Current round: Charles Dance Phantom, Robert Englund Phantom, and ALW Phantom (stage or movie, must specify)

And one for the guys. (or lesbians. whatever) Just to be fair.

Christine, Meg, and Mme Giry.

Marry Charles Dance, f*** ALW (stage, not movie), kill Robert Englund.

Uhm...new round anyone?
the Dario Argento version, the Phantom of Manhatten version, and the Herbert Lom version. And no, you cannot just outright kill them all!

M- Lom version (but kill the midget), F- Phantom of Manhatten and K- the Dario Argento
I'm half tempted to just f*** the Argento version since Julian Sands was kinda hot(ish) in Rose Red (y'know, without the godawful wig), but I'd be afraid of catching bubonic plague from all the rat screwing he does. The Phantom of Manhatten just needs to DIE, but he's less gross and creepy than Sands. I guess. He still just pisses me off. I slightly hate the Lom version just because it's so bad and so screwy, but he offends me the least of the 3 of them.

Hmm...this is a hard one.

Marry: Phantom of Manhatten F***: Herbert Lom Kill: Dario Argento version

I was going to f*** Julian Sands too, but good point with the bubonic plauge thing...ew.

Marry Herbert Lom, f*** Dario Argento version (hey, takes more than a lil' bubonic plague to scare me off!;)), kill Phantom of Manhattan.

Leroux, Kay, and ALW. The Holy Trinity of Phandom. GO!

M-Kay F-Leroux (A lot) K-ALW (sorry sweetie, loves ya but no comparison!)

M - Leroux, F - ALW, K - Kay

But I love them all! <3

M - Kay, F - Leroux, K - ALW

Round of the secondary characters!
the Rat Catcher (Robert Englund or Argento version, your pick), Piangi, and one of the managers (again, your choice of version)

M: Martin Barton (Manager from the Robert Englund version played by Bill Nighy) F: Piangi K: the Ratcatcher (he's creepy)

M: Piangi, F: Andre from the '04 version, K: the Argento version ratcatcher

JH....I think this game may have died as well....

We just don't have enough active people on this spot...

I'll play if we want to keep the game going :)

Marry: Piangi
F***: Firmin from the '04 version
Kill: The ratcatcher from the Argento version.

I'll play, if anyone is still on this spot... *sobs*