I don't know. I can only answer this after I've seen New Moon. Than I can compare the two 영화 and make my own conclusion. But I think it's too soon to make judgements. Let see first how the 초 movie works out, they could always ask one of the directors of the first two 영화 to make Breaking Dawn...
In some ways I think yes, because it's a whole new experience each time. But I guess we'll never know if it was for the best 또는 not, because it's not like we can go back in time and change anything.