I think Hermione lacked the open mind for Ravenclaw. She wasn't able to learn creatively 또는 think outside of the box (which is why she and Luna were so against each other). Besides she said she though "books and cleverness" weren't as important as "friendship and bravery" :)
I know no one knows what house the New Generation ended up in, but everyone says Albus would be in Slytherin. I always thought he'd be in Gryffindor! Why would he be a Slytherin? I don't think he had any Slytherin traits, AND he was only WORRIED about getting into Slytherin. Wasn't Harry worried too? And look! He didn't get put into Slytherin!
Whoa, that was kinda rant-like..I'm done with ranting for the day.
Well, I personally think Albus would have fit in either Slytherin 또는 Gryffindor. I really have no idea why I think Albus would do good in Slytherin; it's just a feeling I have.
@spottedpool. You're thinking of Albus Dumbledore. And also, you're thinking of the fourth FILM, not the book. I have read the 책 over twenty times and I do not remember that line ANYWHERE in the book. It is in the film
I think for the most part, they were put in the right places. Although, Peter Pettigrew is debatable. He was cowardly throughout most of what we've seen, but I also have to say it was a little 메리다와 마법의 숲 to 가입하기 Voldemort to start with- well, brave, yet not. If 당신 get what I mean.
He did some 메리다와 마법의 숲 things for cowardly reasons. I don't know.
And not just because he became a Death Eater. He seemed sort of Hufflepuff-ish at Hogwarts, but his Slytherin-esque traits really came into focus later on.
Well, Hufflepuff is known for loyal, hard-working, honest people, although they also take in "the rest" as well. I can't say Peter was loyal 또는 honest, hard-working is debatable. Slytherin's known for being cunning, achievement-oriented, shrewd, and ambitious. He can be cunning, and he could also fit in the "they hesitate before acting" category, but I don't know.
Hermione has the brains for Ravenclaw. Loyaty for Hufflepuff. Courage to be in Griffindor But she would not be a Slytherin because she is muggle born and Salazar made it clear that only pure blood are to be in Slytherin, most of the time, a few half bloods are in Slytherin, ok occasionally a muggle born would be sorted there but that is a rare thing. But with Hermione defiantly not a Slythein.
if u ask me,i would say that wormtail should have been in slytherin agreeing to the fact tht he is a "good for nothing" and yeah he did show some bravery 의해 joining voldemort but tht reasonably isnt enough for a gryffindor secondly i dont see any traits of intelligence in cho chang tht makes her a ravenclaw.also she was loyal to harry as she dint wear tht "support cedric diggory" batch even though he was her boyfriend so maybe hufflepuff was gud for her and luna was very 메리다와 마법의 숲 she should have been in gryffindor well thts wat i think
Sirius and James have the Slytherin bully quality they are both very ambitions. Wormtail is not cunning 또는 ambitios like a slytherin, he lacks the brains for Ravenclaw, he is definatly not 메리다와 마법의 숲 enough for Gryffendor, and Hufflepuff takes the rest thus he belongs.
I agree with most of them. but i don't think james and sirius should be in slytherin. they both hav bullying qualities - that is true, but one doesn't doesn't land them in the house. Sirius hates slytherin and the sorting hat takes his own decisions into consideration. and sometimes potter can be so thick and daft that he cannot even think straight without tripping over whatever is in front of him; he isn't very cunning. and both sirius and james have the reckless, trouble-making qualities that all gryffindors possess
in my opinion the Harry Potter character that was placed in the wrong house is Harry himself,but if 당신 asked the hat to put 당신 in a specific house 당신 can't technically argue with that.... :)
Cho: Hufflepuff Cedric: Ravenclaw Wormtail: Slytherin Luna: Gryffindor Hermione: Ravenclaw (although she does make an excellent Gryffindor!)
posted over a year ago
Why does everyone think Cho should have been a Hufflepuff? Not trying to be antagonizing, I'm honestly curious. She really doesn't seem like a Hufflepuff to me.
I agree. Hufflepuffs always strike me as weak and pathetic (some of them anyway). Slytherins are resourceful, cunning, ambitious and power-hungry. I don't see Wormtail being any one of those things. If he truly was in the slytherin house, he'd be an insult the whole house
^ Hufflepuffs aren't weak and pathetic, they're honest and hard-working; there's a difference. Hufflepuffs are decent, upstanding, working class citizens; Slytherins are white 칼라 criminals.
YO! I'M a Puff! >:( Anyways, I don't have anything against any of the Houses and fine of being sorted in any one. tho i do prefer Hufflepuff. Anyway, I thought he should be a Slytherin because he became ambitious after betraying his friends. Puffs don;t betray, Hence the loyalty.
Hermione should have been a Ravenclaw, and Pettigrew a Slytherin. Not because he's bad, and Slytherins don't go to Heaven where the 천사 fly; he possesses many of the Slytherin traits: he's ambitious, in his own way, and he's certainly cunning. In fact, I'd say he's one of the most cunning characters in the series; I think he intentionally puts on a lot of that weak, pathetic demeanor to make people underestimate him.
Pettigrew was really the only one I can think that didnt deserve the house he was in, but I dont really know if he could have been in SLytherin either. He was cunning, yes, but he lacked any serious ambition (that I noticed)
Peter Pettigrew should've been in Hufflepuff. He was evil as an adult, but when he was younger he was just an awkward wizard who looked to stronger wizards like James, Sirius, and Lupin for protection. He lacks the bravery of a Gryffindor, the intelligence of a Ravenclaw, and the cunning of a Slytherin. Hufflepuff is the only house left. It's where kind and loyal people go sometimes, but it can also be the house for people who don't fit into any other category. The Sorting Hat said it himself, Gryffindor wanted the bold, Ravenclaw wanted the wise, Slytherin wanted the ambitious, and Hufflepuff took all the rest.
But he had to be in Gryffindor otherwise he never would've been close to James, Lily and the others and probably wouldn't have had the opportunity to betray them. Then there wouldn't be a series.
To me, Peter Petigrew should be in Slytherin. He didn't do a 메리다와 마법의 숲 thing in his life to deserve to br in Gryffindor, and he betrayed James and Lily just to save himself.
Am I the only one here who thinks Luna should be a Hufflepuff? Her loyalty, open mind, serenity, and uniqueness would be 더 많이 than enough to make her one...
Remember, it's 더 많이 about the traits 당신 value, 더 많이 than the traits 당신 have. This is why Petter Pettigrew is in Gryffindor. And why Luna is in Ravenclaw. The traits 당신 have still factor in though.
As Dumbledore points out in the last book, they Sort early - possibly too early. So maybe Pettigrew did show early signs of courage which were crushed out later in life. Maybe Snape did possess enough of the Slytherin ambition and cunning to drown out other traits, 또는 maybe his courage was hidden at the time since nothing had triggered it. There's no indication of Cho's intelligence one way 또는 another. Hermione was nearly a Hatstall because the Hat was considering Gryffindor and Ravenclaw - this is revealed on Pottermore.
