What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Leyton vs. 브루카스 My BLP opinions! #8- Both Peyton & Brooke made mistakes within the triangle. But Brooke took her mistakes too far.

67 fans picked:
Agree!
   61%
Disagree!
   39%
 kellyerin87 posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

9 comments

user photo
maryksand picked Agree!:
I agree, even though by "too far" I don't mean that she did something completely out of line and unacceptable. She was on the edge of it though. Like when she mocked Peyton's mom's deaths. You just don't do that because of a guy, especially not to your friend. She kissed him when she was dying, yes, and she was honest about it with you. No right to say something as cruel as that.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kellyerin87 picked Agree!:
^ Yep. Some of Brooke's comments, and using Lucas all for the sake of intentionally trying to hurt Peyton were just over the line IMO.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
bbiatch picked Agree!:
Brooke was more inmature about it.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
TheBoySawAComet picked Agree!:
mmm hmmm
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
energizerbunny picked Agree!:
To me most of Peyton's mistakes were accidental/unintentional. Not all, but most.
Alot of Brooke's were just plain immature and inexcusable.
Being a complete jerk to Lucas, then asking him out just to get to Peyton
The takeout box scene/quote
Slapping Peyton for admitting her feelings
Egging Peyton's house
Continually calling her a slut, whore etc.
Blaming Peyton for EVERYTHING that happened between her and Lucas
Making fun of Peyton's dead moms etc.

That surpasses Peyton's cheating to me. At least Peyton was completely apologetic and didn't do it again. And no I don't count 3x16 kiss as cheating. Yes, she should've told Brooke but that's not a reason to go all psycho.
This is a reason why it's hard for me to completely love Brooke's character. She's a great person overall, but her immaturity in high-school irks me :/
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
xoheartinohioxo picked Agree!:
Agree to a certain extent. Specifically Brooke making comments about Peyton's mothers.

I know we'll always disagree on this, but i feel Brooke was justified in slapping Peyton in 3x22. If my best friend confessed what Peyton confessed... I can't say I would limit myself to just a slap.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
carambolas picked Agree!:
Considering Peyton never set out to hurt Brooke, while Brooke repeatedly tried to hurt Peyton.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
jemgrl323 picked Disagree!:
I don't know if I'd say Brooke made "mistakes." Not because she never did anything wrong... she did plenty of things wrong on the show and did things wrong within the BLP triangle. But a mistake refers to a person doing something they didn't mean to do. I feel like everything Brooke did that was negative was intentional.
I think Peyton made mistakes, and she made some really big ones... but they were because she was caught up in the moment & wasn't thinking straight. That's not acceptable AT ALL, but it's something that often leads to a mistake. Brooke did things (like bringing Peyton a "leftovers" box, going on a date w/Lucas when she knew Peyton had feelings for him...etc) that clearly involved some premeditation and planning. They seemed like intentional actions, not mistakes. I think she "took things too far" but I don't think they were mistakes.

But I also think Peyton did hurtful things to Brooke that weren't mistakes. They both were kinda terrible to each other at different times (sometimes as mistakes, sometimes not).
But mostly it just felt like Peyton kept messing up while Brooke was intentionally being a bitch. What great friends...(*sarcasm*). I love Breyton but sometimes I really wonder if I'd like them if they didn't have such awesome chemistry.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Derena_Brucas picked Disagree!:
^ agree. Peyton made bigger ones!
posted over a year ago.