be Ms. 안전한, 안전 all the time.
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly! well said!!
newmixgirl posted over a year ago
*
LOL. Like the pic! xD I really like the part when Edward was slammed onto the floor 의해 Felix. WOOT WOOT! Go FELIX! ;D
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
*
Haha, it reminds me of in The Tales of Beedle the Bards, Mrs Bloxam's take of The Wizard and The Hopping Pot, "And the little golden pot danced on it's tiny rosy toes! Hippity hippity hop! Wee Willy Wilkins kissed and huggled the little pot and the pot was so happy that it filled with sweeties for Willy Wilkins and the dollies "But don't forget to brush your teethy-pegs!" cried the pot. So Wee Willy Wilkins promised never to be mean to the dollies and never be an old grumpywumpkins ever again!" <- Hmm. i can imagine Meyer 글쓰기 that.
Mrs-Grint posted over a year ago
Flounder13 said:
Im team-Dracula, so I dont care.
select as best answer
 Im team-Dracula, so I dont care.
posted over a year ago 
*
Go Dracula? Edward who? Pshhhh.
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
*
That was supposed to be an exclamation point after Dracula...
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
*
LMAO @ pic. x) Hahaha...
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
LadyLilith said:
In my opinion, I believe that SMeyer is quite the hypocrite. In one 기사 I read (I know the link is on this spot somewhere, if you're interested I'll go look for it) where she says how Bella is NOT her because Bella is SO much 더 많이 mature than her. Bella's mature 의해 putting her life retardedly in danger repeatedly just to hear her ex sparklepyre's voice, whom originally left her in the first place with very dumb reasoning? Yeah. Real mature. Okay, maybe that's the wrong example to use being as it's not hypocrisy really. ^^;; But it's still dumb!

I don't care what anyone says, I have a firm belief that Bella is a wish fulfillment character for SM(in other words, a Mary Sue.) If 당신 have your doubts, take a look at this link: link

당신 can click to enlarge the picture. Hope 당신 like it. :)

I agree with you, Asvini!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah! I read that S. Meyer said that she's not Bella because Bella is so much 더 많이 mature than her (somthing like that...) when I actually think that Bella is one of the most immature protagonist that I've ever seen. LOL. Yeap! I've seen that picture in Deviantart before! xD
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
*
DUMBASS!!!! If she was on team Jacob then WHY THE HELL did she make it about fagpires ind th FIRST PLACE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ?
hadiychan posted over a year ago
*
Who're 당신 calling dumbass? SM has a very odd way of treating her supposed "team" characters...
LadyLilith posted over a year ago
nuxi said:
from link
"What does Bella 백조 do when true 사랑 leaves her? Not just true love, but Edward Cullen! None of those other heroines 로스트 an Edward (Romeo was a hothead, Willoughby was a scoundrel, Tristan had loyalty issues, Heathcliff was pure evil, Rhett had a mean streak and cheated with hookers, and sweet Gilbert was much 더 많이 of a Jacob than an Edward). So what happens when True 사랑 in the form of Edward Cullen leaves Bella?"

Okay, so SMeyer includes being like Jacob in a list of the flaws of other 사랑 interests. And this is only one of countless times that she implies 또는 directly says that she considers Edward to be flawless 또는 an ideal 사랑 interest. The quote 당신 게시됨 comes completely out of the blue. It's the only thing I've ever seen suggesting she's on Team Jacob and everything else she's said corroborates that she's Team Edward. At the very least, I'd have to say she's not being entirely forthright there.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I've seen this quote a few times actually on some other magazines and a few other websites. No hype about it though. I've actually never seen any of her 인용구 stating that she's Team Edward. But 의해 the way she ended the series, it probably suggested that she's Team Edward. I'm not entirely sure that she's Team Jacob. That's why I put up this question... "At the very least, I'd have to say she's not being entirely forthright there." Maybe you're right.
rachaelwsz posted over a year ago
*
She 게시됨 this on her website just last week. In response to the 질문 "Is Stephenie Team Jacob 또는 Team Edward?" she said "I am Team "You Don't Have to Choose When it's Fiction."" The woman just can't make up her mind.
nuxi posted over a year ago
next question »