In the new film coming out soon, are Merry, Pippin and 또는 Haldir in it?

 potcblackadder posted over a year ago
next question »

호빗 답변

slash5 said:
No i think that those 3 will not be in Hobbit. Beacuse LOTR adventure is many many years later when Bilbo is already old. In Hobbit, Bilbo is young that means those 3 werent even born yet. Well...Merry and Pippin they did not born yet. I forgot who Haldir is. So i think they will not be in Hobbit.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I would now like to have a little cry......:(
potcblackadder posted over a year ago
*
But - Elijah is back in the Hobbit 영화 as Frodo... So, anything is possible: link
HobbitMovieCoUk posted over a year ago
*
this is sad. Pippin was my fave hobbit in LotR. :(
girly43 posted over a year ago
Book-Freak said:
No.

The Hobbit happens about twenty years before Merry and Pippin are born. As for Haldir, I wouldn't think so, as they don't travel through Lothlorien, but there are opportunities for him to make an appearance. Apparently Galadriel is in Rivendell at this point, so he might accompany her as a guard, 또는 he might appear in the battle of the five armies (though I highly doubt that - Thranduil doesn't get on with Rivendell 또는 Lothlorien so he wouldn't want to fight with them.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
girly43 said:
Sadly no. The Lord of the Rings happened when Bilbo Baggins was 111 years old!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »