OKAY I HAVE NEVER READ ANY OF THE HARRY POTTERS EXCEPT THE FIRST ONE BUT PEOPLE SAY THAT HARRY POTTER IS AS GOOD AS TWILIGHT SERIES IF 당신 HAVE READ BOTH TELL ME IF THIS IS TRUE AND IF I SHOULD READ IT.

Cards on the table-- Harry Potter is not the best series ever written. For that matter, neither is Twilight.

I have read all of the Harry Potter series. I have read bits and pieces of the first Twilight book, and I have seen the movie. I have also talked to several 팬 of the Twilight series who have both criticized and raved about the series.

For young readers, Harry Potter is a gem. It combines genius storytelling with likable and believable characters in a world that is completely its own. The Harry Potter realm is full of adventures and odd interesting things to explore. In that sense, Harry Potter is a great book for readers of any age, not just for youths.

On the other hand, Twilight is a very targeted series at young preteen girls. Therefor, its subject matter is prone to limitations and cliches. This is not necessarily a bad thing. The story of Twilight has several merits, and follows the classically effective Aristotillian way of storytelling, much like 별, 스타 Wars and Lord of the Rings. However, I must say that some characters in the Twilight series are not quite up to the interesting, complex standards of the characters in Rowling's series. Most of them are fairly straight-forward, and often some of them are painted as idealistic visions of harlequin romance. Not to mention the feminist criticism I could delve into-- but won't.

Comparing the two side 의해 side in as objective a manner as I can muster, I must say that I would recommend Harry Potter over Twilight any day.

PS: Please don't type all in caps. It's a bit distracting, and it feels like you're yelling all the time.

Harry Potter as good as the Twilight series? Are 당신 kidding me? Harry Potter is way better, I've read both and 당신 can't even compare them. Twilight is horrible compared to Harry Potter, in my opinion.
There's not a thing in which Twilight is better than Harry Potter. Unless 당신 are only interesed in romance and only romance, I assure 당신 Harry Potter is way better.

want my advise about it. 당신 need to read both and deside for yourself. everyone is goin to have their own thoughts about the books. if 당신 ask me they are the same. they both have romance. they both have adventure. and they both have hottt characters.
just read them yourself. then 당신 will know the answer for your question.

Are 당신 kidding??? Ok Twilight freak here but HARRY POTTER IS SOOOOOOOOOO WAY BETTER than Twilight i have to admit
Harry Potter is my obsession!! if 당신 are prepared to have an obsession than 당신 must start to read it if 당신 don´t, don´t try it please cause once 당신 read Harry it´s FOR LIFE... just like Twilight!!
I 사랑 Twilight, i even have 문신 about it but HP it´s the book of the books

I absolutely 사랑 twilight but I've been a Harry potter 팬 longer and Harry potter is CLASSIC. Well, it will be a classic lol. It deserves all of its popularity, great plots, great characters, great fantasy. Should 당신 read the Harry Potter series? Yes, yes 당신 should!
Then again, that's totally biased, isn't it... if 당신 think 당신 might like wizardry, magic, teen issues (like relationships, friendships), strong plots and mystery, go for it. [what have I missed?...]

I personally think that harry potter is a wonderful book and Twilight is too but the constant talking about it wears it down until 당신 have complete loathing for it!
I also believe that Bella can moan on and on about not being pretty etc. The main objectives of the 3rd and 4th film is to sleep with edward so i think that it isnt a great example to the 11 년 olds and up! Plus there has been lots of examples of girls getting morbidly obsessed with the series and locking themselves away!!!!!!
Personally i think twilight has gone a bit too far!

I absolutely adore Twilight and Harry Potter, but in my opinion, Harry Potter is a bit better than Twilight, not only because it is better written, but also because there are 더 많이 questions, mysteries, loose ends that need to be tied up, etc. There's also a lot of battle of good vs. evil, and while I understand that Twilight also has that, it's 더 많이 prominent in Harry Potter. There's still some romance, though, admittedly, a little less, and there's plenty of action, humor, and suspense. Even if some people don't think that Harry Potter is as good as Twilight, 당신 should read it anyway! Why waste time debating whether 또는 not 당신 should read it, just do it! It will better 당신 mentally, and 읽기 is fun! So I say read it, then decide for yourself which series is better. Because they're both two very good series, and you're missing out if 당신 pick favorites.

Well... I've never read Twilight, so maybe 당신 put this on the Twilight vs. Harry Potter club. But please read Harry until the very end.

Its actually bette than twilight 판타지 wise!But its nowhere near as romantic!the best 책 are the 6&7 even if u dont read the rest read 6&7 they are soooooooooo gooooooooooooood

the wierd thing is, i havn't either but my brother says its like the best book EVER, well one of them.

I haven't read the 책 either,i have only seen the movies...but i might read it:D
I use to 사랑 harry potter a lot 더 많이 when i was younger...but then twilight came along^_^

I like the harry potter series better and I do think Harry potter is a much better book, but I do like twilight a lot too, I say 당신 should give it a try is good book, twlight and harry potter are very different acttually I get mad with all this people arguing wich is better and all that, read them maybe you'll like them and if 당신 don't well at least 당신 can say 당신 read them and say why 당신 didn't like them ^^

omg, harry potter is so much better, and i 사랑 twilight, so that means it really is good, its get better with each book, my favs the 3rd and the 5th, and well all of them, but them specially, check them out

O.K so i've read both and I personally think HARRY POTTER is better and my BFF thinks so to like HARRY POTTER is funny,sad and sometimes 당신 get really worried so 당신 ave to read all te books

I hope 당신 read them

I have read all of Twilight and Harry Potter and in my opinion, Harry Potter is better than Twilight, but that's probably just because my best friend loves to rave about Edward. But Harry Potter is a good read.

If you're looking for 판타지 then 당신 should read both Harry Potter and Twilight... they're both excellent 책 and definitely worth the time...
(especially the Twilight series :) )

In my personal opinion, they're both pretty good.

Honestly speaking, Harry Potter is waaay better than Twilight. The characters are developed better and the story is evenly paced with a wonderful conclusion. Twilight is very slow, until 당신 are near the end of each book-then the action comes in for the lat of it. If I had to choose, it would be Harry Potter hands down, even though the last Twilight book was pretty good.

Short and sweet:
Harry Potter is a 더 많이 adventure and 판타지 story that some young adults can relate to (except the murderer wizard coming after you).
Twilight is a 더 많이 romantic and is for young adults who really want 또는 can relate to finding that special someone... dare I say soulmate...

Harry Potter series are better than twilight series... i have read both of them and i really dont know why twilight makes people crazy... i read them so i can have an opinion about it but i didnt like it

I think Harry Potter is 믿을 수 없는 and classic. I mean, hey, it was placed as number two on the list of "Top 101 책 당신 have to read before 당신 die". So, I think that speaks for itself. But like someone mentioned previously, the only way to know is to decide for yourself. :D

I have read both and seen the most recently released 영화 on both. Both are great! But I wouldn't advise 읽기 the 책 before the 영화 b/c the 영화 toys with what they like and if 당신 read the book and then watch the movie it makes the movie less entertaining.

Personally I think that Harry Potter is so much better than Twilight.

And think of it this way: the Harry Potter book series was so good, that they made a movie out of it.

I've read the Twilight series once and Harry Potter multiple times. In my opinion, HP is better and there are 더 많이 책 to read, for enjoyment.

I've read both,and I 사랑 Twilight,but HP is MUCH better!
I think 당신 should read it

Harry Potter is way better then Twilight. if 당신 enjoyed Twilight, then 당신 should enjoy Harry Potter :)

i loved harry Potter but i liked twilight too!of course i like a bit 더 많이 harry potter coz i think it's better written with 더 많이 interesting story and plot and coz i actually i grew up with it... i read the first book when i was really young and now after so many years it's over! well we (me and all the first hp fans) have memories from it and our childhood includes hp too! what i want to say is that i saw harry potter from little 11year-pld child in the 9 3/4 platform to 17year-old teen-adult beating voldemort! and in the whole time i was aging the same time with him!! i 사랑 twilight too, but it's smaller saga, it has sth different to say and i read it now, being quite old... however, honestly, read it!!;)

Harry potter is BRILL if not better than Twilight
but is not as romantic as it. Its 더 많이 magical and are the best thing 당신 will eva read!! My mom said she'd burn them because I read them so much!!"£$DDD LOL

I have read HP and Twilight saga.
And I can totally say that,HP is %100 winner.believe me.
I'm a totally bookworm and I like series like HP and Twilight but including aaaaaaall of 'em,HP rockz anyway.
because HP has a lot of secrets and It' geniousy.But twilight seems so much poor according their authors's 글쓰기 style.
and trust me,HP is much 더 많이 creative.wampires are,you know...ordinary..
I like Twilight but HP rockz my world,so,I think 당신 should read it.

i 사랑 both dont get me wrong! but, (and this doesnt say TOO much) atm on 팬팝 twilight has 26,888 팬 wheras HP has 17,910...:) (tells u sumthing tho!) deff read them they are great but i deff 사랑 twilight much more! :)

HARRY POTTER IS BETTER!!!!

Harry Potter's one of those rare series which actually deserve to be as big and famous as it is. Unlike Twilight. Sure Twilight's ok but it isn't anything compared to Harry Potter. I'm a 팬 of both 의해 the way.

i think 당신 should it took me 3 months to read them all (kept dates of how long it took me to read them added them up) and found that i was 더 많이 또는 less intransted in a diffrent world wich i didnt want to leave so i think 당신 should so go for it and enjoy

I have read all of the harry potter 책 and found them the most interesting,fascinating,entertaining and many 더 많이 ings 당신 can add here....

I have read first novel of twilight series and found it something close to good so i left the thought of 읽기 the rest of them some other day
So there is no point of comparing both of them...........

I've read almost all the HP books, and their very good, 당신 should read them, but their not as good as twilight.. but anyways yeah Read HP!

I have read both the Twilight saga and Harry Potter series multiple times. i 사랑 them both. i would recommend both 2 any1

당신 can't really compare Twilight and Harry Potter, i've read them both, and reread them, and i 사랑 them both, very different stories. 당신 should defiantly read harry potter. :)

I personally think both of these series stand out 더 많이 than any other especially Twilight. They are two diferrent stories but both are written so that is very clear about the emotions and the actions which take. I think 당신 should read them. I have read Twilight and Harry Potter and I never get tired of them 또는 get bored of 읽기 the same conersations and dialogues. I think if a person who like to read adventure, romance and mystery, 당신 should read Harry Potter. I personally like the 책 'goblet of fire' and 'deathly hallows'. It is a series that I will ner stop reading.

Hi,
(I'm french so excuse me if I don't speak well)

I rely 사랑 twilight, but my 가장 좋아하는 is Harry Potter !

I read both series and i think that they r both good;
Harry Potter: is good because its not from one person's point of view,(like in twilight, everything is how bella sees it)HP is in general, and its also funny, i mean it has alot of humor in it and a lot of adventure.

Twilight:i 사랑 twilight because of the storyline,i mean the whole vampire, werewolf thing is my thing, and the whole thing about how bella falls in luv wid a vamp is just amazing! i don't know how to say it but i just think its brilliant!!

okay i read the HP bks long 이전 and i don't remember it well, i read Twilight saga recently and am still crazy about it!! SO ALL AM SAYING IS THAT THEY ARE BOTH GREAT SERIES AND U SHLD READ THEM AND CHOOSE FOR UR SELF!!

I have personally read both the Harry Potter series and the Twilight Saga and I believe that they are both excellent series. 당신 defintely finish 읽기 the Harry Potter series.

I am a Twilight 팬 and I'm not really into Harry Potter (I just really like the films) The 책 are good but they aren't my cup of tea. It depends on what 당신 mean 의해 as good as. If 당신 mean adventure, mystery and magic then they are both equally good. If 당신 are into a good romance then don't bother with Harry Potter until the 5th book (but then it won't make much sense and the romance isn't that interesting anyway)and reread Twilight instead :) If 당신 want a well written book (gramatically that is) then read Harry Potter.
If 당신 have read the 1st book and 당신 liked it, carry on reading, it can't do any harm.
Enjoy...I hope I helped :D

is ok!

I've read some of the 코멘트 made 의해 other people and really its up to 당신 whether 당신 wanna read Twilight 또는 Harry Potter 또는 hell read the both...you might like them both 또는 hate em, that be up to you.

This is what i have to say:
I admit I have my own preferences in both of the series, ive read (own both series on dvd/books) and watched the dvds over a zillion times lol...but they are two very different stories and yeah ive compared them to see what similarities and differences...each author writes differently and we have to remember that...

J.K Rowling and Stephanie Meyer are two very differnt talented writers of storytelling: adventure, romance, drama, relationships between characters, good vs evil, wizards/witches, vampires/humans, magic, real life issues blended into the story, plus of course a new world to explore: both are different.

I do like twilight but i feel that the characters are just underdeveloped and i disagree with some aspects of it but other than that i dont have a problem with twilight. (im looking 앞으로 to see how they manage to renesmee on film tho) and i quite enjoy the romeo and juliet theme/jacob black and a new spin to 늑대인간 and combining Native American vibe into the story which i think is a nice change.

Harry Potter, i like it for its magic, story and i find it very compelling to read as a whole series; 당신 can see it in your head. I also 사랑 how in some ways there are issues that are brought up: prejudice against people/blood status, racism, abuse of power, corruption, family and love, political issues, normality, oppression and overcoming odds..i could go on but there are so many that has a touch of depth 또는 well connection to real issues/themes that we go through while being in a totally different world and whatnot...

I would say Harry Potter. Twilight is a'ight, but it gets too... Ick. And the characters are SOO annoying!!!

Harry Potter can tend to drag in places, but once 당신 pull through the rough patches, it's really honestly good.

I dont think, 당신 can compare those 2 series.
But 당신 really should read both and then 당신 schoud decide which one 당신 like better.

Twilight is absolutely rubbish!
I know many 책 that are better than Harry Potter but o boy Harry Potter beats Twilight by, ALOT! In my opinion.
당신 should definately read the rest of the Harry Potter books, they're very enjoyable =]

ok i have read both Harry and the twilight books, and honestly there is no comparison at all Harry Potter is in a class of its own, who ever said it is as good as twilight is down playing jk rowlings 책 completely.
Don't get me wrong i really like the twilight saga but they are just a variation of so many other vampire related things such as Buffy, Angel,The Southern Vampire Mysteries which TRUE BLOOD is based on (the similarities between them and twilight is uncanny and they were published in 2001 and twilight was published in 2005!!!)and other 책 through the yrs
Jk Rowling however created a whole world for her wizarding community tieing in effortlessly with the real world making everything interlink creating a multitude of characters most of whom end up having a reson to exist within the world while making us connect on some level with them all.....twilight, not so much creativeness going on its just like an evolution of the vampire romances seen in so many other things....so very pradictable......but enjoyable non the less.
Harry Potter is 1 of them one-off strokes of shear genius that comes about once in a blue moon..........Twilight is just a 더 많이 well written vampire romance than some of the others, and there is bound to be many 더 많이 vamp variations to come but there will never ever be another HARRY POTTER!!!!!

I really 사랑 both of them but my loylaty will always lie with the Harry Potter books!

my friend, I have read all Harry potter 책 and all the twilight saga 책 (twilight, New moon, Eclipse, Breaking Dawn)...In my opinion, even if I am a big 팬 of twilight, Harry potter is better written book...Generally it doesn't focus on feelings for as much time as twilight does...Twilight is a very good book too, but I think Harry potter is a better organised book and if 당신 start 읽기 it 당신 will see that 당신 won't be able to stop...Personally I recomend 당신 to read both series so that u can form your own opinion...If u don't have the money to buy every book u can download them in several websites...If 당신 don't know any site just 구글 "free download books" and 당신 ll get lots of them...Hope I helped you...

I have read both the series and they are both AMAZING! i am pretty sure that if 당신 like Twilight then 당신 will like Harry potter. But if 당신 are not into stuff like mythical creatures and magic and stuff like that, then don't waste your time.. I actually like harry potter better because 당신 can relate to the characters better and it explains stuff so much more.. but twilight is my 초 fav..

I'm not going to lie I 사랑 Harry Potter over Twilight just because in the Hp book in seems like it has 더 많이 of a pot and the the Arthur of Twilight rushed sometimes and it wasn't the best of her work.But 당신 should totally read both if nothing else 당신 can say 당신 gave HP a try,right. Both Wirters are awesome and both series are amazing in their own ways!

ok I 사랑 both and have read both but I can't chose cause I get caught up in them when I read them so it usually like the 1 I read last. this is a really hard decision 4 me 2 make but I think I like twilight better because I feel 더 많이 emotion in it. I literally sit there with the book open and yell at the characters. I get 더 많이 wraped into twilight one 일 it was sunny outside but I read twilight 4 about an 시간 and I steped outside and said where's the rain. but I sugest u read harry potter it is really gud and interesting. best 2 not compare it 2 twilight cause they have absolutley nothing in common

I'm sure Harry Potter is A LOT better than Twilight, and I'm not the only one who says that. HP has got amazing characters and J.k: rowling is a very writer; she knows what she's doing when she puts someone in danger, 또는 whatever that happens in the books. Twilight cannot be compared with it, god.

I really can't say which one is better.Twilight was just amazing but Harry Potter was fantastic too.I've read both series and I loved them.Well I loved all the HP 책 but I didn't like Breaking Dawn (twilight 4).And although I'm a huge Twilight 팬 I think Harry Potter was slightly better for this very reason.I suggest 당신 read it because you'll 사랑 it!!!!!!!!

Harry Potter is as good as the Twilight Saga(saga means 4.) 당신 should read them.

Yeah, Harry Potter is WAY better. 의해 the way, learn how to turn your caps lock button of it's really annoying

I'm gonna make this short and straight to the point:

Harry Potter >>>> Twilight

Harry Potter is much better.

i say everybody should read harry potter and twilight at least once. read it. there good books!!!

I have read both, and Twilight is an excellent story, over the top. But, Harry Potter ranks with the classic stories, this is a LEGEND. It is outstanding, the 영화 do not touch the brilliance of this story. I would say it is a bit unfair to compare the two stories Twilight and Harry Potter - they are different and both are great, and both should be read...

well i have read both but me being a 팬 of both it is hard to say but if i had to choose it would be harry potter it is better but ive been a 팬 since i was 8. But 당신 should still read twilight because they are good.

U SHOOD DEFINITELY READ DA REST OF THE BOOKS!! THERE JUS AS AWESOME!!

Yes, they are both equally as amazing!! i couldn't pick my favourite between them- they are fantastic and i've read both series of 책 multiple times. but many people have different preferances. 당신 might like harry potter 또는 twilight better than the other one. everyone's different but i 사랑 them both equally! :)

Both of the series are great. The 책 are well written, have depth, and really stir up the imagination. As for movies, Twilight sucked. I'm hoping New Moon will be different, better. Twilight was the worst movie I have ever seen. Harry Potter movies, on the other hand, are brilliantly directed, wonderfully acted, and extremely believable. I often talk to people who aren't there (no, not schizophrenia, just fun fantasies) and I always imagine I'm either talking to people from Harry Potter Land, 또는 from Twilight. In all fairness, Twilight is wonderful, but I stand loyal to Harry Potter.

당신 should but still twiliglht is better 당신 should also read kissed 의해 and angle and the hunger games it is just like twilght but wight no 뱀파이어 i mean the umm 사랑 삼각형 thing

I have read both, Harry Potter and Twilight, and I have to say that Harry Potter is a lot better than Twilight! When I read Harry Potter I just get into the story and can't stop reading, the characters and plot are a lot 더 많이 interesting. Twilight in the other hand....it is boring as hell. I have tried several times to read the complete series (I try to understan all the fangirls)....but I just can't! Every time I read it I get so bored that I get sleepy, and at the end I start 읽기 something else. In my opinion, the Twilight story is totally absurd and without nothing special, I still can't figure out why is it so famous!!!

So, to make this shorter: Harry Potter is miles better than Twilight

i have read both. they are both well written and there is something about them that makes 당신 not want to put them down. i find other 책 may have a better story line but harry potter and twilight keep 당신 hooked. I like harry potter better though because it is a 더 많이 interesting story... 뱀파이어 and humans in 사랑 just doesnt add up to all of the excitement happenin in the harry potter books.

*sigh* Here we go again. I'm really sick of these 질문 I will say just few things. If 당신 liked Twilight 당신 will fall in 사랑 with Harry Potter.Harry Potter is a UNIVERSE. Twilight is just another book. That's my opinion. And . .please . .PLEASE . .could 당신 stop yelling about Twilight ? My ears hurt ,my brain hurt as well. Thanks.

Harry Potter is way better.I 사랑 Twilight dount get me wrong but Harry potter has it all suspence,romance and theyres always something in the 책 that cant make 당신 stop reading.When i was finished with the series i cried cuz i wanted it to keep going,i wantend another Harry Potter book.But i know theyres not going to be another book like this one.Twilight is not as good,but its not bad but 당신 cant compare it to Harry Potter.

Here's a tip: If 당신 ask harry potter 팬 if they think the 책 are good, THEY'RE GOING TO SAY YES! Just a hint.

i have read both Harry potter is slightly less epic but just as good!

totally read it

I have never read any of the books, but have seen all the movies, except of course Deathly Hallows I'm waiting to see that and then read the books. :) I like both Twilight and HP.

Its better then Twilight

I have read both series and personally Harry Potter is the much better. To me the twilight series ran out of steam. It was as if she ran out of story idea. If 당신 want a read that is action and keeps 당신 thinking Harry Potter all the way.

I 사랑 both.

I used to 사랑 Twilight(always 사랑 Harry Potter), but one 일 i reread the book (Twilight) and couldn't finish it. I said to myself why did 당신 ever read this.

when i was younger I was a HUGE twilight series fan. I had all of the books, t-shirts, ear rings, ect. But then I read the Harry Potter 책 and they BLEW MY MIND!! IT IS 의해 FAR THE BEST SERIES I HAVE READ! It is better then twilight in so many ways, but just to name a few. It has 더 많이 depth and a much 더 많이 develpoed storie line. jk rowling was able to create an entierly new world that is nothing any one has ever seen, but stphen mayer only added on to the world that we live in now. so i say read the books!! and trust me 당신 will not regret it.

Someone brought Twilight up to Harry Potter standards?! Twilight does not compare to Harry Potter in any way shape 또는 form! The only thing they share is Robert Patterson (cedric diggory/edward cullen) --- "Harry Potter is all about confronting fears, finding inner strength, and doing what is right in the face of adversity. Twilight is about how important it is to have a boyfriend." - Stephen King

Twilight and Harry Potter are their own thing. they are very different so it is hard to decide which is better. Twilight is 뱀파이어 and 늑대인간 and Harry Potter is witches, wizards, brooms and other magical stuff. So i don't know. That's all i can say

look guys harry and edward both r very good while their stories both r just fantasies which actually dosent seems to exists

Yes Harry Potter and Twilight are both very good but 당신 can't compare them as each are good in different ways. When 당신 read the first Harry Potter book did 당신 like it? If 당신 did then read it's sequels as the series gets better and better with each book.

Everyone has different opinions, but if u think about it; both series wouldn't be that famous for nothing would they? So if u like twilight i'm pretty sure u would like Harry Potter too. Although they're both very different stories.

It depends...
Do 당신 want to fall in 사랑 with a series and be totally obsessed (Harry Potter) 또는 like a series cause it is really 인기 at the moment (Twilight)
That is as unbiased of an answer I can give...

I think that both Twilight and Harry Potter are good in different ways. I personally prefer Harry Potter, just because I 사랑 the idea of magic. READ ON! :)

The first book was O.K but the rest kinda sucked.:Y
영화 where worse this is just my opinion.

i have read alll the harry potter 책 and the twilight 책 and i think they are equally as awesome, i wouldnt compare them though because they are entirely different worlds, but ya i 사랑 them just the same and i defiantly recommend both the series!