이 질문에 답하기

원스 어폰 어 타임 질문

Do 당신 think that the indiscriminate 사랑 for evil characters might have tragic consequences?

I'm sure everyone heard about the tragedy that happened in Colorado because of someone who liked too much an evil character.

James Holmes burst into a movie theatre in Aurora, Colorado and fired indiscriminately at audience members at the new 배트맨 film.

Unwilling to spare anyone, he killed 12, among them a six-year-old girl, Veronica Moser. He wounded 59 others, including a three-month-old baby.
After his arrest he told police that he was the Joker, Batman’s nemesis. Beyond that, nothing.


Read more: link


 Do 당신 think that the indiscriminate 사랑 for evil characters might have tragic consequences?
 Princess-Yvonne posted over a year ago
next question »

원스 어폰 어 타임 답변

jay1023 said:
No, I happen to 사랑 Rumplestiltskin, but would never imagine stealing babies, 또는 anything like that. It's not the show's 또는 the character's 또는 the actor's fault that the person is psycho. They are simply a part of the story, and have never told any member of the audience to follow in their footsteps. If some one chooses to act upon these behaviors it's their fault, they're sick. It's in way shap 또는 form the shows fault
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Exactly my point.
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
*
I know
jay1023 posted over a year ago
*
Like I said before I for one am not justifying anything I just sympathize and understand. Apparently 어치, 제이 is the same. In all honesty this 'debate' must be getting way too heated if someone who doesn't even like Gina is sticking up for her.
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
zanhar1 said:
I'm just gonna post our prior discussion (hope 당신 don't mind);

Me - So your personally attacking me now? Do 당신 really think I'm gonna go out and shoot people because I like defending Gina when 당신 (pointlessly) insult her. How about 당신 be 더 많이 open minded.

That masaqure and my debating are on two totally different levels! I'm not gonna go cut someones 심장 out to justify Regina lol. And who exactly ate 당신 to say what's right and wrong, someone's a bit full of themselves!

당신 - killing is wrong. being cruel is wrong. justifying murder and cruelty is wrong. Who says it is wrong?! not me, but the laws of humanity. or.. do 당신 think is right?!
I'm not against liking the way an evil character is show in a show. I just think that justifying and liking, admiring them is so wrong.

I'm not attacking you, just giving 당신 something to think about.

Me - Justify and preforming the act are on whole different levels. Honestly I'm not trying to justify anything, rather I feel sympathy and have an understanding as to why she became that. Laws of humanity varies from country to country. Honestly I have no opinion on right and wrong, it is what it is.

Well can 당신 do so in a less... offensive way please?

To add: No offense but this is a bit ridiculous, it seems like you're taking one man's actions (and possible psychosis, keep in mind he is supposedly a schizophrenia) and stereotyping all villain lovers. As someone who always likes the villains (in shows, books, ect) this really kind of offends me. I think I speak for all, if not, most Regina (or any other villain) 팬 when I say; we're not just gonna shoot up 랜덤 buildings to 'justify' villains. Villain 팬 do have morals 당신 know, we know it's wrong to take a person's life. I for one am not trying to justify their actions I just sympathize and understand their motives. I'm obsessed with Bellatrix Lestrange and I haven't harmed anyone at all because of it. Loving villains doesn't make the tragic consequences, the person doing the loving is what makes them. When making theories like this one mus consider a few things; does the 팬 in 질문 have an prior mental instabilities, does this 팬 get too crazily obsessed, is he/she lonely, does he/she have a rough past, ect.

Wrapping things up: To put it simply no, liking villains doesn't make people want to kill 또는 harm anyone. Everyone is different, maybe some people like the man in Colorado will go to extreme to prove their devotion but I would assume most people won't go that far.
select as best answer
 I'm just gonna post our prior discussion (hope 당신 don't mind); Me - So your personally attacking me now? Do 당신 really think I'm gonna go out and shoot people because I like defending Gina when 당신 (pointlessly) insult her. How about 당신 be 더 많이 open minded. That masaqure and my debating are on two totally different levels! I'm not gonna go cut someones 심장 out to justify Regina lol. And who exactly ate 당신 to say what's right and wrong, someone's a bit full of themselves! 당신 - killing is wrong. being cruel is wrong. justifying murder and cruelty is wrong. Who says it is wrong?! not me, but the laws of humanity. or.. do 당신 think is right?! I'm not against liking the way an evil character is show in a show. I just think that justifying and liking, admiring them is so wrong. I'm not attacking you, just giving 당신 something to think about. Me - Justify and preforming the act are on whole different levels. Honestly I'm not trying to justify anything, rather I feel sympathy and have an understanding as to why she became that. Laws of humanity varies from country to country. Honestly I have no opinion on right and wrong, it is what it is. Well can 당신 do so in a less... offensive way please? To add: No offense but this is a bit ridiculous, it seems like you're taking one man's actions (and possible psychosis, keep in mind he is supposedly a schizophrenia) and stereotyping all villain lovers. As someone who always likes the villains (in shows, books, ect) this really kind of offends me. I think I speak for all, if not, most Regina (or any other villain) 팬 when I say; we're not just gonna shoot up 랜덤 buildings to 'justify' villains. Villain 팬 [i]do[/i] have morals 당신 know, we know it's wrong to take a person's life. I for one am not trying to justify their actions I just sympathize and understand their motives. I'm obsessed with Bellatrix Lestrange and I haven't harmed anyone at all because of it. Loving villains doesn't make the tragic consequences, the person doing the loving is what makes them. When making theories like this one mus consider a few things; does the 팬 in 질문 have an prior mental instabilities, does this 팬 get too crazily obsessed, is he/she lonely, does he/she have a rough past, ect. Wrapping things up: To put it simply no, liking villains doesn't make people want to kill 또는 harm anyone. Everyone is different, maybe some people like the man in Colorado will go to extreme to prove their devotion but I would assume most people won't go that far.
posted over a year ago 
*
" I have no opinion on right and wrong, it is what it is." OMG! if 당신 think that KILLING is not wrong... I'm ceasing all contacts with you. it would be nice if 당신 stopped replying to all my comments. I really feel attacked. I want to think I'm free to post a thought on a picture 또는 pick without 당신 coming and responding to my comment, strating over and over your point, forcing it on me.
Princess-Yvonne posted over a year ago
*
Uh, I think that what zanhar1 meant was that she is not judge nor jury, and neither are u, and btw,u are telling us ur opinion as well... So, and I'm sure that the post w ONLY to say an opinion. Not attack u. I'm not trying to either
jay1023 posted over a year ago
*
When the heck did I say anything like that!? I have no opinion on the matter means I don't think it's right nor wrong. I think it depends; is it self defense is it out of cruelty is it the death sentence, just depends. I feel really attacked as well, that makes two of us. On that one picture when I said 'I think shes cute ^_^' I wasn't responding to 당신 I was making my own separate comment, 당신 responded to me. I'd like the same freedom, but I can't get that now can I? I'd like to view a Regina picture without having to see hate 코멘트 또는 insults, it kind of ruins the fun of the spot when your 가장 좋아하는 character keeps getting bashed at every turn. I'd like to post Regina pictures without 당신 coming and posting hate comments. And I'd like 당신 to stop shoving your Regina hate in my face and stop trying to force me into hating Regina. I reflect the attitude I'm given, in the beginning I thought 당신 were a really respectful debater, so I was respecting 당신 and then the insults started coming, I tried to put up with it and continued debating with no insulting, but there is only so much I can take before I need to stick up for myself. What I'm saying is; My appoligies this 토론 got way out of hand, I got offended, and when I get offended I have a tendency to strike back so to speak. If 당신 wanna start over I'm all game for it; I don't 'try to force my opinions on you' 당신 don't 'hate on Regina at every turn' 또는 something like that. Some kind of agreement. @Jay thanks ^_^
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
TVfan97 said:
I'm with jay1023 and zanhar1. I 사랑 디즈니 villains and i 사랑 Regina, but that doesn't mean i'm a bad person.
I am a good person who thinks that villains are 더 많이 interesanting then 히어로즈 in 영화 또는 stories. I would never REALLY kill anyone.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Same here ^_^
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
*
sure! I 사랑 many villains too. not Regina though. But I feel is HUGE DIFFERENCE between liking that fictional character and justifying his crimes!
Princess-Yvonne posted over a year ago
*
^^ Indeed
zanhar1 posted over a year ago
robinsparkles97 said:
I am a Colorado girl, so this definitely hit 집 for me.
But in my opinion, that guy was off his rocker.
I 사랑 Rumpelstiltskin to itty bitty pieces, and I do try to justify his actions a lot, but I would never go into a theater in glittery makeup and stab people.
Same goes for Regina. She is one of my absolute 가장 좋아하는 characters, but I'm not going to dress up like her and cut people's hearts out.
The shooting in Aurora really did hurt me personally because it had to do with fandom, and fandom is supposed to take 당신 away from reality and to your fairytale land. And this jerk came in and took that away from these people. That's like someone dressing like Regina and shooting me during the OUAT premiere 또는 something. It's horrible, and it's the main reason I hate this guy.
But he just decided to go about it this way, I don't think many other people would. I think he had issues, and tried to resolve them the wrong way.
I could go on about this for days, but I won't. Just...I 사랑 everyone in this fandom, Dearies and Evil Regals especially included, and I know 당신 guys would never do that.
*sniffs* okay, I'm done now.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »