이 질문에 답하기

스위니 토드 질문

Who do 당신 think is worse: Benjamen Barker 또는 Judge Turpin?

I know all the Johnny depp 팬 girls are gonna be bitching about this, but i think Mr. T. I know he 로스트 his family, but he was killing innocent people. I don't mind that sort of thing, but i start to when it gets pointless. Why was he killing all those guys anyway? And i didn't like how he was so consumed 의해 hatred that he wasn't even doing it for his family (he didn't even remember what Lucy looked like)

I somehow thought that the judge was the better person. Don't get me wrong, he is a bit of a nympho-romantic, and what he did to Benjamin and his family was wrong, but i think he seems remorseful of it. Why else would he raise the child of the woman he raped? I think he obviously regretted what happened and taking care of Johanna was a way of atoning for it. At least he cared about her safety, unlike her good old dad.
 Who do 당신 think is worse: Benjamen Barker 또는 Judge Turpin?
 MasterOfFear posted over a year ago
next question »

스위니 토드 답변

ShadowQueen013 said:
I think Turpin will always be worse than Sweeney. Yes it may be wrong for Sweeney to kill people to get his revenge but remember that story took place centuries 이전 and who knows, maybe people just did crap like that back then (idk). I feel that Turpin is terrible because he sent Benjamin to a jail in Australia for 15 years for comitting no crime. And have 당신 ever noticed Judge Turpin's house? I mean cmon his walls are covered with people who are practically nakid! And he has 책 from all around the world with drawings about anything a man would like to do with a woman...(thats creepy if 당신 ask me) Plus he sent a little boy to be hung 의해 the neck until dead and he didnt even know whether the child was guilty 또는 not. And at least Sweeney wasnt ruining the lives of people with families like Judge Turpin did. And maybe Sweeney just didnt WANT to remember what Lucy looked like because it would make him feel worse about himself. And I've said this for the 질문 about Johanna but Turpin sent her to an asylum for no reason (it seems like a pattern to me) and how do we know that Turpin wasnt killing innocent people? 당신 dont get to see much of Turpin in the movie but he has probably punished the innocent through court (I really dont know about that but it could have happened) And Sweeney did care about her safety.Remember,who was the one who came up with the idea to get Johanna out of the asylum? Sweeney was. I know Sweeney almost killed Johanna at the end of the movie but thats just because she was dressed like a boy and she saw Sweeney kill Turpin. I see what 당신 mean 의해 asking this question,but I think Benjamin is a better person.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
So killing people for no reson is justifiable just because it took place a long time ago. Allot of the most notorious killers were around long ago, does that make them innocent?
MasterOfFear posted over a year ago
*
Just because someone is perverted doesn't make someone a completley horrible person (he's a guy, they always keep 책 like that)
MasterOfFear posted over a year ago
*
당신 do have good points. And I dont think killing innocent people is good just because it was long 이전 I just meant 당신 dont know what kind of stuff like that happened back then. And I do think that Sweeney thought he was bad because he said "we all deserve to die,even 당신 mrs lovett even I" but its just my opinion that Benjamin is a much better person.
ShadowQueen013 posted over a year ago
PaulInDaHood said:
Well it's hard to say who's worse, but remember that the Judge kept Johanna locked up, didn't seem to care for her happiness, spied on her, and wanted to MARRY her! It seems as though he only raised her since he thought she'd be pretty, like her mother.

Just saying.
select as best answer
 Well it's hard to say who's worse, but remember that the Judge kept Johanna locked up, didn't seem to care for her happiness, spied on her, and wanted to MARRY her! It seems as though he only raised her since he thought she'd be pretty, like her mother. Just saying.
posted over a year ago 
*
He's like Nathan Wallace from Repo, keeping her locked up because he's over protective. That's why he wanted to marry her, so that no man would ever do so and hurt her. People need to be 더 많이 understanding toward both sides.
MasterOfFear posted over a year ago
next question »