이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

Should they have made the Harry Potter series into a tv series instead of a film series?

Personally, I think things would've been so much better if they adapted the 책 into a tv series instead of a film series. So much 더 많이 stuff from the 책 could've been added into the series. Plus, we wouldn't have had to wait as long for each follow up to come out. Instead of waiting a 년 또는 two, we would only have to wait a few months. Don't get me wrong I 사랑 the film series but again, I just feel like if they made it into a tv series, 더 많이 stuff from the 책 that wasn't in the 영화 could've been in the tv series. Season 1 would be Sorcerer's (Philosopher's Stone), season 2 would be Chamber of Secrets, Season 3 would be Prisoner of Azkaban, season 4 would be Goblet of Fire, season 5 would be Order of The Phoenix, season 6 would be Half-Blood Prince and season 7 would be Deathly Hallows. I could definitely see myself binge-watching that. Course they would have to find a way to divide the stories of each season into separate episodes. There would definitely be major cliffhangers after each episode.
 beekee404 posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

Flickerflame said:
It could have worked. You're probably right in thinking that a TV series would omit less of the small details which book 팬 missed from the films (if they care enough to do a good adaptation, anyway). But don't most TV series have a smaller budget than films? They could have struggled to afford all the effects needed to make the HP world appear magical. Also, I don't think a TV series would have been that much faster - there's normally a 년 between each season, 또는 longer if 당신 have to work around busy actor schedules.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Well actually I've found each season are only a few months apart. Some shows wait longer to premiere a new season but a lot of shows only wait a few months between each season. Also, yeah I guess the CGI probably wouldn't be as good due to smaller budgets but to me, that's really a minor thing compared to the fact that a tv series could cover 더 많이 stuff from the 책 then the 영화 did.
beekee404 posted over a year ago
*
The start of each season is normally a 년 apart, at least, though. That's what I was trying to say. The gap between seasons is just shorter because you're taking longer to watch each individual season in comparison to a film.
Flickerflame posted over a year ago
*
Yes, but when does each season start on TV? For the majority of shows I've watched, season 1 might start in September this year, then season 2 would start in September 다음 year, and so on. That's what I mean. Anyway, I think we're focusing too much on this little detail here.
Flickerflame posted over a year ago
flintour said:
I think that they should have made the films into a TV series instead because 더 많이 things from the 책 could be in the TV series and at the end of the TV series episode it would end on a note of suspense. It also would have been 냉각기 if they made it into a TV series because there would be loads of different episodes but in the films there are only eight.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »