해리 포터

이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

DH 영화 : How Severus is to learn about the trio's whereabouts (in the Forest of Dean) so that he could 앞으로 them the Gryffindor Sword ? (The Silver Doe chapter)

In the book, Severus is given this information 의해 Phineas Nigellus Black's portrait Hermione has in her bag. However, as there is no Phineas in the movie version, how would they integrate this into the script ? Who/What must have tipped Severus so that he could give them the Gryffindor Sword ?

I have a small idea about it but I'd like to hear your opinions and ideas.
*
Good question.
bri-marie posted over a year ago
*
Agreed
Kylie90210 posted over a year ago
 LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

IzzyOzera said:
In OOTP Dumbledore spoke to Phineas' portrait....
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Darkshine said:
After Hermione called Phineas for help he came back to the office and told Snape about their whereabouts.
Ah,you mean the movie version.


No idea. :(
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Kylie90210 said:
Not a clue, I'd 사랑 to hear your idea!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
OK, my idea is that at some point, Scabior 빙어, 빙 어 a woman's perfume in the forest. Maybe he reported the fact to Severus that gathered this was Hermione and therefore where the trio was. Just my idea, I'm aware it may be full of flaws.
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
*
Better than anything I've come up with! Explains why they put in that 랜덤 perfume scene.
Kylie90210 posted over a year ago
unholytrinity said:
Great question, im pretty sure, they will supress that fact, and make it like... if dumbledor always knew where they were headed.. and told snape.. 또는 something like that... i never really realized this difference between the movie and book..
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yes, but if they suppress that fact, that still doesn't explain how Severus knew about the trio's location to 앞으로 them the Gryffindor Sword ! Plus, it appears in Severus' memories : that's an important point because that's how Harry realizes that the silver doe is Severus' patronus, and that the Potions Master's patronus was a proof of his feelings for Lily. I don't think how they could avoid this part...
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
*
to be honest, they avoided alot of parts they shouldnt.
unholytrinity posted over a year ago
emilykuru said:
ur guess is right!

u know when hermione comes out once she stands face to face with Scabior but he does not realise she is there becoz of the enchantment. but she tells harry he smelled her perfume- its a very odd thing to be concerned of and since hermione is concerned,there certainle will be some turning point in the story. maybe as u said he will smell the perfume in the forest of dean and tell snape in his office-later snape consults dumbledore and goes with the sword! thats the only possible explanation!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
That's a good point of view.
unholytrinity posted over a year ago
*
yeah thnx!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
*
thnx!
emilykuru posted over a year ago
*
Yes, I don't see any other reason. As 당신 put it, being concerned about perfume in such a place was odd enough to draw my attention.
LadyNottingham posted over a year ago
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!