해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 1000 Reasons Why Harry Potter Is Better Than Twilight

lauracullen66 posted on Aug 27, 2009 at 01:29PM
just start at one and see if you can get 1000
save

해리 포터 대 트와일라잇 54807 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 11701-11750 of 54807

over a year ago FredWRules said…
gemonk, if you're online, please go to this website:
link
over a year ago boolander25 said…
Well I have to go to bed now. Night!
over a year ago harrypotterbest said…
night! don't let the wrackspurts bite!
over a year ago FredWRules said…
night boo!
over a year ago lemony44 said…
worried
VERY MANDATORY!!!! GO FAN THE REAL JK ROWLING CLUB! STEPHANIE MEYER HAS 4682 FANS AND JK ROWLING HAS 3339!!!!!! MANDATORY!!
 VERY MANDATORY!!!! GO 팬 THE REAL JK ROWLING CLUB! STEPHANIE MEYER HAS 4682 팬 AND JK ROWLING HAS
over a year ago thepuppetmaster said…
worried
Okay, I joined fanpop soley to add my own comment to this forum/thread thingy. Please ignore my bad grammar and spelling further ahead and note as well that my g is faulty. Also, I have read both series all the way through, and HP multiple times. And I'm a 17 female, so I fit perfectly in Twilight's target audience.

Harry Potter is better than Twilight. While that statement in itself is an overwhelming positive, we HP fans are forced to explain why to the crazed Twihards that dare challenge the epic saga.

-Let's start with the fans while we're here:
~Twilight: mostly teenage females. Twihards, seriously? I use the term and laugh. Twichurch? Scary. I'm pretty sure Meyer wanted to expound Mormonism, not start a creepy cult. Anyway, while grammar is bad on the internet, mine included, I can't help but notice the abundance of lower case and messed up contractions/spellings. It hurts. Plus, they seemed obsessed over physical appearences, which also concerns me. Finally, they can't come up with a logical debate as to why Twilight is better than Harry Potter without contradicting themselves. If you find one, see me at angelcitystories.deviantart.com. I will test you, and remember, I read the books too. I was one point away from winning a Twilight contest, but I didn't raise my hand fast enough.
~Harry Potter: both genders, and readers from youth to elderly. Yes, we have psychos, but what fan group doesn't? I hate beating people up over their books (and HP followers can get cruel). I do notice we tend to have better grammar and more coherent arguements. Well, to anyone who's read these books anyway. I'm not sure, but I don't think we have a cult. Yet. I'm not joining, sorry. And we have an awesome leader, the woman who spent nearly two decades writing seven totally awesome books (with an "eh" epilogue): JK Rowling!

Which brings me to...

-Meyer vs. Rowling:
~Meyer: She wrote about a dream, and Bella is a Mary Sue. Her writing makes me feel like I'm being talked at, rather than being immeressed into a new world, she's repetatitve, and her Mormon beliefs are startlingly, brutally visible. While I have nothing against dream writing and Mary Sues, she should've done some research on her vampires and werewolves. It is sad that these ancient mythical enemies have been brought to the level of Tinker Belle and...I can't come up with a good comparision for the wolves.
~Rowling: Her writing is simple enough for younger readers, complex enough for adults, and, if you care to really dig in, riddled with wonderful symbolisms and meanings, and even tiny details nobody would ever notice. Her Christian views aren't really visible, hence all the church issues, but if you want to find them, you will. If not, then fine. Rowling does her research, making a world hidden in the folds of our own, adding rich details to an awesome mythology mankind already created. And her werewolves and vampires? While vampires are never directly shown in the books, in HP1 people think Quirell had a run in with one in some disant part of the world where dark creatures exist. Notice: vampires are dark creatures, as are werewolves, and they apparently can really scare people. There are probably other refs but I'm too tired and lazy to lean to where my books are stashed to check. Werewolves: Lupin. He is a tortured human who depends on a potion to keep him sane. Rowling uses him as one of many examples of prejudice, but she lets him some short measure of happiness in his family-Tonks and Teddy-before he is killed. I loved Lupin way more than I care about Jake Black and his gang.

Now, on to character comparisions:

-Harry vs Edward:
~Edward: sexy, immortal, and girlaphobic until Bella, it seems. He is probably meant to be sexual purity of some sort, or maybe temptation. I don't know. Meyer's "sex before marriage is wrong" symbolism confused me to the point of saying "How can Ed have sex anyway, if his body doesn't have blood or nerve impulses?" Anyway, Ed comes off (to me) as an abusive, childish, Tinker Belle vampire who wants to marry somebody he just met and wants to kill.
~Harry: His parents died to save him, an evil Dark wizard wants to kill him, he is an Horcrux, and he is either seen as a hero, deranged, liar, cheater, beloved, angsty, young, irresponsible, rash, loyal, Dumbeldore's man, brave, stupid, brave and stupid, or any of these above. He is willing to die for the entire world, and does for awhile, he lets Ginny go so she can live her life without being in danger, he has problems, huge and small, fictional and real, and he is flawed. He is almost real enough to knock on my door and ask if I have a fireplace (which I don't sadly. Though it might've saved me from trying Floo Powder). He is not one dimensional.

I will write more soon, but I have my own novel that I've been laboring over for three years now. I want it to be as good as HP, though that bar is set high. I have a LOT of work to do on it, and its sequel.
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
^ THIS.

and morning all :)
over a year ago FredWRules said…
morningtude :D
over a year ago Accio_Pandorica said…
smile
Morrrrrrrrrrrrrnnnnnninnnnnnnnnggggggg :) x
That was siriusly good, Jane Doe :D
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
Wow thepuppetmaster those are great reasons! We had about 2600 before be gave up and turned this into a chat forum, as you can see. :D

Your novel sounds really interesting, who would you cite as your inspirations, aside from Ms Rowling, of course.

Im almost ashamed to post my fail-excuse for ff, when we have a novelist in the room. :)
Hope you do stick around though :D
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
@lemony: Yeah, it was a Littlest Pet Shop toy. :P And the t-shirt depicts the most wonderful alternative ending to Twilight.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
DID YOU GO TO THE LINK GEMONK?!?!?!
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
What link? I already joined the Rowling club, if that's what you mean.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
nooo... THIS LINK:
link 471 946 /im -go i.. .gh t
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
Oh... is that yours?
over a year ago FredWRules said…
noooooo... that's someone elses. dammit, the link didn't work. 1 sec.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
link
:D
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
*drools* Wait... you cried seven times when Fred died? PFFFFT. I cried 13 times when Spike died! :'(
 *drools* Wait... 당신 cried seven times when 프레드 died? PFFFFT. I cried 13 times when Spike died! :'(
over a year ago FredWRules said…
crying
spike dies? D:
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
Oops. You didn't know?????????
over a year ago FredWRules said…
no!!!!!!! *runs off sobbing over the loss of her two favourite people/characters*
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
Don't worry, Andie. *pats back* He comes back!!! Ahahahahahaha, gotcha!

FredWRules said: .... YOU BITCH.

GemonkDruid said: MUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
over a year ago FredWRules said…
.... YOU BITCH.
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
MUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

... See? I'm psychic.
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
oh dear
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
Whaaaaaaaaaaat?
over a year ago FredWRules said…
Whaaaaaaaaaaat?
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
I repeat: Spike died, but then he came back. That's the funny thing about BtVS. Buffy died, Spike died, Angel died, Darla died, Fred died... but they all came back!!!!
over a year ago FredWRules said…
OMG TWO FREDS DIE!!!!! D: I actually am tearing up slightly right now.
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
But the Buffyverse Fred... is a girl. DUN DUN DUN!!!!
over a year ago FredWRules said…
say whaaaaaaa????
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
I interupt this broadcast to bring you breaking new story: THE WORLD HAS GONE FUCKING MAD


link

over a year ago FredWRules said…
WHAT THE FUCKING HELL IS WRONG WITH THOSE PEOPLE?!?!?!?!
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
ikr! it's sick! and it happens all over! one day I'm going to find a ik banned books list and read everything on it!!
over a year ago GemonkDruid said…
@moomoo: WTF? Ban To Kill A Mockingbird? And not ban Twilight? LOL WTF BBQ

@An-die: Yep, Fred is a girl. Winifred Burkle to be exact. But then she dies and gets possessed by a demon god.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
is it wrong that whenever I'm watching HBP when Draco's in the bathrooms crying I take the chance to stare at his ass?
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
mischievous
^^ nope, he has a nice arse :)
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
^ agreed :D

and also, HOLY FUCKING MERLIN those people are crazy.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
look, here's another nice one!!
sorry, just came back from dinner. I didn't spend half an hour looking for a picture of DT's fiiiiine arse.
 look, here's another nice one!! sorry, just came back from dinner. I didn't spend half an 시간 lookin
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
cool
Are you sure? ;)
over a year ago FredWRules said…
ok, maybe 10 of those 30 mins were spent staring...
DON'T JUDGE ME!
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
*judgejudgejudge*
nah...

by the way, d'you know what I realised this morning in geography? the southernmost point of finland is on the same level as the northernmost point of scotland. O_o.

also, I want to do an experiment :D so can all of you please ask your geography/biology/whatever teachers what they know about finland? I'd love to hear it :D
over a year ago FredWRules said…
sorry... school starts next week, I'll have forgotten by then.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
I just saw a gif of Dobby from Deathly Hallows before he... you know...
and now I'm crying.
I'm bringing tissues with me to the movies.
lots of them.
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
I'll ask again :D
over a year ago FredWRules said…
ok.

I've stopped crying... mostly.
over a year ago mooimafish17 said…
cool
Does anyone watch spooks?
over a year ago FredWRules said…
nope. sorry.
over a year ago FredWRules said…
SORRY GUYZ MUM'S CONFISCATING MY COMPUTER AGAIN!!!!!!
so this is where I say adieu, and bon nuit!
GOODBYE AND GOODNIGHT!!!!
I love you all <3
over a year ago lucius_malloy said…
good night <3