이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

Who thinks DH kind of lacked emotions in some scenes?

당신 see I couldn't help but become a little startled for example when Ron was not screaming and hitting the 벽 while Hermione was being so badly tortured. The very same when Harry learned that his wand was broken. And again the very same when Hermione did not cry at all after Ron left.
 delamico posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터 답변

bri-marie said:
I did. I was actually fairly angry at the way they handled Ron leaving and Hermione being tortured. It was almost as if these things didn't bother the characters. In the book Ron practically 로스트 his mind when Hermione began screaming whereas, in the movie, he just kinda stood there. Hermione didn't speak and cried for days, but in the movie she was just kind of "whatever . . ." >.<

In the book, there was at least week (or maybe it was a few days) between when Harry broke his wand and when he saw the doe. In the movie, he found out his wand was broken and, within an hour, was following the doe. It makes sense, since they chopped out so much time, that they didn't focus on that in order to keep the movie going.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I absolutely agree with you. And there's also Kreacher's Tale.. He was.. well obsessed with Regulus in the book but here.. he was just..kinda.. not so interested at all..
delamico posted over a year ago
*
I don't think In the movie she was "whatever..." she did actually cry a few scenes when it was just her and harry, 당신 could tell she was very upset.
VintageSmile posted over a year ago
*
But it was nothing like in the book. I meant, compared to how she was in the book, movie watered it down extremely.
bri-marie posted over a year ago
VintageSmile said:
Yes! Some scenes were less intense in film, I kinda felt cheated. The first 30 분 was filled with emotion, for me, but then it kinda went down hill.

So, yep, the only problem I had was that it was that it really and truly did lack emotion.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »