BY FAR! Dark hair is gorgeous on her <33

Hmm. I just realized that I prefer darker hair on all 3 girls. I guess I just think darker hair tends to look more natural... it definitely suits Haley better than the blonde. She's too pale for light hair.

I totally agree with every word!!!

I like dark hair for all except for Peyton because well Peyton Sawyer to me will ALWAYS be blonde & curly.

In general I like Dark hair. I wish I was a brunette. Instead I'm dirty blonde and hate it. lol

But yeah. Haley looks stunning with Dark hair!

thank you the draker look suits her the lighter make her soooooooo pale for that look to

I prefer her hair lighter and long as it was in season 3 & 4. I think she looked sooo stunning back then. ♥
Only like her dark hair in season 6 when it was long and curly. Her short brown hair in season 5 made her look old though. /:

I think both suit Haley, actually!

Both

BJG inspired my hair actually so id have to go with the darker.

I definitely prefer her with dark hair... but I actually think she pulls off both pretty well.

Maybe that's because she's naturally blonde, but has features and coloring that suits darker hair. Either way- she's lucky. She even looked good when she had reddish hair in season 7.