원스 어폰 어 타임 Most Beautiful Girl Contest. Round 5. Pick your LEAST beautiful girl.

This question is now closed
39 fans picked:
Milah
   21%
Donna
   21%
Jack
   13%
Abigail/Kathryn Nolan
   10%
Evil Queen/Regina Mills
   8%
Young Cora
   8%
Blue Fairy/Mother Superior
   5%
Snow White/Mary Margaret Blanchard
   5%
Nova/Sister Astrid
   3%
뮬란
   3%
Eva
   3%
Belle
   3%
Emma 백조
no votes yet
Cinderella/Ashley Boyd
no votes yet
Red Riding Hood/Ruby
no votes yet
Aurora/Sleeping Beauty
no votes yet
 JellyBean404 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

48 comments

user photo
JellyBean404 picked Milah:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17. Anita
18. The Blind Witch
19. Cora/Queen of Hearts
20. Maleficent
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
It is strange how only villains have been eliminated so far. I understand Maleficent and Cora but the blind witch and Anita are a bit prettier then some of the good guys. If Regina and Jack get bumped off before Donna, the Blue Fairy, and Kathryn I'm gonna call bias. That is if we are in fact talking about physical beauty not internal beauty.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
^ Yeah, I will too. I don't like Jack much, but compared to some she's perfection. I'm gonna take a break from voting for Cindy to vote for Donna.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^^yeah, sure.. Is that easier than to accept that really gina is not beautiful? For some of us, ouat fans. Deal with it, for me: she's not hot.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
magichand picked Donna:
^Just because you don't like the charachter, doesn't mean you should insult the actress who plays her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^Where does it say "Lana" in my comment?! It says: Gina! read first, then write.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
magichand picked Donna:
^When it comes to beauty or looks, Lana is the same as Regina.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^so all the others that voted out Anita The Blind Witch Cora/Queen of Hearts Maleficent and the ones saying Donna or Kathryn should be kicked off fast are insulting the actresses too?

well.. I guess this pick is about insulting OUAT actresses then.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
This pick is about Physical beauty. I've seen plenty of comments about Regina, Milah and Jack saying things like "she's kind of pretty, but she's just plain ugly on the inside". Weather you believe that's true or not doesn't matter because it has nothing to do with their personality just their looks. For example I don't find Hook all that attractive but I can't pretend he's not a good looking guy. You don't have to believe that Gina more beautiful then everyone else, (heck I don't rank her at the top ether) but Lana is undeniably an very attractive lady.

Yes, most beautiful picks are superficial and frankly insulting to the actors. Much like beauty pageants, no one cares about how beautiful Ms. Mississippi is on the inside it all about whats on the outside.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
Frankly I don't care how messed up Gina is on the inside. Here I'm talking about beauty. Here the image of her sagging breasts and her round tummy showing in those tight dresses pops into my mind. Also the creepy makeup and the mad-punker hairstyle.

really... I would have rather kept this thoughts to myself, and resume to my first comment. But it just pisses me off that people think ouat fans pick gina as least pretty because she's evil. maybe some do. I can only speak for myself. I pick only looks here.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
I have to agree with you there. Some of the more ridiculous Evil Queen outfits just aren't flattering. However, I love her all-business Storybrook outfits and her pre-killing-her-huband outfits are gorgeous especially the riding outfit in We Are Both.

I feel the same about Rumps. I've had a crush on Robert Carlyle since the Full Monty, but in FTL in find him absolutely repulsive. The flakey skin, the creepy laugh... it gives me the creepy crawlies. Of course in Storybrook he's transformed into the wonderfully charming, thickly accented Rob.

When I'm doing these most beautiful picks I tend to take the more generous approach and try to think of them at their most attractive moment.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
Kristin Bauer is gorgeous... and she was kicked out first! I mean... c'mon!
look at her:

link

is this how the ugliest of them all looks?
link
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
KataraLover picked Jack:
or Milah
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
snowandcharming picked Nova/Sister Astrid:
donna is pretty
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
@claudia_bb
At no point on OUAT does Maleficent look the way Kristen does in those photos. You mentioned Gina having some unflattering outfits. I'm not sure what Mal did to piss off the wardrobe department but they were not kind to her.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^thank you. that's exactly what I was saying, when @magichand accused me of having something against Lana.

hey I'm just talking about the Characters here. And their Look.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
I am so sick of the 'sagging breasts and her round tummy' crap. How is that not insulting the actress. I get it, you don't like her, you don't think she's pretty, but you don't have to be such a jerk about it. Do you know how annoying and offending it is to read comments like that. Go ahead and say you don't think she's attractive, I don't care, but can you leave it at that and not bash her like that? In case you forgot some people on this spot actually like her, and don't appreciate comments like that.
And how the heck are her breasts saggy (why do we even have to bring boobs into this one?)? I don't see how these are saggy; link
link
link
And then there's the 'round tummy' comment. If Regina is fat then what is skinny? Are all of these actresses supposed to be paper thin? Lana is an actress not a model. Regina isn't fat, at all--everyone has at least a little tummy, people need some fat to be healthy. And honestly, even if she was a bigger woman she'd still be pretty, just because someone is heavier does not mean they are ugly. The last part about the make up and hair isn't too offensive, but I'd still like to say that she's the evil queen not the glittering fairy of rainbows. Her make up isn't supposed to be cutesy it's meant to be creepy, and creepy (in my opinion) doesn't necessarily mean ugly.

And it pisses me off when people don't know how to be nice when stating their opinions. I'm sorry, but that whole comment bugged me a little (maybe I'm over analyzing here but) not only was that an insult to Regina, but also to Lana and heavier people (weather that was your intent or not, it was an insult to all of the above. I have yet to see you say anything kind of Lana) as well as a giant middle finger to her fans. You could've left it at 'I don't think Regina is attractive and it's because of her personality, but her looks' you didn't have to call her fat.

This is pretty much why I hate picks like these so much, it gives people the opportunity to go crazy with the insults. It gives them an excuse for it. And opens the actresses and characters up to ridicule. I know not everyone does it, but a handful of people who do kind of ruin it for other fans. I have been picking Cindy this whole time (except this round) and have not insulted Cindy at all, I have the decadency to keep it to myself. I don't mean any offense to the asker of the pick, she did nothing wrong, it's the voters.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
Hey, as I've said before: you all pissed me off with your: Oh, gina's gorgeous. there's no reason to vote for her as not pretty. that's just the stupid fans that don't understand the question and vote basted on inner beauty.

there ARE reasons. I've stated them. So.. just deal with it!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
I think it's more annoying to scroll through a page and see a spew of insults spoken against a character you really like than to see posts about how pretty a character you don't like is. I don't get all upset when people call Charming hot, I scroll past it and get on with my life. I don't get how people complimenting their favorite character is annoying. It's so much harder to ignore insults made against something you really like that to skim past complements to a character you hate.

Again there is a respectful way to state your opinions and a disrespectful way. I am sorry, but calling someone fat and saying they have saggy breasts isn't the most respectful vocalized opinion I've read. Lose the attitude that is really irritating. Geez. Not once have I given you attitude, and I apologize if that's how you interpreted it, that's not how I meant to come off. And before any assumptions are made, I'm not yelling either.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
Where have I said gina is fat?! No-were! you really like to play the victim, don't you?

I DID say the super-tight dresses she wears show off a round, unaesthetic tummy. I thought we were talking beauty, right?!! LOOKS. I didn't make this pick. It looks unaesthetic.

In the first picture you gave: her boobs ARE saggy. Normal boobs shouldn't be that low.

you go saying there are no LOOKS-related reasons to vote gina off, that is bias. And when I come and give you my reasons you're all pissed off. YOU'VE ASKED FOR IT. here they are! DEAL WITH IT.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
KataraLover picked Jack:
zanhar1 I have to say that third picture of Regina you linked she actually to me looks kind of ugly. But actually I have to say Regina's looks are starting to grow on me.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
@Claudia 'and her round tummy showing in those tight dresses' That is technically calling someone fat isn't it? Round tummy is usually used to describe bigger women.

I was not the one who said that. I said some fans pick based on a dislike of character. And someone on your pick did vote that they based their picks on favorite characters.If it wasn't you all you had to say was 'I'm not voting biasedly' I would have believed it. Again I never asked for reasons, I just had the misfortune of reading them. Can we not cuss? I said pissed once (twice now) and I shouldn't have, so can we quit with the swearing, not necessary. And neither is the attitude, I will ask nicely, can you please drop the attitude and talk to me maturely.

@kataralover Yeah that 3rd one wasn't her best shot. That's good ^_^
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
You walked into this discussion with an attitude, so you drop it first.

No, it does not mean she's fat. It means she doesn't have a flat stomach and shouldn't wear hose dresses if she wants to compete as most beautiful.

You can look nice with round shapes. Best example: Belle. She looks gorgeous, aesthetic.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
No I did not. If you read my comment I said I did not intend for my comments to be read in a sassy tone of voice and apologized if it sounded that way. Furthermore the italics are there to add emphasis not attitude and my intended overall tone was supposed to be more monotone. I already did, I never had one. This whole argument was meant to be read more monotonously. In fact I have been sicerly apologizing and saying please upon making requests despite feeling utterly disrespected and insulted. Not saying you have not been offended either.

Well it sure sounded like you called her fat. Can you please be more clear when bringing something up like that.

Basically what I'm saying is, let's just stop for a minute, cool down and discuss this again more kindly. I don't like fighting with people over the net, and I'm quite sure you don't either. If you want to work with me (meaning any attitude from either of us is dropped) I'd be more than happy to work with you. Frankly the two of us managed to blow this whole thing out of proportion and I don't think it's a good idea to continue any further discussion like this.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
magichand picked Donna:
Claudia_bb: Just so you know, being sexy doesn't mean looking pretty. So what if Regina has round tummy? That doesn't make her less sexy.ž
Here is a proof: link
link
She has tummy, but she is still smokin' hot.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
And Donna is ugly? Isn't she sexy too? Or Maleficent?! Are they ugly? Aren't they sexy?
maybe the whole pick is wrong then. I don't see why it's not fair to pick gina, but it's fair to pick other gorgeous women.

I get it! you all have your reasons. us, the ones voting for gina, have ours too. so back off.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
Which one of us are you talking to?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
magichand picked Donna:
zanhar1: Every time when i have a point, she changes the subject. Now that i explained what means for being sexy, she now commsnts about how '' we think that Donna'' is not sexy
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
Okay I'll admit I don't find Donna that attractive. But Mal, I was sad to see her go. Milah too. I've been voting for Cindy this whole time.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
hey! you vote someone off too. I vote gina. You have your reasons, I have Mine. How are things different?
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
I never said you couldn't vote Gina off. I just don't understand where you're getting this from.

And can I please get a response to; Basically what I'm saying is, let's just stop for a minute, cool down and discuss this again more kindly. I don't like fighting with people over the net, and I'm quite sure you don't either. If you want to work with me (meaning any attitude from either of us is dropped) I'd be more than happy to work with you. Frankly the two of us managed to blow this whole thing out of proportion and I don't think it's a good idea to continue any further discussion like this.

It's my peacemaking statement, I would like to know if you want to forgive and forget or forgive and start over.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
Hey, as long as I'm not going to read on the next "who's the least pretty" more comments on how ouat fans that vote for gina are stupid and vote not based on looks, but based on inner beauty... all's fine.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
Again that wasn't me calling people stupid. So I guess we'll be fine. So is all forgiven, because if you forgive me I have no problem doing so for you?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
KataraLover picked Jack:
Actually I think the entire time she's dressed in that outfit in picture three she's ugly. In fact the only commercials I saw of her in them she was dressed like that and at first I thought she was ugly. That explains part of the reason I'm not a big fan of her looks.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
@zanhar1 & claudia_bb
I'm afraid this argument is partly my fault I made an observation and an assumption hoping that someone would give me a more reasonable explanation. I'd forgotten how heated this fandom gets on this topic. On the other hand I'm also somewhat wickedly pleased because I was able to get my explanation and so much more. >cue rather sheepish evil cackle<

@zanhar, you may have noticed I had a bit of a discussion with Claudia because her comment lead me to believe that she was voting for Gina based purely on her dislike for the character. However, she was able to convince me that there were other reasons and even though I don't necessarily agree with them I can understand them.

From what i understand claudia believes that some of Gina wardrobe is unflattering to her body shape. Although i don't necessarily agree that she has "sagging breasts" I can see how the cut of the neck line on some of her dresses would give that impression. That third picture you posted, which you admitted was not the best, is a good example of that. The cut on both her and Mal's dress makes it look like their bossisms are just days away from becoming ripe and falling to the ground (bit of humor there).

As for her "round tummy" you yourself admitted that Lana is not a model and the sad truth is that ONLY models truly look good in tight pencil dresses. I am a skinny person, to the point where I was called pencil and toothpick in school. Still I have yet to put on a slinky dress that didn't make me feel as if I was hiding a small barrel near my mid-region.

I personally prefer Gina's more conservative mayor-of-Storybrook wardrobe. The collars are higher and the fabric looser, but it hugs her curves in all the right places (her hips and waist) and the short skirts and tight leggings show off her gorgeous legs. Also the pop of color we get in any clothing she wears when she's not completely miserable (e.i. young Gina, mayor Gina) really brings out her exotic complexion.

Best example: link
link

I believe Lana looks more comfortable it these classier outfits and that can make the difference between beautiful and "not quite right".

I'm telling you all this not to rekindle the argument but to try to explain what I think I learned from claudia. I'd also like to say that claudia never actually said Gina was ugly just that her sort of looks just don't do anything for her.

@claudia_bb
I enjoyed hearing your point of view but you do have a sort of uncompromising attitude sometimes. For example your first comment:

"yeah, sure.. Is that easier than to accept that really gina is not beautiful? For some of us, ouat fans. Deal with it, for me: she's not hot."

It sort of felt like you were looking for a fight. If you had dropped the "yeah, sure" and the "Deal with it" and just explained that you didn't find Regina's look attractive and that you thought her body didn't suit her wardrobe you wouldn't have received such defensive replies.

I actually appreciate your abrupt manner of speaking because it encouraged me to strike up a conversation and i was able to learn your view on things but just so you know this is the "attitude" that zanhar and magichand were referring too.

One last thing. You mentioned Belles outfits and how even with her "round shape" she still looks "gorgeous" and "aesthetic". For the most part I agree with you. I love Belle's cozy thrift shop look. She looks the picture of the young hip librarian and it fits her personality and her body shape like a glove. But even Belle has had her off days. Remember the adventurer outfit from The Outsider?

link

Talk about sagging breasts! If you tripped and fell you might never find your way out. You'd be swallowed by her bulging bossisms. A little vulgar yes, but is not I that brought up OUAT breasts.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^I'll try my best not to be offended by your schooling. You DO sound very offensive with your "let-me- try-to-explain-you-you're-wrong-I-know-wha­t's­-be­st&­quo­t;. You give me indications on how to express myself and everything.. Ok... I'm trynig not to feel offended.

btw. Belle's breasts are very up-high in that picture. That's not sagging. Gosh, maybe it's the age too.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
@kataralover Each to his or her own, I can respect that. It wasn't her best outfit.

@minervadawn Naw it's cool, you wanted a reason, you had the right to ask for some.

Yeah I saw that conversation.

Yeah I can see where she would get that in the last picture. My big thing though is people need to be careful and mindful of how they word things. People here seem to overstep the boundaries of voicing an opinion and being just plain mean. Lol ripe boobies.

I would agree to that, it's pretty much exactly what I was trying to say. And the thing with those models, many of them throw up or starve themselves to maintain that weight. But yeah, sometimes the costume designers need to do some more work. I personally love Gina's cloths, but a few can use some work.

Once again totally agree. I love her mayor wardrobe! simple yet beautiful. Though I love the sparklieness, complexity, and gothic look of her Evil Queen dresses I always preferred madam mayor and her looks to the Evil Queen's. I love Lana in those bushiness suits. They are cute and sophisticated and as you said, outline her body in just the right places, to her advantage without making her look like a slut (not that any of her other outfits did).

That one was actually my favorite Gina outfit. It was so simple yet elegant. Lana actually did do an interview in which she said she was more comfy wearing the mayor's cloths; as the evil queen she confessed that the dresses squeezed the crap out of her lol.

Don't worry I didn't take it as an argument. I welcome other people's opinions.

And just to confirm (no offense intended, so I'll apologize in advance if I do offend you Claudia) that is the attitude I was referring to and I'll admit when given attitude (in real life too) it will make my responses more harsh and out of line. Attitude is a real peeve of mine especially when I am trying to stay level headed.

Thank you for a well thought out discussion mineravadawn.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
@claudia_bb
I apologize if I sounded condescending. I was just trying to point out what sort of things set people, myself included, off. It is difficult to convay tone or intent over the internet. I did not intend to appear "schooling". I hope you understand that I ment no offense. You have every right to express yourself however you want.

You're right "sagging" is not the right word for that dress but it is not as flattering as most of Belle's dresses.

@zanhar1
Thank you for your well thought out reply.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
^Ok, I understand you. Sorry if I offended you myself, that was not my intention. It just really feels that in this club, if you're not a fan of Regina, you're going to get a "special treatment".

I haven't seen the other fans, disliking other characters from OUAT, being so attacked as the non-gina-lovers.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
@minervadawn No problem. That's what I hate about the interpret, tone gets misinterpreted a lot and that is usually the most common cause of fighting over the net.

@claudia That's not true. I don't mean to make you or any other Regina nonfan feel particularly hated.I try to keep things equal. And despite what you may or may not think I don't hate you or Yvonne. I don't necessarily agree with you two but I don't hate you guys. And can you try to understand that you aren't the only ones who feel like they get a special treatment. You don't know how many times I logged off of fanpop after one of these arguments feeling (particularly in regards to Graham's death) like people hated me. It works both ways. Each part of the fandom feels outcasted in one way or another.

Part of it is that people who hate the other characters don't outright call the character they hate ugly, naive, chubby, or in some cases even bitch (that was not you or Yvonne). People tend to respond more negatively to comments like that than comments like 'oh I hate ___." Kataralover on this very pick technically called Regina ugly but no one went off on her because she didn't use name calling. What I'm trying to say is it isn't anything personal.

And I also am not trying to sound like I'm lecturing or full of myself. I'm just trying to hopefully make peace.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
@claudia
Thank you for understanding. I can see how you can feel ganged up on. (you rather valiantly fended off myself, zantar and magichand singlehandedly) The reason I referenced your comment is so that you could avoid offending Gina lovers when you express your opinion. It is a very delicate skill (they are a passionate bunch and easy to set off).

I like almost all OUAT at about the same level. Emma, Snow, Belle, Rumple, and Gina and all equal in my book. I love them all and they all occasionally do things that annoy me. The only characters that I'm not really a fan of are Cindy (I'll admit it I hate her) Charming (because he bores me, but I like him with Snow) and Hook (because his penis joke really turn me off). Now I can sympathize with you there try telling Captain Swan shippers that you don't find Hook attractive, now that's walking into a minefield.

I personally don't like being told that I am wrong in my opinion. I love it when people tell me why they disagree so I can understand why they feel the way they do. But when the refuse to accept my opinion as equally valid even if they don't agree that's when I tune out. I didnt get that impression from you. I felt like you made some valid point that I even agree with to some degree. Thank you for helping me to understand your point of veiw.

@zanhar. We basically agree on most things, although I do agree with claudia in that I'm not a fan of the evil queen dresses, but thanks for backing me up.

posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
I am zantar, king of the jungle.

Anyhow, yeah you held up really well 3 against 1. I know how that feels it's really hard to do, I've been there before.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
minervadawn picked Donna:
^ lol I've been avoiding that mistake this whole time but I finally slipped. : ) What does zanhar mean anyway?
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
xP it's okay I've been called zanhar2 (that became my evil twin) and hamzar lol.

It's my name Zanny and my sister's name.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
KataraLover picked Jack:
Your sister's name is Harry? Oh and my the way I'm a guy. Boy all this because of a difference of opinion? Even the Disney Princess club isn't this bad.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Donna:
No, it's Harli.

Yeah, things get crazy here...
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
claudia_bb picked Evil Queen/Regina Mills:
:/
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
viktoriya773 picked Jack:
I really don't find her even a bit attractive!
posted over a year ago.