이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

Were 당신 disappointed with anything in the Deathly Hallows 2?

The first big thing that i was disappointed with was the garbled speech on the Elder Wands allegience, in the book and in my head i imagined it to be an Epic and cocky 'Gotcha and in your face' speech. I thought this was one of the best twists and they didn't do it justice.
Also poor Freds death???? Did i blink and miss it? And the scene where he is dead, definately a lot 더 많이 moving in the book.
Oh and Harry snapped the Elder wand in two? wtf? Didn't he repair his own pheonix feather wand?
I know people 사랑 Hermione but another thing that annoys me is how they make out its Hermione with all the clever ideas. Yes she is smart in the 책 but so is Harry. In the 책 Harry was the one who winged the escape plan out of Gringotts and yet they make out its Hermiones idea(again).
*
I agree about the elder wand and Fred's death, but it isn't the first time Hermione's been given someone else's dialogue 또는 been made out to be the only smart one so that doesn't really bother me anymore.
D_J267 posted over a year ago
*
I was mostly angry about the dialogue between Harry and Voldemort being shortened as well as the one between Harry and Dumbledore. The not fixing of his own wand and also the last battle being with no one around like that is really lame why did they change that?
alharr34 posted over a year ago
 lakota_spirit posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

Vixie79 said:
I was pretty happy with it. The only thing I wanted 더 많이 of, was about Snape and Lily in school. Also explaining a little better on why they weren't 프렌즈 anymore. They kind of left it in the air a bit IMO.

Other than that, I was happy with it. The small changes really didn't bother me. I felt the over all message of the book was still there.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yea, i don't think people who haven't read the 책 would really understand Snape and Lilys relationship.
lakota_spirit posted over a year ago
*
Yeah, but I figure if they don't read the 책 they really don't deserve to understand. I mean, you're going to get 더 많이 from 읽기 the 책 than watching the movies. I see the 영화 더 많이 of the physical reactions of the charaters to situations as where 당신 get the inner thoughts and feelings of the characters in the 책 as well as the reactions outside of their own head. Also, I was kind of disappointed in Voldy's and Bella's death. They were kind of like...BLAH...I also didn't like how Molly delivered the line, it didn't have any gumption in it at all. Oh well I guess...lol.
Vixie79 posted over a year ago
bri-marie said:
Some of the changes I was slightly disappointed in (Fred's death and the lack of why Percy was there; Harry snapping the Wand before fixing his own; skimming the surface of why Severus became a Death Eater and his feelings for Lily; the duel between Harry and Voldemort). I didn't really care for the special effects either -- although my dad pointed out that those were probably due to the movie being in 3-D.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
hollywoodluv said:
I wasn't really disappointed, I was OK with any changes made but now feel there should of sorta been a part 3 so we could have seen the deaths and 더 많이 that was in the book but 사무용 겉옷, 전반적인 I was amazed 의해 how good it was, it has been out 5 days and i have already seen it twice.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
No i wasn't disappointed with the film 사무용 겉옷, 전반적인 just a few bits, they should have definately 스플릿, 분할 it into 3.
lakota_spirit posted over a year ago
lunaginny said:
that 통스 lupin 프레드 and snape die
and 드라미오네 dose not happen

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LifesGoodx3 said:
I just wish the final duel would have happened in the Great Hall, with all around to see it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I totally agree also with the dialogue between Harry and Voldemort
alharr34 posted over a year ago
*
I thought about that too, the whole Harry/Voldemort duel was a proper disappointment.
CherSummer posted over a year ago
*
Same :0)
lakota_spirit posted over a year ago
*
I agree. And it was missing Harry explaining WHY Voldemoret was clueless...A very important part of the book imo.
jewlbear posted over a year ago
xcrazygirlx318 said:
I was happy with it, but I agree about the deaths. They also left out Pettigrew's death, which I thought was a shame; the whole movie seemed a bit rushed if I'm honest.

They even left out Teddy! The only mentions he got, were at the beginning, and it wasn't him specifically, and then in the forest Harry says about Remus' son, but his name isn't even said. Harry wouldn't even find out that he's a God-father in the films.

I appreciate that they have to cut a lot down from the 책 to make the 영화 work, but maybe there should've been a Part 3, to look at things in 더 많이 depth. Apart from that though, an amazing film: 5 stars :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah, Teddy would have been nice to have in there too.
LinaHarrow posted over a year ago
*
Yeah… I think it is sorry that they left out Teddy, I had really hoped to see him.
CherSummer posted over a year ago
danfan1 said:
No i was not disappointed with the 초 part of the deathly hallows. i nearly cried
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LinaHarrow said:
They could have done a lot of things better, but I really wasn't disappointed with anything. I loved the movie to death. Especially the Luneville moment. But if I had to change anything, I would give Fred's death 더 많이 attention: a longer scene, a fuller shot, an inclusion of Percy, etc.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
delenadarti said:
Romionie's kiss
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Gyroball13 said:
I was disappointed 의해 how like almost all the main characters died.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yeah, but that's in the 책 too. Filmakers can't change that.
BrittaniiFTW posted over a year ago
BrittaniiFTW said:
I feel as if the movie should've gone into 더 많이 detail about the torture Draco went through the most. I feel as if they did Snape justice, but 프레드 could've had a little 더 많이 time on the screen, but 당신 have to keep in mind that some people (like the twins and Percy) weren't in the 영화 as much as they were in the books, (I believe Percy was only in the first movie amiright?) so the filmakers can't help if they gave some characters smaller roles earlier on, not knowing that they'd be so important later.

All in all: Fav Harry Potter movie !
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
alharr34 said:
I totally agree with 당신 I was really angry they cut that dialogue between Harry and Voldemort was cut short. I was also angry that the dialogue between Harry and Dumbledore was cut short and the not repairing of the wand. Also wasn't the final battle in the great hall with everyone watching not in front of the school with no one around?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
adultswimperson said:
1.I was disappointed with 프레드 dying even though they never showed him getting killed.

2.The fact Harry broke the wand instead of keeping it for himself to fix his own.

3.When Snape had to die when he loved Harrys mom the whole time.

4.When the fight at the 성 turned out to be 더 많이 of a drag than I thought with most of the wizards dying, even the battle on the bridge with the giant trolls and the concrete gladiators didn't stop them.-_-
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bakes2389 said:
Everything 당신 said disappointed me as well. Also, I really wanted to see Teddy. I 사랑 how the movie just skips over his character and doesn't describe him at all. And the ending in general missed so much detail; it bothered me. I also was mad that the 초 part didn't bother finishing the plot about the Thief. It is so built up in the first part, officially never explained, and then dropped altogether in the 초 part.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
MrsSiriusB said:
Agreed. The things that bothered me the most was firstly, the fact that Hermione came up with the dragon plan. She is very clever, but she has too much of a rational mind to EVER even think of that. Secondly, the deaths. For Fred's death, they only show like a 2 초 snippet where they show a Death Eater torturing 프레드 then Voldemort spoke to the entire school. I hated that. Remus and Tonks' was acceptable because Harry wasn't actually there to witness it (neither was he there for Fred's death in the film, but oh well) but it was absolutely pointless (and really sad) to see Lavender die. On that note, did she even die? Probably since the giant was well, literally eating her skin. But it wasn't very necessary. Lavender's annoying, yes, but she did not deserve the death. What else? Hmm, yes, Harry did not shout Expelliramus and Voldemort didn't say Avada Kedavra. That was a very important highlight in the story because it showed how Voldemort's curse backfired. Also, where the hell was the audience?

So, yeah, these are things I didn't like in the movie. But the things I liked (The Epilogue, Snape's memories, the trio together after the war was over being my extra favorites)outweighs the things I didn't, so I'll say I loved it. It was a satisfying and terribly bittersweet ending to such a beloved series.

Harry Potter forever
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »