Pretty Little Liars Recap: Say Cheese 

fans can attest, it’s not uncommon to shout think “WTF?” during any given episode of the ABC Family drama — and Tuesday’s hour presented what might have been the WTF-iest moment in the series’ history.

: New Clues About the Girls’ Lives After the Big Time Jump

I’m talking, of course, about Spencer’s opening nightmare, in which a creepy young dancer lead her through the catacombs of Radley in an attempt to deliver some sort of message. Spencer claimed the girl reminded her of a young Alison, but I know I’m not the only person who got major flashbacks to

during that freaky little ballet. (Note to Spencer: If you see a well, 

A follow-up trip to Radley with Hanna confirmed Papa DiLaurentis’ assertion that Charles is dead, giving birth to a new theory: Someone Charles was close with is now pretending to be him — and it turns out that “someone” might just be Lesli. That’s right, Mona’s “pal” Lesli was 

a patient at Radley, long enough to know Charles 

Bethany Young, and Lesli was none too pleased when Mona told her what the girls discovered.

Fortunately, the hour wasn’t a total nightmare for Spencer. She bumped into her old sponsor Dean — who, unfortunately, wasn’t wearing his

costume — and was able to get out of her head for a little bit. He also gave her his number, though I don’t think Spoby fans should start freaking out just yet. (Or do. Since when does anyone listen to me?)

PICTURE IMPERFECT | I love Aria, but there’s got to be something loose in that girl’s head. She’s been out of captivity for like five minutes (maybe 10) and she’s already taking field trips to creepy junkyards with Clark, a guy she 

knows. I’m just thankful she politely turned down his offer for a date; the last thing she needs is to jump into a relationship with yet another guy who’s probably stalking her. Of course, it was the discovery that Clark might have accidentally photographed “A” that really got Aria’s attention. (Side note: Did anyone else’s ears perk up when Clark mentioned the photography contest? I’m thinking Aria will be an L.A. lady after this season’s five-year time jump.)

THE EMANCIPATION OF SARA | Despite the focus on Lesli, this week’s episode did nothing to squash my suspicions about Sara. Per Emily’s suggestion, and with a little extra help from Caleb, the pixie-haired enigma took the first steps in getting herself legally emancipated from her mother. (You know, the mother we

haven’t seen and probably doesn’t even exist.)

possibility that Alison’s trip to church camp won’t be a complete disaster? Or that Papa D. isn’t already planning on burying Lorenzo next to Charles?

* I love that we now know Spencer’s mom works out at Curves. (And don’t you forget it! It could be a clue!)

* Am I the only person who didn’t know Caleb owned his own web design company?

fans, what are your thoughts on Lesli now that we know she might be connected to Charles? Drop a comment with your latest theories below.

WTF is right… But does anyone else get the feeling that Leslie is just working for someone? She seemed more scared than angry from her tone

Definitely a WTF moment with Spencer, but it’s why i love this show so much! This is definitely a fave episode of mine.

Lesli is definitely a creep, but I can’t decide if its too early for her to really be ‘A’ or is she just another red herring?

I don’t know, i’m not totally trusting Sara, but I’m not as against her as everyone seems to be.

oh and can Lorenzo just leave, he’s probably one of the more irritating new love interests they’ve introduced.

Anyone else notice that big clown head turning slowly behind Aria while she was taking pictures at the junk yard…. super creepy!… and what was that about????

So I guess the writers just love making the girls accuse every single person on this show to be “A” or know “A” somehow and then completely doing a 360 and making all that info they get irrelevant. In no particular order; Mona (was actually real) Toby, Paige, Mona again (lol), Alison (are the girls this stupid? nvm they have been since s1), Jenna, Noel, Ian, Lucas, Andrew, Charles, Cece, Wilden, Ezra, Spencer (was to find Toby but still), and now Leslie. All these people had a reason but it gets stupid after this many fake outs, lousy writing in my opinion. But Leslie? She was in one friggin episode prior to this and that “she was in Radley” plot does not cut it for me – even though that girl does have problems.

The girls accusing everyone, only to have them to do a total 180 is… pretty much the show’s jam, yeah.

I don’t blame them. Considering how many people have turned out to have hidden agendas, it’s a small wonder that they trust anyone at this point. Anytime the show gets a new character, it almost always turns out they’re working for someone else. There’s a small part of me that just wonders if crossing the town line into Rosewood just sets you against the Liars and everyone is actually A.

Yeah, that’s my biggest gripe about the show—everyone with a pulse gets set up as a red herring and it often makes the writers look as though they’re flying by the seat of their paints with no real long form story mapped out(I know, Marlene has said infinitum that she knows how the show ends but I no longer believe a lot of what she says considering she’s often all talk with little payoff). You can go ahead and start the countdown to when Toby’s new partner is suspected of being A. Before it’s over with, this “season of answers” will be just another season of more questions.

The tatoo girl is the same tatoo girl in The big bang theory show.

I think Creepy Dancer aka Maddie Ziegler is a young Leslie

TOTALLY forgot that was Maddie! Thanks for the reminder.

Personally, I think everyone is “A”. There have been too many people working for so called A, even if it was to protect someone else. I think there is someone manipulating everyone into being an “A” at various moments.

I love Lorenzo and wish Lesli and Sara would disappear.. Like Clark to. Are they going to do anything about Varjack and Holly Golightly?

Really confusing. Not all LGBTQ Characters on #PLL are evil(ie. Shana and Jenna)or duplicitous(Allison). C’mon; enough with the stereotypes!

First it has nothing to do with her sexuality and we don’t even know what that is for sure at this time.

It’s the fact that these extra characters like her and Lesli are thrown in the mix and take up screen time that could focus on the liars and not the secondary characters

I also am not a shipper – relationships aren’t a big deal only secondary but I do like them showing alisonhaving a relationship or connecting with someone since the girls ignore her

Ok never mind about my second comments thought your comment was a reply to my comment

I had no clue about Caleb’s company either. And I lol’d about Spencer’s mom working out at curves….really?!

So did we ever figure out for sure who Red Coat was because I’m thinking it could be Leslie. As for the rest, idk, to many rabbit trails….

No, CeCe was only red coat during the episode where Ali asked her to dress up as Red Coat so that they could stop Emily from being sawn in half. That was part of an act. But CeCe did kill Det. Wilden. We still never got a real answer as to who the actual Red Coat is.

I thought this was the season of answers. Only one worth mentioning that A might be a girl. I agree with someone who said the girls aren’t that smart. They think A is someone different in every episode.

I m freaked…the dancing girl wont leave me alone

I personally don’t like Sara Emily can do so much better. Sara is a bit creepy. I don’t think the show is giving enough clues. We get misled every week to keep the suspense going. I don’t like Alison. I’m use to her being “dead” now. Clark is weird. Aria is dumb for running off by herself. Now that Leslie if she happened to be A I’d understand. She’s clearly nuts. I just want to know a definite answer to who A is and why he or she is doing this.

Emison needs to happen soon. All these new characters are taking too much screen time. More focus needs to be put on the girls and not on these new relationships.

Did anyone else notice all the masks in the tattoo parlor!?! They looked like A’s creepy masks.. I don’t think Leslie is A only because the writers have said they’ve left tons of clues as to what is happening and she is a newer character and nothing up until recently has ever been mentioned about her.

I think Mona was trying to get caught. Was she really trying to sneak in a make that much noise when she knew Hanna and Spencer would be there…?

OF course we think everyone is A at this point…… it’s like how you can’t trust anyone but Chloe on 24 either. It’s just how the show goes.

I’m sticking to my guns, Hanna is A!! To me it would be pointless to have the show go on this long and then have A not be one of the Liars!!!

WHEN will we have REAL answers? It’s complete nonsense… Now they tell us Leslie is A? Really…? WTF -.-

Blind Item: Crossover Event Eyed for Fall — and It Will Blow. Your. Mind.

Sharon Osbourne on Hiatus from CBS\' The Talk Due to \'Extreme Exhaustion\'

Blind Item: Will This Be the Fall\'s Most Divisive Television Event?

1Blind Item: Will This Be the Fall\'s Most Divisive Television Event?519

3Blind Item: Crossover Event Eyed for Fall — and It Will Blow. Your…85

4Matt\'s Inside Line: Scoop on The Flash, Teen Wolf, Bones, Once…76

5Fall TV: Supergirl vs. Young Batman, and Monday\'s Other DVR Dilemmas74

Blind Item: Crossover Event Eyed for Fall — and…

Outlander Casts Harry Potter Actress as Season…

House of Cards Adds Neve Campbell as Series…

MythBusters Summer Return Date Set; Watch…