what do 당신 think is better negima the book 또는 negima the show

I think the book because it has 더 많이 action and its really interesting.

the book, the show pales in comparison.

The one I saw was a complete mess. It started out good, 의해 following the basic storyline of the book, only in 랜덤 order and with small changes.
That is, until about halfway, when they started making big changes (to fulfill there own sick fantasies) and skiping important events from the book. They even skiped a, now major, character altogether. 의해 the end, they had completly stoped following the book and made up there own storyline that was complete bullshit. And they even gave it the worst, most cliche villain ever: The Devil. (WHAT!?) There was never any mention 또는 even hint of The Devil before, why is he suddenly the main villain? It was so bad it was almost unwatchable.

Also, the book is still ongoing. So.... yeah.

I haven't read the 망가 yet, but I have watched the show and I like the show a lot more. :D