carlisle rox my sox!!

i like both, but i don't know esme enough to say.

I agree with MsECullens. More is said about Carlisle, thus making him easier to like. For me at least.

I like carlisle because without him none of the family member( except jasper hale and alice cullen) would exist. Esme seems like such a sweet woman but then again you here more about carlisle.

You don't read enought about Esme, Carlisle's has a bigger character, they're both sweet and loving characters.