트와일라잇 시리즈

이 질문에 답하기

트와일라잇 시리즈 질문

Truthfully, who is better for bella?

Ok so Edward is her TRUE love, but she would have been with Jake would it have not been for the vamps. so what is your opinion? i have my own, of course, but i'd like to hear other fanatics opinions.
*
now, look at the 코멘트 and see for yourself, it is hard to decide, isnt it? Though most say edward, is it just because the 책 in her view? and if 당신 say jacob, is it just becuae she hurt him, 또는 becuase he's so hot?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
Jake he is hot
ashlynn9 posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
Ah yes, i forgot to touch on that, we see edward through his true other half, Bella, and we see Jacob through her eyes as a forever best friend, do 당신 think that, that could have an effect on who we choose?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
 EmandJazz posted over a year ago
next question »

트와일라잇 시리즈  최고의 답변

mandapanda said:
Better for Bella, I would say Edward. Setting all the "teams" aside. They both can protect her, but Edward would literally do anything for Bella. Jacob, however, immaturly handles situations. He has no sense of Bella's feelings. In Eclipse, there were many times where he hurt her because of his actions. He mentions killing the Cullens, which pains Bella. He forcfully kisses Bella and continues to pursue her when she had made it clear she didn't want him in that way. Bella was wrong to use Jacob, but it doesn't excuse Jacob's actions. Edward knows Bella loves Jacob as a brother and Edward wouldn't do anything to hurt her.

From Eclipse. Chapter 22: 불, 화재 and Ice-
"Would 당신 kill me?"
"No"
"Why not?"
"Do 당신 honestly think I would hurt her like that?"
"No, I guess not."

The entire series is about Bella and Edward and the situations they go through. Jacob just happens to be in the story. He's just another event.

And I HAVE TO DISAGREE with a 코멘트 that has been said. Jacob is NOT Bella's soulmate. Where in the world did 당신 get that from?
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i've heard the same answer over and over and frankly this answer of yours has not even remotely convinced me.
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
Hiding 12 comments... click to show.
*
Sorry, I thought 당신 meant there were no legit reasons. I agree that being hot 또는 sexy isn't a legit reason. 당신 give very legit reasons for being Team Edward and that's why I respect your opinion. And remember, people's personal views and experiences will impact their choice. Not everyone believes in 'soulmates' so that's irrelevant to them anyway .And people's experinces of relationships etc will sway what 'team' they are - it certainly does for me.
katiecain posted over a year ago
*
i most certainly understand that people can relate to the characters and also that their preference will say which "team" they are on. But in all respect, the 질문 was for Bella. I understand 당신 still think Jacob is better for her, and of course, I can see where 당신 are coming from. We've had 더 많이 than enough debates about this particular subject and each side holds their own. :)
mandapanda posted over a year ago
next question »

답변

Andressa_Weld said:
Ok for Bella the better one is Edward of course, he's her soul mate and bla bla bla bla bla bla. But the better one in my opinion.
 select as best answer
Ok for Bella the better one is Edward of course, he's her soul mate and bla bla bla bla bla bla. But the better one in my opinion.
posted over a year ago 
*
As much as I hate the imrpinting-thing, that's a nice comback from Jacob if 당신 ask me. :) Lol..
sapherequeen posted over a year ago
*
wow, thats creative. I 사랑 it! haha.
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
Edithuddy said:
Definitely Edward!
I'm not Edward team, i'm not jacob's either.
The whole saga we saw how Jake was in 사랑 with Bella and that was so sweet. But they were just not meant to be.
Bella always belongs to Edward and so on.

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
ahh, but as i said in the 코멘트 a couple 분 이전 was, Forget about the whole 사랑 thing- take it away from your thought proseccess- now, they can both obviously can protect her, both 사랑 her (different levels but NO 사랑 speaking of here), they have the looks (Obviously!), but now who in your opinion accually is better for her? like, Jacob 또는 Edward, who could help her more? conceal her better? 당신 get my thought process here?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
Hiding 11 comments... click to show.
*
Ok, here it is 더 많이 plain. Jacob and Renessemee are made to be together, total destany. So what will happen when she is old enough to be with him? will they have to leave the Cullens because of their intense thought about eachother? Since edward can read both of their minds, and they will be thinking 더 많이 phyical, what do 당신 think will happen? does that make 더 많이 sense?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
ahh ok! I got your point!!!! Uhm well I think Edward already knows that that is something that eventually will happen, so as he's done his entire life, he should keep his mind off of J's and R's mind.... I dont really think they should run away because Wherever Bella and Edward are is where they belong. Jac & Ren will always be attached to Bella, 더 많이 than Edward. I don't think they could separate from each other
Edithuddy posted over a year ago
ForsakenMoon19 said:
Okay, truthfully its Jake who's better!!! I don't care what any 팬 of bloodsuckers keep saying!!! 당신 can paint it any way 당신 want it but even when he 로스트 the girl in the end it stands to reason that the only screwed up person in this whole 삼각형 was Bella!! who kept trying to sneak off to see Jake? BELLA!! who kept up with all the teasing and flirting? BELLA!!! who kept saying jake was her sun (which she would never say that to edward)? BELLA BELLA BELLA!!!! She might have started out as seeing him as someone to pass the time in New Moon but i'm sorry the messed up chic fell in 사랑 with him, get over it!!! she was just too much of an idiot to admit her feelings for jake to edward and was obligated to stay with him in the end!!! For god sakes she kissed Jake twice!!! (no matter what 당신 팬 say, she brought it on herself!!) She was happier with jake, edward is way over possessive and rediculous!!! and not only that he's dead!!!! this idiot is willing to throw her entire life away for a dead guy???!!!! and to 상단, 맨 위로 it all off jake got slapped with the damn baby (what a way to get beat down 의해 his smug arch rivial) Well now she can say goodbye to her (real) family, 음식 and precious sleep!!! oh and since she's with a dead guy who eats 동물 (shame on 당신 for being doglovers and liking this guy), the rest of us can fantisize about our sexy, too-good-for-Bella-skank werewolf Jake Black!!! whooo hoooo!!!!!!!!!!!
 select as best answer
Okay, truthfully its Jake who's better!!! I don't care what any 팬 of bloodsuckers keep saying!!! 당신 can paint it any way 당신 want it but even when he 로스트 the girl in the end it stands to reason that the only screwed up person in this whole 삼각형 was Bella!! who kept trying to sneak off to see Jake? BELLA!! who kept up with all the teasing and flirting? BELLA!!! who kept saying jake was her sun (which she would never say that to edward)? BELLA BELLA BELLA!!!! She might have started out as seeing him as someone to pass the time in New Moon but i'm sorry the messed up chic fell in 사랑 with him, get over it!!! she was just too much of an idiot to admit her feelings for jake to edward and was obligated to stay with him in the end!!! For god sakes she kissed Jake twice!!! (no matter what 당신 팬 say, she brought it on herself!!) She was happier with jake, edward is way over possessive and rediculous!!! and not only that he's dead!!!! this idiot is willing to throw her entire life away for a dead guy???!!!! and to 상단, 맨 위로 it all off jake got slapped with the damn baby (what a way to get beat down 의해 his smug arch rivial) Well now she can say goodbye to her (real) family, 음식 and precious sleep!!! oh and since she's with a dead guy who eats 동물 (shame on 당신 for being doglovers and liking this guy), the rest of us can fantisize about our sexy, too-good-for-Bella-skank werewolf Jake Black!!! whooo hoooo!!!!!!!!!!!
posted over a year ago 
*
ya jacob for ever i 사랑 him
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
*
That's very rude to just go posting "JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD" on anyone's answer who disagrees with you.
New_Moon_Master posted over a year ago
*
how is it rude to ask for someone's opinion? Its rude to go and ask this type of 질문 than critize ppl for being honest!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
wow. i see that too. which is why i honestly cannot decide on who's Better.
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
sapherequeen said:
I'm on Team Rosalie, so I hold no favorites between Edward and Jacob when answering this.

I say Edward, because even though he has his creepy moments, he still loves Bella passionately and would do absolutely anything for her. He stood up to the most feared rulers of the vampire race to protect her. He traveled to Volterra to die just so he could see her again in death. He kills two of his own kind to save her life. And, whether it takes a long time 또는 not, he gives in to her needs and desires. He was even willing to kill his young for Bella (which was something I particularly didn't like, but Renesmee's alive, so.... *sigh with relief*). Edward amazingly relishes Bella to no end, which makes him the best man in my eyes.

Jacob..what I like about Jacob is that he keeps trying and fighting, even when Bella makes it clear that she's going to choose Edward. He doesn't give up the one he loves, which is admirable :)
Plus, he's hot. I can't lie ^_^

But overall, Edward is Bella's soulmate.

It was meant to be....
 select as best answer
I'm on Team Rosalie, so I hold no favorites between Edward and Jacob when answering this. I say Edward, because even though he has his creepy moments, he still loves Bella passionately and would do absolutely anything for her. He stood up to the most feared rulers of the vampire race to protect her. He traveled to Volterra to die just so he could see her again in death. He kills two of his own kind to save her life. And, whether it takes a long time 또는 not, he gives in to her needs and desires. He was even willing to kill his young for Bella (which was something I particularly didn't like, but Renesmee's alive, so.... *sigh with relief*). Edward amazingly relishes Bella to no end, which makes him the best man in my eyes. Jacob..what I like about Jacob is that he keeps trying and fighting, even when Bella makes it clear that she's going to choose Edward. He doesn't give up the one he loves, which is admirable :) Plus, he's hot. I can't lie ^_^ But overall, Edward is Bella's soulmate. It was meant to be....
posted over a year ago 
*
당신 only say that because 당신 think he's hot and because of the actor. so unless 당신 can produce your reasons for why 당신 think Bella really loves this dead guy, you've got nothing here.
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
Hiding 13 comments... click to show.
*
I'm Edward's side too!!b'c0z he is so sweet aNd r0mantic!!
xoxo_jeanhugs21 posted over a year ago
*
Thank you, xoxo_jeanhugs21 :)
sapherequeen posted over a year ago
New_Moon_Master said:
Like she says, Jake was her soul mate, but the 사랑 that she felt for Edward went beyond that, beyond sanity, lol. And (SPOILER!) the douche imprinted on Renesmee, which is also 더 많이 powerful than a soulmate. I don't really like how Breaking Dawn ended, but oh well.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yes, but what im trying to get through is, what if we were back in bella's- so to speak- shoes in Eclipse (or new moon 또는 twilight for that matter) and she accually thought through it all. 사랑 aside (though thats most likely impossible) just who IN GENERAL 사랑 thrown out the window, is BETTER for Bella?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
*
Hmm...They're both pretty good for her in that way. She has certain things in comman with Edward and differant things in comman with Jacob, so I think it's about even. And that's kind of disrespectful IluvJacob99. I didn't go to your answer and tell 당신 that Jacob sucks. Of course I don't think that Jacob sucks, but still. :S
New_Moon_Master posted over a year ago
prettykaren_15 said:
actually i only and trully care only about edward and since his life now is all about bella, then bella is for edward ONLY! Jacob 또는 no jacob...and even if edward was'nt a vamp, i still think bella would fall for him still, because she 사랑 him for him, and not because he's a vampire. as a matter of fact bella met jake already before she even met edward.. So so Bella is for Edward ONLY...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i see where your coming from. saying they were all human, she'd still go for edward, is what your saying, right?
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
Yeah your right, I do believe that and I do believe that Edward is the right one for Bella, I understand her reason for picking Edward because I would aswell. But I also know why its so hard for her to let go and forget about Jacob because he helped her heal. So that is why she always had on the back of her minde that maybe Jacob really is the right one for her. But I always thought it was Edward that was right for her. No matter if she lives a normal Human life 또는 not. TEAM EDWARD!!!!
kikithetwifreek posted over a year ago
*
JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
kikithetwifreek said:
Well Jacob is good for Bella in a way because they are both humans, intill in Breaking Dawn when she becomes a vampire. So in a normal human way Jacob is would be right for her and it would be 더 많이 normal and she would go throuh a normal life cycle. But Edward compleats Bella without him she is very reckless in kinda dumb. She loves both of them but really I believe its Edward that is right for Bella becasue he compleats her in every way imaginable.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
hmmm, a reason to be for edward. This 질문 is getting me all over the board. ok, i think NO MATTER WHAT, both are needed. that i know
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
jacobblack45 said:
Jacob. He is so sweet to her and i think he did everythin he could to try to win her.When i went and saw New Moon all the chances she had i kept thinking "you are so stupid Bella go with jake 당신 idiot!!!!" She was seriouly driving me crazy!!!!!!!!!!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
ive thought the same since i read the book new moon September 2008 ( yeah, i remember)
EmandJazz posted over a year ago
*
JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
*
well if he is then tell us why 당신 think that!!!!!
jacobblack45 posted over a year ago
*
OKAY. HE'S HUMAN, HE DOESN'T EAT 동물 또는 PPL, HE'S ALIVE NOT DEAD!!!, HE MAKES BELLA HAPPY, HE'S HER SUN!!!, HER DAD LIKES HIM, SHE KISSED HIM TWIICE (WHILE SHE WAS ENGAGED TO A BLOODSUCKER!!), HE'S A WEREWOLF!!! (WAY 냉각기 THAN A VAMP), HE'S 더 많이 EXCITING. HE'S COURAGEOUS, HE'S UNSELFISH, HE MAY BE HOT-HEADED AT TIMES BUT WHAT GIRL DOESN'T LIKE THEIR MEN A LITTLE BAD?, I COULD CONTINUE IF 당신 WANT ME TOO!!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
aeen said:
i think edward is better to be her bf,coz she 사랑 edward,n jacob just make this reletionship mass up!!!!!!!!!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
JACOBS BETTER THEN EDWARD
IluvJacob99 posted over a year ago
*
my thoughts exactly!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
TwilightGal708 said:
Edward!! Definitly Edward!! They are perfect! Jacob is close but he is a little to tempermental (even before the werewolf part)
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Edwrd is perfect but he is so boring !!! Jake germany 사랑 당신 <3 !!!
ErdbeerVicky posted over a year ago
nincy said:
Edward
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
xoxo_jeanhugs21 said:
for me.,Edward is the best for Bella!!B'c0z Edward will do anything to protect Bella!!although.,Jac0b is actually do that!!Well.,iM n0t a Jacob fan!!i wiLl always be Edward's fan!!s0.,definitely.,Edward is really the best for Bella!!=]
 select as best answer
for me.,Edward is the best for Bella!!B'c0z Edward will do anything to protect Bella!!although.,Jac0b is actually do that!!Well.,iM n0t a Jacob fan!!i wiLl always be Edward's fan!!s0.,definitely.,Edward is really the best for Bella!!=]
posted over a year ago 
twilightrosefan said:
Edward ,Edward and bella are just like romeo and juliet a strong love.
 select as best answer
Edward ,Edward and bella are just like romeo and juliet a strong love.
posted over a year ago 
peppergirl30 said:
I gotta say Edward cuz Bella always is happy with him and she truly loves him. It's all explained in the 책 and movies.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!