이 질문에 답하기

트와일라잇 시리즈 질문

I'm sorry but I have to ask this, is there anyone else here that HATES Breaking Dawn?????

*
For some of 당신 that don't know, Taylor already stated in an older interview before that he really didn't like the way things ended up in the series for his character!!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
I didn't know that but I didn't like it either he should have bin with Bella :(
megan-ox123 posted over a year ago
*
yes he should have!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
 ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
next question »

트와일라잇 시리즈 답변

mandapanda said:
Well, first. Let's all calm down. LOL I know Breaking Dawn is a very sensitive and controversial topic with the imprinting, babies, and all that good stuff :)

However, I hated Breaking Dawn. LOL The only good thing about it was the wedding, honeymoon, and the last two pages. I liked Bella's power. Everything came full circle. She came in being the physically, weakest character to being the strongest character. That's what the book cover signifies if 당신 didn't know.

Things I didn't agree with: (fasten your seatbelts. This may come off as bashing, but it's not)

-Imprinting. Yes, I get that imprinting is considered a 'beautiful' thing. It's starts off as a brother, a friend, a guardian. But, it could turn into something more. That is the "reason" behind Jacob's intense feelings for Bella. We all know Bella isn't a normal person. She's sometimes very very irrational. So, let me ask 당신 this: If Jacob's feelings were because of Renesmee, then what's the reason for Bella's feelings? It's completely contradictory!

-The characters are completely OOC. Edward is completely out of character. I mean, he would NEVER stoop as low as having Jacob sleep with Bella to give her a baby. Alice is MIA in half the book. Really. If 당신 read all of the 책 back to back, the first three are COMPLETELY different character wise.

-I've said this many times, but it makes no sense that Bella and Edward have a baby. NO SENSE! The logic to the situation that Stephenie Meyer feeds us is ridiculous and illogical. Edward has no flowing blood. No fluids. And, 의해 no fluids, that automatically means no sperm. There is NOTHING swimming upstream.

-Again, I say this everytime a 질문 has to do with Breaking Dawn: All of the books, SM has said time and time again that even though there are 판타지 creatures such as vampire and werewolves, the myths are false. She established that the stereotypical myths were false. She established a new mythology. Yet, in Breaking Dawn, a prophecy was foretold? And it came true? Talk about hypocritical and contradictory!

As 당신 can see, I have major issues with Breaking Dawn. I try not to dwell on it 또는 the future movie and how it will turn out. I think it will be a disaster, but I can't be positive. Judging 의해 the scripts Melissa Rosenburg has 제출됨 involving the Twilight movies, she can even mess up Breaking Dawn's story.. 또는 possibly make it better because Breaking Dawn was rather... ~crazy to put mildly.


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
And once again, 당신 win at life.
katiecain posted over a year ago
*
당신 have to realize that SM is creating her own fantasy. We were told the original story of mythical creatures, SM believes in somthing different.....Who are we to crush her beliefs. I mean I don't agree with her 100% but that is just because we were all told differently then her
stormdaku posted over a year ago
*
Yes. She created her own fantasy. I'm no arguing that point. HOWEVER, she said that all the stereotypical myths were invalid. Yet, she brought a prophecy into the story. It's contradictory from what she established. That's all I'm saying.
mandapanda posted over a year ago
glossygirl125 said:
I do. It's a good book, but goes to hell when Jacob's pov starts. It was completely stupid, and I would have prefered the entire book stayed in Bella's. And then Renesmee! The whole thing about her was just wrong, but the icing on the cake was when Jacob imprinted on her. Seriously SM, that was just wrong.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
okay i'm never gonna hate Jake so the pov isn't really an issue, though i don't think it was a smart 옮기기 to change the pov from bella to jake!!! I hate the book overall!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
i think the jake part was cool i was getting tired of bellas over dramatic 나귀, 엉덩이 anyways
Jacoblackswife posted over a year ago
*
Lmao! I couldn't have said it better, glossygirl125! It was just sick.
Babygirl92 posted over a year ago
*
I loved Jacob's part I was getting sick of Bella's lovey dovey relationship with edward Jake's part was 더 많이 interesting and finally there are some swears in the book like it's not gotta be rated G
megan-ox123 posted over a year ago
RoseBelikov27 said:
I'm sorry everyone to have to say this but Breaking Dawn is the best book in the series. I think Eclipse is pretty bad because Bella saves Edward in New Moon but yet she still can't decide on who she wants? I would have made my mind up just hearing that Edward went to the Volturi. And in Eclipse Jacob uses Bella's 사랑 for him against her.

What a crappy friend!

She should have decided in New Moon that Edward was the one for her.
And stuck to him


She strung along Jacob of course but he fell for it he should have known that Edward would have eventually come back for her and he should have said what was in his 심장 straight away not wait til bloody eclipse to tell Bella.


Jacob get your sh*t together!!!
select as best answer
 I'm sorry everyone to have to say this but Breaking Dawn is the best book in the series. I think Eclipse is pretty bad because Bella saves Edward in New Moon but yet she still can't decide on who she wants? I would have made my mind up just hearing that Edward went to the Volturi. And in Eclipse Jacob uses Bella's 사랑 for him against her. What a crappy friend! She should have decided in New Moon that Edward was the one for her. And stuck to him She strung along Jacob of course but he fell for it he should have known that Edward would have eventually come back for her and he should have said what was in his 심장 straight away not wait til bloody eclipse to tell Bella. Jacob get your sh*t together!!!
posted over a year ago 
*
yes
Lyannab posted over a year ago
*
I dont think there was really ever an issue of Bella not knowing who she wanted...she always wanted Edward.
Hellohoudini posted over a year ago
*
WHAT THE HELL??!!!
RoseBelikov27 posted over a year ago
stephmfan215 said:
i definitely think it ruined the series. i dont get how some ppl thot it was the best!!! when i first read it about half way thru i just put it down and stopped 읽기 for like 2 weeks cuz i was so annoyed 의해 it! at last there is some1 that understands!!!!! the 초 time i read it i thot it was better than the first time around but still not good. im so glad im not alone in this world
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
if 당신 ask me i think ppl like it because its part of the series but i think its the worst of all the books!!! Yes i am so glad i'm also not the only person in this world with these feelings!!! I hated the story in BD and everything was just plain rediculous, totally took away from what made the first three 책 great!!! I hope this doesn't get made into a movie but if it does i sure as hell won't be wasting a ticket on such a piece of c**p as BD!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
i know it killed the characters! it just took away from all the rest
stephmfan215 posted over a year ago
*
i feel the same way!!!
stephmfan215 posted over a year ago
star2894 said:
I HATE that Jacob imprints on Renesmee. That was just wrong. The rest of it was okay.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yes the renesmee thing is just plain stupid and there was nothing about the book that i liked!!! Worst book out of the whole saga!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
i hate that 2!!! in my opinion jacob will always b the guy that loves bella but it will never b enough. not some guy that loves a baby!
stephmfan215 posted over a year ago
*
thanks for siding with me Life_sucks, ya it doesn't make sense!!! jake loves bella, unconditionally i don't care what other 팬 say and she fell in 사랑 with him!!! how the hell does he all of a sudden decided "oh if i can't snag the girl of my dreams, why not go for her love-seed?" It's wrong ppl. WRONG!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
She_wolf said:
I hate breaking dawn too, it is completely different from the other 책 and madee me both angry and sad, because it was a REALLY bad ending to the twilight saga. I cant believe Jacob imprinted on a baby?!? He's bellas girl! It was just Stephenie Meyers way of getting him out of the way of Edward and Bellas romance... which is just plain annoying. And the ending with the Volturi where they all get ready to have a battle, almost made me think "Oh this isnt so bad", until they all just went back 집 without even a fight!!!??? What is with that??
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
당신 hit all the major points there!!! why do 팬 like this book, seriously its terrible!! BD ruined the whole series for the rest of us 팬 of the first 3 books!!! i know the volturi in this one was a HUGE let down and your right how the hell can jake go from being totally in 사랑 with bella to hooking up with her baby ???!!! GROSS!!!! BTW the baby thing is stupid altogether!!! I can't wait to see eclipse in theatres but i'm not wasting a ticket on BD!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
Babygirl92 said:
I do. =P Jacobs' POV sucks. Like really sucks. Total downer. And I even find Bellas' POV kinda dumb.
Eh. Whatever floats Meyers' boat, huh? I really think it could have been better, but I do understand the point of it going to Jacobs' POV. Like, what would she talk about if it was all in Bellas' POV while she was stuck on the 침상, 소파 the whole time, and doing nothing but piss and drink blood? Not the greatest either way.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
naley_fan said:
Yes,sort of. Even though i used to hate it a long time ago. Now i dont really care that much. But still,i think its the worst one.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Hellohoudini said:
No...to me...Breaking Dawn was great!

I loved that everyone got their happy endings. I loved that Bella and Edward got married and had a child. I 사랑 that Bella was changed into a vampire. I 사랑 that Jacob finally got some happines in his life (people get your minds out of the gutter..there wasnt anything dirty going on between him and Nessie) I 사랑 that the 늑대 pack and all the vamps came together to save one little girl.

The only I didnt like about it was that it ended.

♥Team♥Twilight♥
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Not everyone thinks Jacob/Renesmee is gross because it's dirty right now. The problem is he's gonna be like her family until she's suddenly old enough to be with him... Those feelings don't change. Renesmee will have no choice in the matter. She's going to bought up being told constantly that Jacob is the one for her.
katiecain posted over a year ago
*
well first meyer said in an interview that Jake was her 가장 좋아하는 character in the series and then she does this to him!!! Very disappointed!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
I get why 당신 think it's stupid and I agree but come on Hellohoudini's opinion is just as valid and is entitled to it :]
katiecain posted over a year ago
reneemonique said:
i dont hate it,i just dislike it. i mean why do jacobs POV-i got so confused! i think i had to read it 3 times till i got it. I even thought that edward would have just let Bella stay human,it would have been a better story line,and the ending was just so bad. but i gotta admit i did like 읽기 it, stephenie is a brilliant writer:)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i'll agree with 당신 that bella should have stayed human and the storyline was downright terrible but there was nothing great about BD, notthing!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
megan-ox123 said:
Okay I'm gonna be honest, I hated it when he imprinted on Renesmee it just like killed the book the whole time I was just hopin' him and Bella would get together and the 'Kaboom' he's in 사랑 with her Daughter so after that part YES I did hate Breaking Dawn.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
NCISLuverjk93 said:
I didnt hate it but I really disliked how everything ended... idk why but I did. It kinda ruined the series, I mean it didnt meet my expectations :/
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Ya I didn't like the ending it had one of those fairy tail endings when I would've expected it to have a dramatic ending
megan-ox123 posted over a year ago
*
Yes exactly! I mean I didnt want anyone to die, but when characters in Harry Potter did, it made the ending... better LOL
NCISLuverjk93 posted over a year ago
friendsfan101 said:
I guess...
I mean, Jacob actually IMPRINTED on Renesmee? What was up with that? I figured that he'd end up with Leah 또는 something...that seemed to 덮개, 랩 up pretty nicely for Jacob. = (

Also the Jacob POV. I like Jacob, but come on!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
zanesaaomgfan said:
I loved BD! Its my 2nd fave book!!!!!!

*EDIT*

I partly agree with mandapanda with the imprinting and Bella and Edward having a baby and all... but BD wasn't the worse and wasn't the best book. If 당신 read the book, 당신 know Edward has no blood flowing. I asked a few people in my club, they all said that he drank enough blood to reproduce. I thought that that was kida dumb.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
shingkai said:
breaking dawn was my least 가장 좋아하는 in the series. i think it sucks the ending. i would like it if it's a fairy tale i'm 읽기 but it's twilight and i thought SM would build up a great ending because she has already proved herself but she didn't. BD only leaves me frustrated and upset.

the only reason i keep 읽기 it is because i was expecting a big fight with the volturi but that it didn't occure. i feel bad for jake because of the imprinting thing, i guess i'd rather want him to be broken hearted for a moment then find a way to recover but imprinting isn't a solution especially with a toddler involved.

also i hate it when edward was being compared to an incubus because he impregnate bella. well i guess its her only escape goat so she wont be criticize 또는 at least less criticism for there's no way a vampire could make a human pregnant unless he is an incubus in my opinion.

*i do not intend to offend anyone but that's my opinion*


select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
missCullen17 said:
I think a lot of people hate Breaking Dawn because
it has a lot of changes and strange twists for the story.
I think it was a great book, Stephenie really put a lot of her imagination in BD, and like any other author, she has the right to create a new world of fiction.
The reason why I liked Breaking Dawn so much, it's because it was very unpredictable. Every new thing thayt I read I was like "wow! I didn't expect that!" and I like the storys when they don't follow the same line and it makes it boring.
Well that's my opinion, of course.
I'm sure there's a lot of people who disagree with me, and others who don't.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
how the hell can 당신 call it unpredictible??? It was completely predictible!!! Bella got everything she wanted, no hardships and NO TWISTS!!! She has a baby with a vampire, which is stupid because he's actually dead!!! She becomes a vamp and throws everything and everyone in her life away like garbage!!! Just when i think she's gonna come to her senses, stay human, and end up with jake, he hooks up with her damn baby!!!! I'm sorry but like i've mentioned many times before there is nothing remotely good about BD, the worst book ever in the series!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
*
wow jeez calm down! I just maid it clear that for me Breaking Dawn was great and I have my reasons to like it. Maybe we all 사랑 the twilight series, but that doesn't mean we have to 사랑 ALL of it. And maybe it wasn't unpredictable for you, but I as sure as hell didn't see Bella having a baby, like 당신 said, it's stupid because Edward is DEAD. And is so obvios that you're team Jacob, so maybe that's another reason why 당신 hate so much BD. I'm, on the other hand, completly Team Edward
missCullen17 posted over a year ago
*
regardsless of which character i thought bella should have went with in the end, the book is still a HUGE mess!!! And i'm not the only person with these feelings!! it's fine if u wanna like it ur another twihard so what's new!!!
ForsakenMoon19 posted over a year ago
sapherequeen said:
I don't necessarily hate it....but I never got any enjoyment out of it, except for Renesmee sometimes and Rosalie vs. Jacob moments.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah same here.
zanesaaomgfan posted over a year ago
next question »