Book: I didnt really care for it....spent too much of the time with Bella whimpering over Edward. I didnt even get to enjoy the fact that Jacob was the main 사랑 interest in the novel.
Movie: LOVED IT!!! Possibly even better then the Twilight movie. Taylor did such a fantastic job at playing Jacob that I am re-reading New Moon now, hoping that the 초 time around Bella's whimpering wont be as noticable and that her and Jacob's relationship will make up for the lack of Edward.
As weird as it may sound I think Taylor's portrayal of Jacob may have just caused me to switch teams from Edward to Jacob lol.