이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

Hermione covers up Ron and Harry. Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone.

I could never understand this. When the teachers find Harry, Ron and Hermione with the uncounsious Troll, Hermione blames herself so as to protect Harry and Ron. She says that she came looking for the Troll in order to confront him and Harry and Ron saved her. That is very so stupid in my opinion. How wrong would it had been for her to say: "I was crying here because Harry and Ron upseted me after classes, I hadn't heard about the Troll, so Ron and Harry came looking for me and saved me".I really never understood the motives behind this.
 Sophia21 posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

deanna_xox said:
same i think it would of been easier her telling the truth but then ron and harry might of got 더 많이 points taking of off gryffindor and then everyone would be upset so i think she chose wisely and she must be a good friend after that :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
uuh, McGonagall would have been a real b**** if she took points from Ron and Harry for having had a fight with Hermione.
Sophia21 posted over a year ago
*
Yeah i know but she would proberly of done it for being disloyal to a family/team member
deanna_xox posted over a year ago
ScottishChic said:
Yeah, I always thought that Hermoine blaming herself was weird. But she was kind of trying to make friends. I dont know if that scene is exactly like it is in the book but Ron goes and days its no wonder she hasnt got any 프렌즈 and that was her way of saying she liked those two. That sounds cheesy but hopefully 당신 know what i mean. xox
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah but she could have done what BellaCullen96 said. And seeing as Hermione is quick thinking she should have come with that excuse. that was one of those "WTF?" moments.
Sophia21 posted over a year ago
BellaCullen96 said:
Yeah, I watched the movie just last night, and whenever I think of that part I always wonder why she doesn't say that. She didn't have to say that she was crying, to save her the embarrassment of explaining why, she could just have said she was in the bathroom and Harry and Ron just came to save her.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »