Does anyone know whether 또는 not Lily had any feelings for Snape?

I think at first Lily had feelings for Snape because they did spend a lot of time together, he was the one who introduced her to the magical world, and she did her best to protect him from the Marauders. However, I think after he publicly refused her help when James levitated him upside down and with his continual involvement in interest in the Dark Arts and Deatheaters along with his Slytherin friends, Lily seemed to grow afraid of him and what he was turning into. After his public refusal of her assistance, I feel that she 로스트 all respect for him and any hope, and possibly even desire, of a relationship with him. Furthermore, Sirius states that James did become 더 많이 mature in his later years at Hogwarts, and I believe that his maturity is what eventually led Lily to him romantically.

IMO she really liked him and cared for him but only as a friend, they knew each other since they were kids and were very close, so Lily indeed had feelings for him but never in a romantic way.

Then when he called her a mudblood she felt betrayed and very hurt, I don't think she ever forgave him compleatly, also I think she was very sad when she found out he was now a death eater, so I guess she then only thought of him as someone she once cared a lot for, I don't think she ever wished him anything bad,

And with James she stared to going out with him in the last 년 of hogwarts, so she wasn't Snape's friend anymore, so James didn't have to do anything with them not being 프렌즈 anymore, in a side note I'm almost certain Lily always felt something for James and Snape knew it even if she didn't admit it, another reason why Snape hated James so much

I think that Lily felt very strongly for Snape in their earlier years, since they spent a lot of time together and Snape was the first person she could truly talk to about the magical world. I also think the fact that James and his 프렌즈 bullied Snape made their relationship stronger becuase Lily felt 더 많이 inclined to protect him. However, I believe that she only really felt friendship for him because if she really did 사랑 him, I don't think she would have gone with James.

Plus, the fact that Snape resorted to dark magic and had new Slytherin 프렌즈 drove Lily away and to spending time with James and his friends. I think this showed Lily how different the two boys were and I believe she may have been scared of what Snape was becoming. I think she may have felt guilty at first as well, but she did try to make it work, but Snape just seemed to grow 더 많이 distant and drawn 의해 evil. In a way, it goes both ways. Snape was bullied so that could have drove him to evil, but he could make his own choices. :)

Only platonic I think. She might have been intrigued 의해 him at first, but I don't think it lasted.

JK Rowling confirmed that Lily only had emotions of friendship towards Snape, but she could have grown to 사랑 him if they'd remained friends.