goin with lucas was a horrible thing to do but i hated it when she was horrible to haley she was trying to make things right but peyton was jus being horrible to her

I don't like Lindsey anyways and I didn't care that she was rude to Haley even though I do like her, Peyton was just mad that she could do that to Nathan b/c he was miserable then

Urg.. I hated her when she did that, Brooke is her best friend - and even though everybody says that it is okay, cause Peyton&Lucas is made for each other, I just don't think it's cool! You don't kiss your best friends boyfriend. And I know Brooke made a move on Lucas when Peyton liked him, but Peyton insisted that there wasn't anything between them?

TriineA i totally agree it was such a sucky thing to do ihated peyton in season one but now i do love her

Yeah.. Love her too (: - and love their friendship!

as well as doing Luke while he was with Brooke

she was asleep when she sed tht but it was still horrible and it ruined her and jake who are great

i dont think the Haley thing was that bad really,

she said i love u lucas when in bed with jake i didn't know that

Peyton was asleep when she said "I love you Lucas". I say things in my sleep when I´m dreaming and I can not control that. That option shouldn´t be considered in this pick.

yeah .. she was asleep, it's not like she could control her feelings while she was dreaming....i think it's terrible that she did that to brooke i do..but lucas did it too and i think she was SO mean to haley..but idk i didnt like peyton as much during the love triangle..but i other than that and once that triangle was over she became one of my (if not my only) favorite characters. ..

Her meaness to Haley was justified - she was sticking up for her friend Nathan, just like i would for one of my friends - because lets face it Haley had acted like a complete bitch to Nathan and deserved bad treatment. It kinda annoyed me that Brooke let Haley off the hook so easily actually...

The "I love you Luke" was out of the poor girl's control...
anywho, everyone has the right to their opinion, lol.

I picked this one cause Brooke was starting to get serious about luke, and was peyton's best friend, so Peyton screwed up royally, lol; but the poor girl was in love (still is). and luke was PERSISTENT!

she didnt mean to say she loved luke when she was with jake, aww i felt sorry for her but kinda happy that she did love luke! ;) yer this one wasnt her fault!
what sg1 said about haley - she was sticking up for nathan - and she wasnt even that bad - she just wanted haley to fight for nathan - she stopped after haley said she wasnt gunna give up!
as for manface - im glad she was horrible to her - it was great to watch - its not as if manface never gave it back!

although i loved the whole LP behind Brookes back, it wa wrong of peyton and it is the worst hing shes done especially to er best friend!

I think if she did say yes to Lucas, both wouldnt be so messed up in season 5. still i think she did the right thing by saying someday, because they were only 19 and had dreams to accomplish. but it really messed up the leyton relationship.

Peyton hated what haley did to nathan, which is why she stuck up for him. Just like luke stuck up to haley. When she came back it's like she expected nathan to just forgive her right away. I was glad peyton stuck up for nate and fronted haley because that pissed me off.

Now i've answered this question before so i'll just post what i wrote on the other pick.

I hated when LP cheated, but don't get me wrong Leyton are meant to be, but i really hated what they did! I think they should've done it better like instead of luke being w/ brooke while sneaking with peyton...he should've atlease broke-up with brooke b4 they even start kissing and stuff...i really didn't like that....i think that would've been less-painful on brooke's part!

Anyways the COCAINE peyton did was so not her! That's why i hated S2 becuase the characters were like not themselves! What peyt did was STUPID and putting her with jake was like, well not stupid, but not the right choice, but i understand that luke just did that cuz peyt was shutting him out and she really needed someone there for her, but it showed a peyton that was always needy when she was with jake and i don't like that kind of peyton! Peyton is a very stong person and she can look out for herself, but S2 she just wasn't that kind of peyton..i knew she was!!

That is out line! even we all now brucas DONT belong she didnt have to have afer!

LIKE WTH IS WRONG WITH YOU SEYTON???
EW!

horrible friend