이 질문에 답하기

트와일라잇 시리즈 질문

What was Charlie's reaction when he found out Bella was pregnant/ first heard about Renesme?

I don't exactly remember. It suddenly hit me when I realized that Charlie should be suspicious when Bella was married in August and had a child in September, 당신 know? He would have thought(known really) that Bella was pregnant at the wedding and when Edward and Bella came to tell him that they were getting married too. He said he wanted to be on a need to know basis so that means he didn't find out about her being a vamp either. I wonder what his reaction would have been.
 twilight_quirk1 posted over a year ago
next question »

트와일라잇 시리즈 답변

etf4life said:
he was confused,he didn't even know that bella was pregnant because she never told him until she was born.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
elstef said:
He never knew that Bella was pregnant, 또는 that Renesme was Bella and Edwards biological daughter. They told him that she was Edwards neice, and that she came to be raised 의해 them after her parents died. I think Charlie knew something was up, especially since Renesme has the same eyes as Bella and Charlie, but he let it go because he was in a sort of "dont ask dont tell" mood at that point. All he mentioned was that Bella and Edward were young to be parents and that he was young to be a grandfather, but he felt better when they pointed out that Carlisle was a grandfather too.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thnx i totally forgot that he bnever knew Bella was preggers
twilight_quirk1 posted over a year ago
dragon3 said:
Charlie knew something was up,He knew that they were lying.He could tell that she was his granddaughter because she looks like both Bella and Edward,she has his curls.
Charlie is Charlie, he acts like an idiot but is hurt when he is lied to. Charlie knows about 늑대 and vampires, he chooses to ignore it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
i thought he only knew about 늑대 cause of Jacob, but not 뱀파이어 right?
twilight_quirk1 posted over a year ago
*
Billy told him everything about 늑대 that includes vampires,I suggest 당신 re read breaking dawn.It is the reason that Charlie doesn't talk to Billy for a bit. The two are connected.
dragon3 posted over a year ago
Flickerflame said:
When they first introduced Nessie to him, they claimed that she's Edward's niece. Charlie got suspicious because he noticed that she shares Bella's human eyes. They then admitted that she's their daughter, because he asked them not to lie to him. He was freaking out at first, trying to work out how it happened because a normal pregnancy would have been showing heavily the last time he saw Bella. But he eventually pushed all the freaky issues aside after Bella reminded him he'd asked for a need to know basis.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »