she really annoyed me in eclipse!
especially when she kissed jacob & was trying to seduce edward cuz i knew she would go off & kiss the DOG

those ppl (vamps&dogs alike) r her family!!!! i don't care that their super strong and can stop moving vehicles where they stand, they can still die!!! and she loves every mystical creature in her family!!! she's just human and jake made her do it by saying that he was going to TRY to kill himself. what the hell is she SUPPOSED to do??? say "fine Jake, it's better that you do that, save us all the heart ache." NO!!! i may hate Jacob Black, and i may think that he's a self conceded prick, but i would hate her just as much if she said that!!!

*cools down* sorry... she wants to keep her family safe... she wouldn't b able to live if she lost Edward or even THINK that she lost him...so she asked, the same for Jake, maybe not on that same level, but close... i don't blame her for what she did, i'd do the same, (if u hate her because of it then u don't understand... try being in her shoes: ur family is going to fight FOR U and they might possibly die, how would u feel???), in my oppinion, if u even had half a heart, it would go to this girl who is having vampires galore going after her and trying to kill her, they would b fine with killing anyone in their way... bella darlin, i'm with u on this one!!!

i agree totally with Edward901. I would probably be feeling the same way as her in this situation, protect the ones I love.

i think she wasnt over protective. if u love someone as much as she loves edward you would do the same. i know i would. she was just protecting him.

why would you want the people you love to risk their lives... you would've done the same thing and you know it!!

It got a little old after a awhile, because that's basically what her thoughts were throughout the book. But I know that what was going on for her was serious and scary and etc. It got tiring though...just a bit.

i couldn't stand bella in eclipse!

i agree with edward 901