What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

호빗 Do 당신 think Peter Jackson was biased against Thranduil?

17 fans picked:
No. i dont think so.
No. i dont think so.
   65%
i hated thranduil so i really dont care.
i hated thranduil so i really dont care.
   18%
PJ is never biased against ANYBODY! (me: thats...
PJ is never biased against ANYBODY! (me: thats what 당신 think)
   12%
yes, and for many reasons.
yes, and for many reasons.
   6%
YES. the most biased EVER.
YES. the most biased EVER.
no votes yet
no 코멘트
no 코멘트
no votes yet
 girly43 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

6 comments

user photo
No. i dont think so.
Flickerflame picked No. i dont think so.:
The story was just being told from Bilbo's POV and he was loyal to the dwarves.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
i hated thranduil so i really...
AnastasiaGordy picked i hated thranduil so i really dont care.:
I ddn't know that there are so many Thranduil haters! :)
Hello friends!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
yes, and for many reasons.
girly43 picked yes, and for many reasons.:
he was being very biased in many parts.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
No. i dont think so.
pumpkinqueen picked No. i dont think so.:
Well frankly, he gave him more screen time then he should have had. So you can't complain on that part. He wrote him much like Tolkien did, from the main story and the side ones. Frankly he gave the elves way to much screen time and didn't give the dwarves enough. Also, as Flicker said the story is suppose to be from Bilbo (and the dwarf's) view, so the elves won't be seen in a good light.

Much like Tolkien, I think Peter favored the elves and was biased that way.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
yes, and for many reasons.
girly43 picked yes, and for many reasons.:
@pumpkinqueen What? NO. Thranduil was not like how he was in the book. Thranduil was a decent guy in the book, in the movie he is portrayed as some sort of villain! And in my opinion, the dwarves had a very deceent amount of screen time.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
No. i dont think so.
3xZ picked No. i dont think so.:
In fact, I like him by far better in the movies.
posted over a year ago.