이 질문에 답하기

타이타닉 질문

Am I the only one that thinks its so unfair that kind hearted JACK dies and that bastard Cal lives?

I wanted Jack and Rose to get married in the end. I know they did in her dreams, and she took his name. I just cry when she says " I'll never let go Jack....I'll never let go"

then a while later she turns to him and he is dead.
 Persephone713 posted over a year ago
next question »

타이타닉 답변

ginny_potter_97 said:
yes i am disappointed that Jack died, but if Cal died and Jack lived it would have been to predictable. The good guy wins and the bad guy loses. so i know they did it for a reason and made it unpredictable
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
good, point. Just so sad. :(
Persephone713 posted over a year ago
*
that is so true ive always wondered why cal lived and jack died now 당신 just made it sense
mariameid posted over a year ago
ded99 said:
Cal have to die not Jack :(((
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Gleek4ever said:
Cameron wanted the audience to sympathize with the story. To feel how devestating 타이타닉 was for the real passengers and families involved, he had to create a tragic story involving characters that the audience really got to know and cared about. Rose couldn't die of course because she was the narrator. Jack's death was imminent from the beginning. He HAD to die. Had he lived, 타이타닉 would be nearly as powerful as it is. Also, I think that Cameron was trying to make a point about class distinctions of the time. Did 당신 notice how all the 3rd class passengers died and the 1st class passengers lived? Even Rose who went down with the ship?
select as best answer
 Cameron wanted the audience to sympathize with the story. To feel how devestating 타이타닉 was for the real passengers and families involved, he had to create a tragic story involving characters that the audience really got to know and cared about. Rose couldn't die of course because she was the narrator. Jack's death was imminent from the beginning. He HAD to die. Had he lived, 타이타닉 would be nearly as powerful as it is. Also, I think that Cameron was trying to make a point about class distinctions of the time. Did 당신 notice how all the 3rd class passengers died and the 1st class passengers lived? Even Rose who went down with the ship?
posted over a year ago 
sunsetdriver said:
wellllll...technically Cal dies too,it's just that it takes him a little longer,17 years later actually.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
cuddly-pandas said:
I think it's sad that Jack died too. Cal was annoying and he shouldn't have lived.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
AaronHaley4ever said:
as Machiavellian as Cal's actions were, they don't justify death for me. Don't get me wrong...I'm not saying Jack should've died, but it's unlikey that Jack's fate would've been any different had Cal died as well.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I actually like Machiavelli for everything but his huge flaws
cubsrule posted over a year ago
boytoy_84 said:
I did wish that Jack did lived and marries Rose and have a family. But the film wouldn't be as good as it is. It's sad that Jack died but that's what made the film become very popular. Cal is an asshole from treating both Rose and Jack. I do believe how 당신 feel. Jack is 더 많이 caring
and outgoing and willing to anything for Rose while Cal just wants to marry Rose for the money making Rose feel trapped. Rose wanted to feel free and happy and Jack is the one that made her happy. But this is how director, James Cameron wanted the film to be. I think it's one of the best films (based on a true story) ever.
select as best answer
 I did wish that Jack did lived and marries Rose and have a family. But the film wouldn't be as good as it is. It's sad that Jack died but that's what made the film become very popular. Cal is an asshole from treating both Rose and Jack. I do believe how 당신 feel. Jack is 더 많이 caring and outgoing and willing to anything for Rose while Cal just wants to marry Rose for the money making Rose feel trapped. Rose wanted to feel free and happy and Jack is the one that made her happy. But this is how director, James Cameron wanted the film to be. I think it's one of the best films (based on a true story) ever.
posted over a year ago 
next question »