At the beginning Bethany shouldn't have been in the cast but a Samantha Shelton should. What do 당신 think about that? 투표 Results - 원 트리 힐

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

원 트리 힐 At the beginning Bethany shouldn't have been in the cast but a Samantha Shelton should. What do 당신 think about that?

107 fans picked:

It wouldn't be the OTH we know!

55%

Without Bethany OTH would sucks!

37%

It would have been better, I don't like Bethany!

missfran posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

13 comments

	miss73 picked Without Bethany OTH would sucks!: Samantha is sooooooo ugly for one....Bethany is soooo much prettier than she is...plus she sucked on the videos before they got bethany......god im sooo happy that they found bethany because if not than i probably wouldnt watch it...sorry soo long posted over a year ago.

	Nine00 picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: If she would have been in there from the beginning, i probably wouldn't care. But now i got used to Bethany and she just seems like the perfect Haley to me posted over a year ago.

	Leyton4ever picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: i'm not gonna say the show would suck without bethany, the entire cast is awesome, i think they would still have done well without her, but she is way better than samantha shelton being reagen...ive watched scenes of the unaired pilot and chad and bethany definately had better on screen chemistry than chad and samantha so they made the right choice with bethany posted over a year ago.

	nedmcgee picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: without bethany i doubt the whole chris keller and haley's singing career story line would've happened and i liked that story line!i think chris keller is so funny he kinda brought a light humour to the show posted over a year ago.

	ElliesOwner picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: I agree with Leyton4ever. In factwhen I had watched those unaired scenes, I left thinking I would have hated Haley. Also her and James would've had NO chemistry, I don't think. She was too rough to be Haley, or at least the Haley I know and love. posted over a year ago.

	Supersweet picked It would have been better, I don't like Bethany!: behtany annoyeys me and her face is really manly it would of been better with samatha posted over a year ago.

	Lila856 picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: i don`t like haley but i don`t have a problem w// bethany really i don`t think? & to miss73: IF YOU`RE JUDGING BY PRETINESS, DON`T GET ME STARTED THEN IT`S A WHOLE OTHER STORY HALEY IS NOT PRETTY @ ALL! posted over a year ago.

	georgiapeach91 picked Without Bethany OTH would sucks!: I saw the scenes with Samantha, and they were horrible! OTH would have been way different with her, and I don't think it would have been as good. Plus, I agree with Leyton4ever in that Chad and her had no chemistry, and Samantha would have been AWFUL with James, I can't even imagine. If OTH had any different actors playing the characters i don't think it would be as good. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	sundayymorning picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: Umm, who's Samantha Shelton? Sorry, I'm stupid :] posted over a year ago.

	SawyerxScott picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: i love hales! posted over a year ago.

	Laurra said: i wouldnt really care :s it wouldnt change anything for me posted over a year ago.

	LauraRocks picked It wouldn't be the OTH we know!: that would have been really weird! posted over a year ago.

	ns_23 picked Without Bethany OTH would sucks!: love her ! posted over a year ago.