Why on earth would he?

Wow! somebody picked: "Yes"!

Well....he did threaten to kill her first....it was her (wrong) 'natural reaction.' Henry saved him! :-)

^ Exactly!!

Not killed (and I bolded that because some people may misunderstand), but he deserved to be tangled up like that. After all he picked the fight with her and blamed her for them falling trough. I picked the yes option because it was closer to my true response; he deserved some form of discipline.

Its human nature to try to protect there family. He seen Regina as a threat. She could have easily knocked him out or something to keep him away. There was no need for anyone to die.

@Simpleplan: No he didn't deserve to 'die' Its just that Gina's 'reaction' into doing that...He was blinded by 'hate' and blamed her....

@zylica But it was also Charming reaction no matter how stupid it was. I believe both of them were in the mist of a adrenaline rush also know as the flight or fight response. They just got done with battling and he just lost his Wife and Daughter. Regina almost lost her soul. The both of them were wrong to attack the other.

Charming is a fighter so yes his natural reaction was to fight .
@ Zanhar1 Charming didn't deserve punishment!!!
He did nothing wrong and I'm glad Henry walked in and saw Regina for
what she is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

On the country he did. You don't just yell at someone fir something they didn't do and expect to not at least get yelled at back. >.>

Poor charming, he just reunited with his wife and daughter now they got separated again :'(

I think both of them were in difficult situation and they were not handle it well, charming threaten her so it make sense if regina fight back, but he doesn't deserve to be kill, he did try to help her

Seriously it's getting harder to be neutral in this spot

He didnt wanted to help her in a 1st place. I never liked him, and when he wanted Regina killed, i dislike him even more. He always judges a charachter and he doesnt know nothing about his/her past (Rumpel and Regina)
He always thinks he is some big hero, well i think he is not.
I liked that scene when Regina crushed to the wall and told him he is NOT the heroic prince.

(usually i dont write this kind of comments about charachter i dislike, but after all of this spots about Regina and her dislikes, why wont i point out my opinion about the charachter i dislike )

rere14: You're right. In a spots like this it is so hard to be neutral.

@Simpleplan: Agreed.^^

Not at all. An eye-for-an-eye, Regina will get what's coming to her soon.

^^^ agreed

Honestly everybody is saying they want Gina to suffer, ist nearly getting your ver soul sucked out enough!?

gina was going to kill Charming if it wouldn't have been for Henry! She said it herself: I should have killed you when I had the chance! But now is not too late!

And that was her reaction to a person who saved her jeopardizing his own life! just to see what kind of creature gina is...

He didn't even want to save her, Emma and Snow told him to. In fact he specifically said something along the lines of "No it's not our problem it's her problem." He didn't care to save her at all and would've let her die if not for Snow and Emma, how noble.

Oh, so Snow and Emma deserved to be lost and taken away from their family? Gina tried to kill his daughter - Emma and his wife Snow. And instead of getting revenge he saved her life! That's noble! Too bad gina's soul is so dark she does not appreciate all the good things she has received fro life and still receiving, all the chances she gets.

Never said that. Actually it was the dementor thing that time, he should've gotten mad at it. Only because his wife and daughter told him to, he wouldn't have otherwise. She's revived more bad than good, it makes one bitter.

Charming said: I should killed you myself!
If Regina didn't crush him on the wall, he would strangle her.
I don't blame Regina. I would do the same, if someone want to kill me.

he's not like that! he's better than that. You're confusing him with gina...Not everyone reacts like that..

Of course he was mad! Who wouldn't be? if the woman you saved despite the numbersous time she has hurt you in the past might have cause the death of your daughter and true love?

But gina's reaction was pure evilness and ingratitude! kill the one that saved you risking his own life!

@ YvonneHe said he wished they didn't help her...

Yes but the loneliness ceased upon fining Henry. Gina's still continues and worsens as the series goes on.

@TVfan Exactly! Double standards in full effect. I would totally fight back as well.

He and the town's people all behaved savagely and tried to kill her. Most of the characters in the show act like her, needing vengeance and what not.

She didn't cause it, she wasn't the one who grabbed Emma's ankle and pulled her into the portal, nor did she shove her. In fact Mrs. Parrilla said Gina felt some what guilty about the whole thing.

Not really. As stated above she didn't push them. It's Gold's fault for seeking vengeance and summoning the thing that pulled Emma down. And no one died in that scene.

He had every right. I don't care how tragic Regina's past was. After everything she's done, he had the right to. End of story. She's acting on revenge and it's taking over her. A person like that should be put in a mental institution, not BELLE.

Don't get me wrong. Regina did the natural thing and fought back but I still think Prince Charming was in the right. After all she's done it was a natural reaction.

When did she kill him? Did I miss something?

(The malice in these picks are quite obvious. They are a little bit obnoxious. Have you ever read fairytales? Bad things happen to good people all the time. That's pretty much the driving force of fairy tales)

^I was wondering that too. Charming is awfully spry and coherent for a dead guy.

^^ Thank you someone else who realizes the malice in some of the picks here! I agree with all of that. After all there'd be no story without the villain doing his/her job as the villain and preformingg evil deeds.

yeah! I just don't like gina as a villain. Gold is an awesome villain though!
so, he first has to die like Graham did and then talk about it? the evil intention doesn't count I see.
and yes... I've seen some VERY VERY malicious picks lately here too!!

Well it's a good thing she's trying to turn good then.

Yeah I know, we all should stop with them. Because this has been going on for way to long now. I think we can both agree it's time to stop.

I don't know why you asked it anyway to be honest.....

^ Around this time, there was this huge fan vs anti thing going on. It was asked mostly out of spite. A lot of these were made from both sides.