이 질문에 답하기

해리 포터 질문

was lily really ment 4 james 또는 severus?

should lily have picked severus insted? i dont know and thinking aboul it makes me feel depressed,i cryed wehen i first found out! POOR SEVERUS!!!!! AND LILY!(she had 2 choose)
 was lily really ment 4 james 또는 severus?
 harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
next question »

해리 포터  최고의 답변

lilith84 said:
I am not sure she deserved Severus. I mean, if she was a real friend, she would have forgiven him. I know that what he did was horrible, but they were teenagers, and teenagers do stupid things, especially under influence of strong emotions. Lily knew Severus better than anyone, she should have known that humiliating him in front of him worst enemies might not end up well. I am not justyfing Snape, what he did was horrible, but 프렌즈 stick together, they forgive and accept people for who they really are. I don't know if I would like Lily to end up with Severus, he deserved so much better. As for James, I don't really care about him.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
*blushes* um... thanks? ;)
lilith84 posted over a year ago
*
oh yup. here comes the girl that always knows what to say and that aint no sarcasm.
vskparaimer posted over a year ago
*
Best answer :-D
nene72 posted over a year ago
next question »

답변

Hermione30 said:
No, Lily was really meant for James.That's why they ended up married.If they didn't get married, Harry wouldn't have born and Voldemort wouldn't have died.And James loved Lily and she loved him back.So, there's no doubt about it.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
good point
harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
*
he might be a child of severus and lily. snape is 더 많이 talented than james
bhavvishyya posted over a year ago
StichxAngel4eva said:
well... she ended up with James.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
supose
harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
butterflys said:
Lilly should of chosen Snape. I mean Neivle could be the Chosen One and kill Voldemort latter on. I mean Snape would of probually have loved Harry if he was his and Lillys. i think it would of been cute. :)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
neville would have died because harry mother put a protective charm on him so the curse backfired but voldemort had divided his soul into seven that is why he 로스트 his body
krambally posted over a year ago
*
she didnt put a prtective charm, she sacrificed herself and nevils mum would have done the same so etherway, bacicly the same stoy
harrypotter-rox posted over a year ago
*
Why wouldn't she sacrifice herself; she isn't Voldemorts B-itch of a mom. Excuse me while I die because i can't deal with myself
butterflys posted over a year ago
krambally said:
lily was meant to be with james because when harry looked into snape's pensive he saw that james used to always taunt snape lily used to help him and they always used to friends.until harry asked lupin about it and he said when they were 17 they started to go out
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
lillymango1 said:
i think it would of been james becausesnape is a deaffeater now and voldamort killed harrys family and in potter puppet pals snapes vdairy *snape:i went to go ask lilly potter out today but she stood me up *something around those words * (back to harry ) harry: my mom was the best LOL
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Teamdamon33 said:
James!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
luinwen said:
James, he loved Lily and I'm sure she loved him too, Lily only loved severus as a friend, and when he called her mudblood was the final straw, a lot of people don't like James and they will say snape, but I don't think Lily would have loved him if he didn't have changed, we only saw him for a brief moment and yeah he was being an as, but he was 15 he was immature, he didn't liked snape and lets be honest most people are really mean sometimes mostly to people 당신 don't like, also Lupin also said Snape cursed James whenever he could so that type of things were "normal" between them

James wasn't a bad person, he was loyal, loved his 프렌즈 and lily, he was a great wizard, he tried to give time to escape to lily and harry, so yeah I think Lily choose well

Also yes if Lily and James haven't married there wouldn't be Harry, everything happens for a reason
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
James Potter= Draco Malfoy just without being a deatheater 또는 a deatheaters kid
butterflys posted over a year ago
*
how can 당신 compare them?, the only thing they have in common is that they were spoiled
luinwen posted over a year ago
*
Hadn't thought about it either till I saw butterflys' 코멘트
nene72 posted over a year ago
Matsy23 said:
no not really shes meant for james O.o
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Gabriel1985 said:
Logically it is no surprise that Lilly chose James ( he had money and looks) but truthfully, the romantic in me believes that Severus would have been better for her.

Yes James Potter was a bully, the worst kind of bully. He bullied people to show off and make himself feel better, he believed that he had the right to abuse people because of who he was, for no better reason than they existed (His words from the book " He exists" ).

In comparison whom did Snape bully? Yes he ridiculed people, but I would like to challenge 당신 to show me one exert from the book where he actually physically hit one of the students under his care. 당신 could make a point that Snape regularly attacked James, but what proof do 당신 have that he was not hexing in self defense? Yea Sirius said that Sev attacked James, but common Sirius is hardly unbiased, he did after all try to get Snape killed.

select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
teenytinybear said:
i am not entirely sure, but if she didn't end up with James then Harry would 더 많이 than likely not exist. If she had Harry with Severus than he wouldn't be the hero he is today with defeting Voldimore.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »