If I could do anything, I'd make them feel what they made me feel. I'd hurt them emotionally, not physically. I'll learn to forgive, eventually. But I don't forget so maybe I'll keep bringing up that kind of topic just like Brooke did.

I agree with you nem, I just wanted to know where everybody stood on this issue it is a very touchy subject. I probaly have done the same as Brooke but it would take my best friend and my ex a long time. It would take my best friend along time to earn my trust back.

well as much as i hate cheating my biggest weakness is my friends, i can not hold grudges, it just wouldnt last. i would be all 'i hate you, you are low and blah blah woof woof, i will never forgive you, you are so disowned' there may be some bitchiness caus i can do that and it would be hard to move on from that betrayal but i would quickly want her back in my life, i wouldnt stop loving my friend and though i may never be able to fully forgive her and trust her i would need her back but because it would always be there that slight reservation would always be there and i prob would do the occasional catty remark and bring up what she did. but though i would do that i would want to be able to just push my friend away and never see her again, it just wouldnt happen that way though, i really really suck at grudges, and like i said, my friends are my weakness.

i think brooke was so forgiving the first time cause peyton was like a sister to her and brooke was so heartbroken by what happened that she needed someone but the second time i wouldn't of been as forgivng thou

Except i would have never gone after Lucas in the first place with all the signs saying Peyton liked him. But all in all Brooke was alrite in season 1. Season 3 is where she really became a bitch!

the first time i would of been like ok theres no point in faling out but the second time id of kicked her sorry ass

I think Brooke should never have forgiven Peyton the second time. Bestfriends dont do what Peyton did and especially not twice.

Brooke was a bitch in s3? How?
I cant believe that some people think Brooke was the bitch in s3 and not Peyton. Peytons the one who cheated again...was Brooke not supposed to be mad at her?

How? saBRUCAS you know how i feel about this - you know the whole... it was a goodbye kiss cause Peyton was dying! I'm pretty sure we had an extensive..erm..conversation on this!! =] So Brooke's reaction was out of order and really horrible ie totally bitchy!

vv Well OfC we know different truths cause i disagree!

I would have done pretty much the same thing except for P.Sawyer never would have gotten forgiven cause..well she just wouldn't! ^^Now as for that Brooke didn't get mad at Peyton about the kiss she got pissed b/c Peyton told her about her feelings for Luke.Which IMO was a shitty thing to do.You can all play it off as she didn't want to be dishonest but we all know the truth.Nuf said.

I love the lp cheating in s1 but if that happend to me I wouldnt forgive any of them. I cant understand how Brooke did it? I admire her for that.

I think eventually I'd be able to forgive her...as hard as it seems. But we all make mistakes / = And obviously Peyton was remorseful.
And then we can fight our ex-boyfriend haha : D