Do 당신 think the chapter "The Prince's Tale" read like a fanfic? 투표 Results - 세베루스 스네이프

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

세베루스 스네이프 Do 당신 think the chapter "The Prince's Tale" read like a fanfic?

354 fans picked:

Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears

69%

Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!

25%

I thought it was OOC and yeah definately as if JK punked it off Fanfic.net

Lady_Hamilton posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

37 comments

	Lady_Hamilton picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: I guess in the end it was about Snape...yay! more screen time...maybe but still, i'm a little borderline on the way the book was written. It felt like a fanfic, but maybe its just that i've read soo much of it that many writers also came to the same conclusion that Rowling devised in her book...sigh...misses snape posted over a year ago.

	PotterGal said: I think some parts, like the epilogue, seemed like fan fic, but i thought The Prince's Tale was amazing! posted over a year ago.

	ilovemichael picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: i dont even know what a fanfic is, so i just chose a random answer posted over a year ago.

	piperpayton22 picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: i know snape was good all along but i dont like the fact that he was in love lily that is so not kool cuz james and lily duh duh and duh so whatever to snape but i think it was off of fan fiction cuz of the sytle but also the part which harry sees the past when his parent dies that is so fanfic cuz i read one with the same words and everything so posted over a year ago.

	kateliness2 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I thought this was a really sad, really good chapter. posted over a year ago.

	Jinx22 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: teah i have read fics similar to it, but she made it so much better! posted over a year ago.

	Serienjunkie91 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I loved that chapter. It was awesome. posted over a year ago.

	Jillywinkles picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: Um, why is there no choice where I can say "no"? That chapter didn't feel like fanfic to me, although the epilogue did. posted over a year ago.

	MioneWeasley545 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: i felt like i was reading fanfic... b/c i never thought she would actually make that stuff true! happy that she did. :D though the whole "everything for lily" thing... sad? I think it was more than just lily. posted over a year ago.

	lucysmileyface picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: i love it...really sad, but wonderful chapter posted over a year ago.

	AutumnKiss picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: No, I really don't think it read like a fanfic. I think it read like the original author. Few fanfic authors have captured Snape. It was great but it was terrible all at the same time. I really loved his character ... so sad. Still, it was a wonderful chapter. posted over a year ago.

	bored2pieces2 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: That book was so sad. God, I was a mess. Every single one of my favorite characters died! I was an emotional wreck. I mean, personally Deathly Hollows was just a suggestion and not what really happened! posted over a year ago.

	Visitor picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I actually thought the entire book read a little like a fanfic... which in my opinion was kinda ok :) The thing with fanfiction is... it usually gives you exactly what you were wishing for but what could never happen in the books. DH was like a fic to me because everything I hoped would happen actually did happen, and so much more :) posted over a year ago.

	Vesper picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: Aw, come on, enough with the bashing! It's not like all books weren't very fanfic-ish, with the ultimate Mary Sue being Harry, with sudden character insertion in the middle of the story (Tonks, Luna), with THE MOST STUPID EPILOGUE EVER. Gimme a break. Snape's story was beautiful. Perhaps even the most beautiful from the whole book - he had his bad moments but he got his redemption. One of very few HP characters with some actual depth. posted over a year ago.

	karababy picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: i read it over and over. but it did sound as if she got it off fanfic posted over a year ago.

	percyandpotter picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: i don't even know what a fanfic is. posted over a year ago.

	ShadowRocksxxx picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: who cares? it was still great! my fave chapter out of the whole book :) posted over a year ago.

	Kraucik83 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: My fave chapter of all books! :) posted over a year ago.

	Shepard14 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I think that some guy boarded a plane and spied on how JK rowling was going to make the neding, then flew BACK to wherever he was from and posted it as a fanfic as close to teh original as possible...hoping to get famous off of it.....hahahah I am just kidding... posted over a year ago.

	Eddiefan picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: Soz but didn't understand question but I have read the book and lked the parts with Snape! posted over a year ago.

	sapiencia picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: No way. I think that part completely hooked the story together. Snape wouldn't be the same without it. Every part of it made me sob for a few days, truthfully. posted over a year ago.

	LoveforSeverus picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I didn't think so... But I was crying so hard. Especially at "After all this time?" "Always." posted over a year ago.

	EalasaidWooster picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I didn't think so. posted over a year ago.

	TheNightHawk picked I thought it was OOC and yeah definately as if JK punked it off Fanfic.net: I think it did. The whole thing struck me as very OOC for Snape, and I was disappointed. Book seven didn't do justice to Snape in the least. posted over a year ago.

	Vixie79 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: If it did read like a FF, it was the best i've read, cuz I've read some BAAAAAAD...BAD...BAD ones. LMAO. posted over a year ago.

	bri-marie picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I don't think it did at all. That's actually one of my favorite chapters. I thought it explained his behavior throughout all seven books in a way that kept the over all theme about how strong and important love is. posted over a year ago.

	NessieCarrow picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: Not really It sound like it should sound sad because that was his life posted over a year ago.

	animesnapefan picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: who cares i mean it wus graet it made me cry T__T so sad!!!! best chapter ever EVER!!!! posted over a year ago.

	frostydragon picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: It explained so much and so much about so many characters. posted over a year ago.

	danilynn92 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: love fanfiction posted over a year ago.

	xElvenPiratex picked Eh? I dunno...who cares it had Snape it!: All I know is I've never read any fanfiction that even came close to involving my emotions that much, so no, I don't think it read like fanfic at all. It was legit. :D posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	PotterLucy picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: I don't care...the Prince's Tale is beautiful posted over a year ago.

	Misguided_Angel picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: none of it read that way to me really. And the prince's tale wasn't ooc because thats the way he was meant to be from the beginning, we just didnt get to know posted over a year ago.

	crazychlo said: The Princes Tale was the best chapter in the entire series IMO, so there is NO WAY that the genius that is JK Rowling can be compared to fanfiction. It was planned from the very beginning, there were tiny hints of it throughout the series, so no, she didn't just get the idea from fanfiction. As Misguided_Angel said, how is it OOC when that has been what his character is all along? posted over a year ago.

	Lackson4ever85 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: Little bit,but is was PERFECT♥ posted over a year ago.

	KitKat71483 picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: Well, it fit with the way he was portrayed and the actions and attitude he had. I've read better fanfic......and I've read much much MUCH worse. LMAO But, it did fit the confines of the story plotline that JKR has created. It brought things together in a way that had meaning and accelerated the plot. posted over a year ago.

	Pinklilyrose picked Even if it did, i think it was great! Still made me pour buckets of tears: Never cried so much at reading a book or even that 1 chapter, it was perfect and nicely done. posted over a year ago.